Posted by RICHARD GREEN 2 on 20/02/2017 14:03:23:
Hello Trevor,
I would stick with the Pozilock type of collets for threaded shank cutters,
The ER types cant be as secure, just gripping on the shank by friction, I've got some but rarely use them.
I'm waiting to be shot down in flames on this one………………………………………………….
Richard.
Hmmm, I dunno, this is more interesting than it is flammable.
You make a good point, with the collet forced up into the thread, it certainly makes sense that would provide more grip but I find that due to the thickness of the pozilock collets they don't clamp down or "squeeze anywhere near as much as the ER ones do. (I suppose that could be a good thing for the pozilocks' life time)
So maybe the ER compensates for itself in that area. Never had a problem with slipping unless I didn't do it up as hard as I should by mistake. Anyone ever had a problem with spindle collets in that regard? I haven't heard anyone moan about it.
Food for thought, or flaming if someone can contrive a reason, working for Rego-fix perhaps!
Michael W