problems fixing to wallboard

problems fixing to wallboard

Home Forums The Tea Room problems fixing to wallboard

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #845646
    old mart
    Participant
      @oldmart

      I want to add a small rail to the bottom of the stairs and having no end of trouble. The area where the rail is to fit was covered over when the extension was built, the stairs originally went straight into the living room, but now turn a further 90 degrees left and end in what was originally a small kitchen area. The extension has a much bigger kitchen now. The two way light switch has been moved to the left end of the new wall and I suspect that the gyproc board has a layer of metal foil beneath the surface which not only makes finding the stud positions impossible, but shows up as live electrically over the whole surface. I have tried two different stud detectors without any success, and the separate live wiring detector which works perfectly on every other switch and wire in the house just lights up red. Tapping the wall does not reveal any thicker regions either. I do have a Magnusson bore scope, but it will need a 10mm hole to have a decent chance of looking inside the cavity.

      #845650
      Grindstone Cowboy
      Participant
        @grindstonecowboy

        I use a small, powerful disc magnet on a length of cotton and swing it like a pendulum across the wall, slowly moving up (or down) for a foot or two. Sooner or later, you’ll find it sticks to a spot where a plasterboard screw is. Carefully mark with a pencil. Then try again a bit further up (or down) and find another. Mark again. That’ll give you a pretty good idea of the stud centre, maybe go for a third if it’s way off vertical, as you might have found a cross brace.

        Or, if no success that way, drill a small (~1mm) hole, and if there’s resistance for the full length, you’ve found a stud. Then more holes an inch in either direction until you meet no resistance after the thickness of the plasterboard. You can pretty accurately find the centre of the stud that way.

        The holes are easily filled and touched up afterwards, just don’t do them at eye level.

        Rob

        #845654
        bricky
        Participant
          @bricky

          Mark out where the rail is to be fitted level a centre line the length of the rail.The centres of studs are usualy 400mm centres,tap the wall along the line and one should notice the sound change when finding a stud hammer a nail in along the line and you will find your first stud and the others should be 400mm alongthe line as studs are fitted to plasterboard sizes 1220mm.hope this helps

          Frank

          #845657
          old mart
          Participant
            @oldmart

            Thanks, I will keep you posted on my progress.

            #845658
            Macolm
            Participant
              @macolm

              To explore for battens etc, I have used a large darning needle pressed into a a solid mounting, in turn fixed into a wooden handle. It is strong and rigid enough to probe successfully, but minimises the size of hole to be subsequently made good.

              #845663
              Mark Easingwood
              Participant
                @markeasingwood33578

                Tapping the wall with a hammer, knocking in a small nail, or pushing in a bradawl repeatedly, (preferably behind the area you are going to cover), until you find an upright are all methods used by us Joiners.

                Be aware if it is recent work it may be, “Dot and Dab”, or even metal studding, so no timber to fix to, it could also be insulated plaster board if it is an outside wall. 16 inch centers if it is old work 400mm if it is newer work.

                You can fix to the plasterboard using Gripfill or similar, or use plugs & screws or brick screws to fix through to the wall behind, just don’t overtighten the screws or you may bend the plasterboard back to the wall, where there is no support behind it!!!!

                There are also some very strong fixings for plasterboard available these days, such as “Gripit”.

                GRIPIT

                Mark.

                #845667
                peter1972
                Participant
                  @peter1972

                  Do not rely on studs being 400mm or 16″ between centres. I fitting a handrail for a straight flight of stairs in a fairly modern house (so my friend with poor mobility had handrails both sides). I found there was just one stud half way up the stairs. Evidently the studs were at 1200mm between centres (and only nominally 2″ x 2″). I therefore had to fix the handrail with just three brackets: to this stud, to a post at the top and to a stud at the very bottom.

                  For fixing through dot-and-dab plasterboard, I use frame fixings but shorten the plastic plugs so they pass fully through the plasterboard. I have been known to locally fill the cavity between plasterboard and blockwork first (for a floating shelf).

