On
15 November 2025 at 18:42 Bazyle Said:
A razor very quickly develops a curved edge during manual sharpening so the fixed holder was probably found not to work very well.
I agree. My experience with cut-throat razors comes from microscopy where they are used to slice very thin sections. Posh folk own microtomes, a machine that holds the specimen and drives the blade. Poor relations use a cut-throat and it has to be VERY sharp.
Best to not let a cut-throat get blunt enough to need a regrind, the trick is regular stropping on a leather belt, with the occasional light touch up grind. Stropping on a belt isn’t difficult, and I don’t see much advantage in a spinning disc.
Two forms of razor:
- Cheaper straight-ground razors. The shape is good for slicing specimens rather than shaving, don’t know why.
- In the past only barbers and rich people bought expensive hollow ground razors. They were much imitated – cheap razors made of inferior steel and crudely hollow-ground, to fool innocents. Birmingham was world famous for cheap nasty tat. I’m not sure a hollow ground razor would strop well on a wheel, might be a good way of spoiling a high-end razor.
We’ve mostly forgotten cut-throat razors were once very expensive and highly desirable. In Victorian times “buy cheap buy twice” was mostly true, so there was a lot of mystique and dodgy goings on. Poor quality blades sold in gilded boxes and sharpening aids that didn’t work that fleeced the unwary hoping to save a few bob. Customers spent good money on gizmos that would magically turn a poor razor into a good one. Or at least keep it a little sharper!
This tool may be a gimmick. Anyone remember when safety razors were sharpened by leaving them under pyramids:

Modern steel and manufacturing methods put the kybosh on razor mystique. A scientifically formulated stainless steel is rolled into a thin strip, which is punched, hardened, and ground and honed to a super-sharp edge by a machine. Hardly any metal in it, so dirt cheap – no need to resharpen them, disposable.
Cut-throats still have a niche though. Anyone use one? And if so how do you keep it sharp?
Dave