DTI’s Its all in the name

DTI’s Its all in the name

Home Forums The Tea Room DTI’s Its all in the name

Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #532104
    Steviegtr
    Participant
      @steviegtr

      I needed a finger type DTI. The Mercer one i have is a bit iffy at best. So i bought one off ebay. Just a plain faced cheap item to do what i need . Accuracy not that important.

      It was £16 & in the picture it looked a pretty yellow colour. It arrived in a nice plastic fold open box, with 2 different size dovetail. All good & works fine. But in the ebay pictures it was a plain face. Look at the one i received. You have got to laugh.

      Steve.

      miluloyo.jpg

      #36308
      Steviegtr
      Participant
        @steviegtr

        Recently bought DTI

        #532107
        Ramon Wilson
        Participant
          @ramonwilson3

          Reminds me of the ROLE'Y' (the bottom right hand of the X was missing otherwise identical) watches bought in Singapore in the sixties for a few quid or less – superb looking diving watches that flooded in a hand basin laugh

          Tug

          #532108
          Vic
          Participant
            @vic

            According to an article I read some years ago by a company called Long Island Indicator, Mitutoyo don’t make particularly good indicators anyway. Perhaps your Miluloyo is better, but I doubt it somehow! smiley

            #532110
            not done it yet
            Participant
              @notdoneityet

              Apart from the one expected being 0.001mm resolution, perhaps?

              #532130
              old mart
              Participant
                @oldmart

                If your Miluloyo works ok, it is good value for £16, a real one would be three or four times as much. If you drop it, there won't be as many tears.

                #532141
                Chris Evans 6
                Participant
                  @chrisevans6

                  When I was working I bought Mercer 301, maybe had 4 or 5 over 50 years. Just before I retired 7 years ago I bought a Mitutoyo. If it breaks it will be a £16 job that should see my time out.

                  #532144
                  David Colwill
                  Participant
                    @davidcolwill19261

                    img_20200423_105657.jpgMy Mitutogo cost £7.00 and has held up pretty well.

                    David.

                    #532147
                    Ian P
                    Participant
                      @ianp
                      Posted by Steviegtr on 06/03/2021 13:52:27:

                      I needed a finger type DTI. The Mercer one i have is a bit iffy at best. So i bought one off ebay. Just a plain faced cheap item to do what i need . Accuracy not that important.

                      It was £16 & in the picture it looked a pretty yellow colour. It arrived in a nice plastic fold open box, with 2 different size dovetail. All good & works fine. But in the ebay pictures it was a plain face. Look at the one i received. You have got to laugh.

                      Steve.

                      miluloyo.jpg

                      I've looked inside a few DTI's and in all of them the actual mechanism seemed quite simple, I'm now wondering what the 7 jewels do, have you counted to see they are all there?

                      Ian P

                      #532151
                      Tony Pratt 1
                      Participant
                        @tonypratt1

                        I've wondered for a while why the fakers go to all the trouble of copying Mitutoyo products & then make simple spelling errors. It has just hit me that they don't use our alphabet so to them it all looks good, maybe??

                        Tony

                        #532155
                        Ian P
                        Participant
                          @ianp

                          I don't see any spelling errors

                          Ian P

                          #532157
                          old mart
                          Participant
                            @oldmart

                            The spelling errors are to prevent legal action. Even in China, there have been lawsuites against counterfeit goods. Big names like Kennametal and Henkel (Loctite) have factories there and will protect their copyrights.

                            #532160
                            Thor 🇳🇴
                            Participant
                              @thor

                              I have a Mitutogo, same as David's. Mine too has served me well for almost a decade and sice I use it to compare, not absolute measurements it is good value.

                              Thor

                              #532171
                              Brian G
                              Participant
                                @briang

                                I cant remember where I read this "The main difference between cheap and expensive indicators is the sound the owner makes when they hit a concrete floor"

                                Brian G

                                #532181
                                Tony Pratt 1
                                Participant
                                  @tonypratt1
                                  Posted by old mart on 06/03/2021 17:03:02:

                                  The spelling errors are to prevent legal action. Even in China, there have been lawsuites against counterfeit goods. Big names like Kennametal and Henkel (Loctite) have factories there and will protect their copyrights.

                                  I don't think that would wash, but hey who cares.

                                  Tony

                                  #532190
                                  Steviegtr
                                  Participant
                                    @steviegtr

                                    To be honest i am delighted with it. Well the needle moves when i touch the stylus. I have not stripped it to see if the crown jewels are in there & will not be doing so. I bought it mainly to run on the vice jaws for the mill when fitting.

                                    A few of the good makes i have are so old. They do not always drop back to zero.

                                    Steve.

                                    #532198
                                    Tony Pratt 1
                                    Participant
                                      @tonypratt1
                                      Posted by Brian G on 06/03/2021 17:39:10:

                                      I cant remember where I read this "The main difference between cheap and expensive indicators is the sound the owner makes when they hit a concrete floor"

                                      Brian G

                                      The air was blue when I broke my £100 Compaq DTI.crying

                                      Tony

                                      #532307
                                      David George 1
                                      Participant
                                        @davidgeorge1

                                        An ex work mate borrowed my 0.001 Mercer dial indicator to set up a job on a CNC mill and forgot to remove it from the spindle which started to rotate at 10,000 rpm. It was buried halfway through a 10mm policarbonate screen when I last saw it.

                                        David

                                      Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
                                      • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                      Latest Replies

                                      Home Forums The Tea Room Topics

                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                      View full reply list.