                  #845668
                  Alan Charleston
                  Participant
                    @alancharleston78882

                    Hi Old Mart,

                    I have used these anchors into plasterboard. They have good holding power and I have used them to hang a large (5′ x 2′) mirror to a wall. I don’t know what they are called in the UK but here in NZ they are called Gib Anchors.

                     

                    GibAnchor

                    #845682
                    Mark Easingwood
                    Participant
                      @markeasingwood33578

                      Another tip I just remembered, look closely at the skirting board, if there is one, and if it does not have too many layers of paint then you may be able to see where the nail/screw heads are.

                      If you are really lucky, roll back the carpet edge, as there may be pencil marks on the floor indicating where the studs are.

                      there should also be a row or two of horizontal noggins if it is a stoothing wall.

                      Mark.

                      #845685
                      peter1972
                      Participant
                        @peter1972

                        Those gib anchor plasterboard fixings are strong enough to hold a fairly heavy vertical load but nowhere near stong enough for reliably fixing a handrail in my view. They may not work if it is dot-and-dab construction.

                        I see there are dot-and-dab fixings available, incoporating a steel sleeve, that would be even stronger than using frame fixings; example:

                        https://www.wickes.co.uk/Corefix-Connect-DOT+DAB-Fixing—100mm—Pack-of-24/p/301974

                         

                        #845696
                        duncan webster 1
                        Participant
                          @duncanwebster1

                          Thanks Peter, I’ve been wondering how to fix a cupboard to dot and dab. If anyone is having plastering done, dont let them use dot and dab, insist on browning with a skim. It takes longer but is a much better job. I’ve just had an extension built and they didn’t seal the gap twixt plasterboard and roofspace, when it was windy there was a howling gale coming out under a windowsill (also not well sealed). I hope I’ve sorted it by drilling a row of holes all round the affected wall and squirting in expanding foam. T7ime will tell

                          #845699
                          Fatgadgi
                          Participant
                            @fatgadgi

                            Duncan – try Rigifix fixings first dot & dab.  They anchor into the brick behind the board and bridge the gap.  Think Screwfix sell them.

                            #845707
                            Andrew Crow
                            Participant
                              @andrewcrow91475

                              If you are fixing a hand rail to a stud and plasterboard wall you really  do need to find the timber as there are no plasterboard fixings that are strong enough. One way to do this is by drilling a series of small holes vertically and horizontally until you find one of the studs, if relatively modern they should be spaced at 600mm crts. The drilled holes can easily be filled and smoothed afterwards.

                              If it’s a “dot & dab” with brick or block behind, drill for your preferred plugs and if you don’t have dab behind the holes, squirt in expanding foam then push in a temporary screw to prevent the foam coming out of the hole. Once the foam has set screw on your fittings, it will give a bit of extra support to prevent the plasterboard from collapsing. Alternatively as someone has already mentioned there are metal anchors available  but there is still a risk of the plasterboard collapsing under the pressure.

                              Andy

                              #845708
                              Georgineer
                              Participant
                                @georgineer
                                On Alan Charleston Said:

                                Hi Old Mart,

                                I have used these anchors into plasterboard. They have good holding power and I have used them to hang a large (5′ x 2′) mirror to a wall. I don’t know what they are called in the UK but here in NZ they are called Gib Anchors.

                                I’ve just been asked by a friend to re-hang a dress rail which had been fixed with these and then fell down, ripping the fixings out of the plasterboard and leaving uneven crumbly holes.   I think that the best solution will be the red “GripIt” fixings, which require an 18 mm hole and are rated at 74 kg.

                                There are other sizes including an even stronger one, which I would have used in the days when my then-teenage son used to swing his whole weight on the stair handrails.

                                George

                                 

                                #845709
                                old mart
                                Participant
                                  @oldmart

                                  Update, I have used the magnet method and unfortunately the centres appear to be 550mm apart. Next step will be to find the width of the wood by one of the poke a tiny hole methods. Another problem is that sellers seem to include the overall length of bars, but not the centre distance of the fixings. I have found a longer rail on the B&Q website with an overall length of 687mm which shows promise as the bar will be sloping on the wall. I do have the anchors which are pushed through a hole in plasterboard and expand when set with a special tool, I think they have a 4 or 5mm screw thread.

