Lathe cutting aggressive taper

Lathe cutting aggressive taper

Home Forums Manual machine tools Lathe cutting aggressive taper

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #851896
    Lee Kennedy
    Participant
      @leekennedy29914

      Evening guys,

       

      any advice on this?

      my lathe is cutting a taper of 0.25mm over a 25mm distance.
      approx half way along the cut there is a significant change in the finish and this is where the cut gets heavier. The finish changes from good to a horrible tearing. It also damages the cutting tool.

       

      i didn’t even attempt to start looking at bed alignment etc. Retreated in defeat for the evening. Seems strange that there’s a definite point where the finish changes and the cut gets heavier.
      I can’t detect any slop or excessive play anywhere. My thoughts are this is more a mechanical issue than an alignment issue.

       

      thanks

      Lee

      #851900
      alecs
      Participant
        @alecs

        Pictures of your set up and of the job and its surface finish are really needed to make any meaningful comments.

        But it’s unlikely to be bed alignment for that severe a taper. Possibly material with a hard spot? Try a test with a different piece of material. Or it could be faulty tool bit. Try changing that too. Or it could be toolpost loose and moving. Or it could be a couple of dozen other things.

         

        #851901
        Bill Phinn
        Participant
          @billphinn90025
          On Lee Kennedy Said:

          this is where the cut gets heavier. The finish changes from good to a horrible tearing. It also damages the cutting tool.

           

           

          As Alec says, we really need more info. We don’t know what you’re trying to cut with what tool nor how you’re trying to cut it, except with a lathe, which isn’t much to go on.

          #851914
          JasonB
          Moderator
            @jasonb

            What diameter are you turning?

            Could well be a tool height problem with work flexing away from the tool and cutting at the unsupported end, this would explain it being a larger diameter at the start of the cut

            But as you get closer to the chuck the work can’t move so you are over/under ctr height and that will give a poor finish and damage the tool.

            #851982
            Huub
            Participant
              @huub

              I assume you cut using the top slide and not using the power feed.

              If you cut using the top slide, than the top slide is not aligned properly, set at an angle or the gibs are not tightened evenly along the whole length of the gib. Try cutting using the power feed and check if it is cutting better.

              If you cut using the power feed than check the gibs. I suspect the gibs are not tightened right (must be lose at 1 side). You must tighten the gib screws (top slide & cross slide) until you feel a very little drag. Than check if it still turns a taper without locking the gib screws.

              Reduce the depth of cut by 50% and check if it gets better.

               

              #852008
              Pete Rimmer
              Participant
                @peterimmer30576

                The first thing I would do is change material. Sudden changes in finish suggest that what you’re turning has a definite change in it’s condition, either by constitution or temper.

                Actually, first of all move the part further into the chuck and go again. if the change of finish moves with the part, then it’s the material. If not, it’s the machine.

                #852026
                alecs
                Participant
                  @alecs

                  And if it’s not the material, a bellmouthed old chuck could be to blame. What type of lathe have you, and how old is it?

                  #852035
                  Dave Halford
                  Participant
                    @davehalford22513

                    Lee,

                    Unfortunately we don’t know,

                    Direction of cut.

                    stick out, tail stock support or not.

                    material, some is dire and won’t turn.

                    tool type.

                     

                    If this is still your GH600 at least it won’t be wear or a bad chuck just yet.

                    #852106
                    Howard Lewis
                    Participant
                      @howardlewis46836

                      As Dave Halford says, we need more information.

                      What machine are you using?

                      We assume that the workpiece is being held securely, and unable to shift.

                      Both work and cutting tool must be held securely

                      What is the material? HSS will have a job cutting hardened steel. You need carbide for that.

                      How does the lathe behave with different material?  It could be irregularities in the material.

                      Is the tool sharp?

                      What sort of tool is is?  A form tool, having a greater cutting edge might be more liable to chatter that a single point knife tool.

                      Is it at centre height?

                      Is it set to present just the cutting point to the work, rather than a long edge?

                      Are the gibs tight enough to prevent movement?

                      Whar depth of cut are you using?

                      What feed rate are you using?  If either of these is excessive for the tool/material combination, you may well have problems.

                      What cutting speed are you using? Too high a peripheral speed will shorten tool life, and cause problems.

                      Finding the answers to some of these questions may help you to find the solution, rather Forum members without the detailed knowledge that only you can have, being on site.

                      Howard

                      #852135
                      Neil Wyatt
                      Moderator
                        @neilwyatt

                        If it’s ‘where the cut gets heavier’ this suggests you are trying to cut the taper all in one go or with a heavy depth of cut.

                        Try keeping the DOC quite modest and cutting the taper in several passes.

                        While the single pass is attractive if you need several matching tapers, you are better off zeroing the cross-slide dial at the ‘finished’ setting and using the cross-slide to apply in-feed. A;ways finish with a second pass to take out any spring in the system.

                        Neil

                        #852138
                        John Hinkley
                        Participant
                          @johnhinkley26699

                          Neil,

                          One of us has misunderstood the OP’s post. I read it as the lathe cutting an unwanted taper whereas your reply assumes that he’s trying to cut a taper. I have just reread the original post and I am still confused, though now tending towards the intended taper interpretation . As so many have said, more information is required before any meaningful suggestions can be made.  If I were to guess, I’d say low tool height and/or a long unsupported workpiece.

                          John

                           

                          #852198
                          alecs
                          Participant
                            @alecs

                            The AWOL OP mentioned bed alignment, leading me to assume his taper was non intentional.

                             

                            #852209
                            Nicholas Farr
                            Participant
                              @nicholasfarr14254

                              Hi Lee, definitely need more info, like diameter and length of material, and if you are using a centre or a steady to support what you are cutting.

                              Regards Nick.

                              #852455
                              Martin Connelly
                              Participant
                                @martinconnelly55370

                                Sloppy spindle bearings letting the workpiece climb over the tool at some point as the forces change? Loose top slide being pushed down as the forces change? So many possibilities when everything needs to be well adjusted on a lathe.

                                Martin C

                                #852460
                                Baz
                                Participant
                                  @baz89810

                                  About time we heard from the OP, his lathe could be anything from a Cowells to a ten foot between centres Dean Smith and Grace, if he cannot be bothered to provide a bit more detail as requested why are you all wasting time speculating on what iffs and maybes.

                                  #852463
                                  alecs
                                  Participant
                                    @alecs

                                    Just another drive by.

                                    #852516
                                    old mart
                                    Participant
                                      @oldmart

                                      I would cut tapers starting at the small end with relatively small depths of cut in several passes until the tool reaches the large end of the taper. That way the depth of cut stays about the same rather than increasing. Supporting the work to minimise any deflection helps. With tapers, it is important to set the tool height exactly on the centreline.

                                      #852523
                                      speelwerk
                                      Participant
                                        @speelwerk

                                        It seems the taper was a bit to aggressive since the OP is silent.

                                        #852744
                                        alecs
                                        Participant
                                          @alecs

                                          Crickets.

                                        Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
                                        • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                        Latest Replies

                                        Home Forums Manual machine tools Topics

                                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                        View full reply list.