                                  #845727
                                  peter1972
                                  Participant
                                    @peter1972
                                    On old mart Said:

                                    Another problem is that sellers seem to include the overall length of bars, but not the centre distance of the fixings.

                                    You could mount wooden ‘mobstick’ handrail on handrail brackets. That way there is no problem with spacing. However most brackets have three fixing holes and you are unlikely to manage to get all three screws securely into a stud.

                                    #845730
                                    Mark Easingwood
                                    Participant
                                      @markeasingwood33578

                                      Fix 1″ X 4″ to wall, and screw handrail brackets  and handrail on to it, or use “Pigs Ear” handrail.

                                      Pigs Ear on EBAY

                                      One of the problems with the self drilling fixings pictured above is that, if using on “Dot and Dab”, the point hits the blockwork before the body has fully sunk into the plasterboard, it will then spin and create an oversize hole!! The screws are not usually long enough either. I wouldn’t trust a cupboard on them.

                                       

                                      Mark.

                                      #845742
                                      howardb
                                      Participant
                                        @howardb
                                        On Andrew Crow Said:

                                        “If you are fixing a hand rail to a stud and plasterboard wall you really  do need to find the timber as there are no plasterboard fixings that are strong enough.”

                                         

                                        Oh yes there are fixings strong enough!

                                        https://www.screwfix.com/p/rawlplug-hollow-wall-anchor-setting-tool-kit/903kk#product_additional_details_container

                                        Expensive? Yes but they are reliable and very strong, I’ve used them to hang heavy weights like electric radiators on to plasterboard walls, you can buy the anchors on their own but you really need the setting tool to do the job properly.

                                        #845756
                                        Alan Charleston
                                        Participant
                                          @alancharleston78882

                                          Hi,

                                          One way of doing what you want is to screw a piece of 3″ x 1″ or 4″ x 1″ timber to the outside of the wall and screw the handrail to that. Cut a piece the right length, place it in the right position and draw a faint pencil line around it. Remove it and drill a series of 1/8″ holes in the wall along the length to locate the studs.  Then screw the timber to the wall. All the holes you drilled will be hidden under the board. Then screw the handrail fittings to the board.

                                          I’m not sure whether the criticisms of the Gib Anchors are justified. The flanges on the fittings which support the handrail generally have 3 holes in them. If there are 3 supports (top, middle and bottom) then there will be 9 anchors to support the rail which I believe would be enough to ensure they didn’t pull out.

                                          Regards,

                                          Alan C.

                                          #845763
                                          peter1972
                                          Participant
                                            @peter1972

                                            I would never rely on the strength of plasterboard to support a handrail.

                                            #845787
                                            JasonB
                                            Moderator
                                              @jasonb

                                              Did not know anyone used “dots” these days. I remember it was in one of my college text books 45yrs ago but never seen it being used. They all just “dab” these days including me.

                                               

                                              As Marks says if someone is going to by hanging off the rail or pulling themselves up the stairs use a timber or piece of MDF tso fixings go into the studs then you are free to place handrail brackets where you want and with screw heads that look right. Bit of grip fill etc on th eback of th eboard won’t hurt.

                                              I found wattle & daub walls made plasterboard look easy as I have a few clients with very old houses, good fun hanging kitchen cabinets and wall mounted applieances off twigs and mud.

                                              #845856
                                              old mart
                                              Participant
                                                @oldmart

                                                I foung a rail of the exact length to fit at the optimum angle to use the wall studs and the rail is nice and tight. It has another advantage, it doesn’t stick out as much as some which helps on stairs.

                                                The fixings that I have for use for hanging things like mirrors without help from studs are these I have 4 and 5 mm thread sizes, a lot of variations are available.

                                                I used to live in an early Tudor cottage with wattle and daube partitioned rooms in the loft space, there was a bat colony living there.

                                                 

                                                 

                                                SAM_1223

                                              Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
                                              • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                              Latest Replies

                                              Home Forums The Tea Room Topics

                                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                              View full reply list.