1 Inch Traction Engine, which modell is recommended

1 Inch Traction Engine, which modell is recommended

Home Forums Traction engines 1 Inch Traction Engine, which modell is recommended

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #842510
    karl07
    Participant
      @karl07

      Hello everyone Since I’d like to get a tractor, I wanted to ask you which model would be recommended. It should be around 1-1.5 inches in size, otherwise it will be too heavy for the basement (a larger one would be nicer, though). Ideally, it would be used, but a new, ready-made model would also be fine. Which manufacturers are still active? I could get a 1-inch LLVWELYN, but it’s not in great condition, but the owner says, that he proofed the boiler with airpressure. I would appreciate it if you could tell me more about it!

      Thank you in advance !

      Regards

      Karl

      #842518
      Nigel Graham 2
      Participant
        @nigelgraham2

        Proofed the boiler with air-pressure…

        Hmmm. To what test-pressure? Did he also build the boiler? Does the boiler have any previous test documents?

        I’d be very wary of that one. Pressure-vessels are proof-tested hydraulically, not by compressed-air, so someone admitting that would make me wonder what other mistakes he’d made.

        Especially if the engine is “not in great condition” generally – which could mean major repairs like a cylinder re-bore.

        At least the seller seems honest even if not very knowledgeable.

         

        I don’t think there are any manufacturers of ready-to-run traction-engine models in the smaller scales, but you could see what second-hand engine dealers like Station Road Steam and similar specialists have available.

         

        Regarding moving the engine about, even a 1″-scale traction-engine can still be a hefty lump of machinery.

        With respect I think this is something all new to you so I would take a lot of advice before buying any engine, and if not already a member join a model-engineering society for help and future boiler-tests. (You only need the latter for running the engine in public including club-only events, but still adviseable if your “public” is limited to your family in the back garden.)

        #842521
        JasonB
        Moderator
          @jasonb

          Maxitrak would be worth looking at both new and secondhand for ready made as they have a couple in that sort of scale. Also worth noting that a 1″ tractor will be a lot smaller than a 1″ ploughing engine.

          As for second hand a good1″ Minnie with boiler paperwork would be worth considering

          #842543
          karl07
          Participant
            @karl07

            Well, I already know about the pressure test, but the seller apparently doesn’t! He says he bought the tractor like that himself, and that he has others that he hasn’t tested yet. It’s strange, isn’t it? Many sellers I’ve asked about the leak-tightness almost always say: “I don’t know if the boiler is leak-proof!” A steam locomotive dealer once told me that if the boiler on a tractor leaks, it’s practically a total loss, as soldering becomes very difficult. Unfortunately, the tractor is quite a distance away; otherwise, I would have driven over and tested it with water.

            Regards

            Karl

            #842556
            Nigel Graham 2
            Participant
              @nigelgraham2

              Odder and odder…..

              Your opening message suggested to me the seller had inherited the engine but did not know how to use it, nor look after it. That is likely so for at least some of those other sellers you’ve asked.

              Now, he seems to be a dealer trying to buy and sell goods he does not understand. Nor does he understand his likely customers.

              I am not sure of the situation regarding the Pressure Equipment Regulations for selling second-hand engines commercially. Although a boiler trade-built before 2000, or privately-built, won’t have the same level of paperwork and would need be tested as if a “new” boiler. The reputable miniature engine re-sellers do test their goods properly.

              He seems best avoided!

               

              The locomotive dealer is right. Repairing a leaking shell joint can be very difficult or even impossible, and raises the uncomfortable question of the soundness of the rest of the joint. That applies to locomotive as well as traction-engine boilers – basically the same anyway.

              #842562
              Paul Kemp
              Participant
                @paulkemp46892

                Karl,

                First off I would ask what your experience and capabilities / available equipment are?  For example if you buy a used engine that turns out to require remedial work to get to a running condition do you have any machinery or ability to make replacement parts?  It is quite common for individual builders even when working to published / established designs to deviate from the ‘drawings’ if only using alternative screw threads or different materials to those recommended.  Unless it is a commercially produced model the chances of being able to purchase any spare parts are extremely slim.

                Secondly I have never heard of a Llewelyn steam tractor?  That is not to say this is not a commercial manufacturer I have never heard of but a quick internet search did not bring up any results on a manufacturer, full size prototype or model design.

                If you do not have a lathe / milling machine, basic hand tools etc and some knowledge of how to go about repairing or refurbishing a used model I would strongly recommend you confine your search to a commercial manufacturer that will be able to support you with spare parts if any are required.  I have seen too many people purchase what to them seems to be a “bargain” which has subsequently turned out to be sub standard with serious underlying defects that have been hard if not impossible (poorly constructed or leaking boilers) to rectify.  This has lead to disappointment, unexpected cost and ultimately serious disillusionment for the hobby.  I would always caution against purchasing any model steam engine sight unseen.  In fact it is always best to take someone with experience with you to view and to see the model demonstrated in steam.  This applies even to small models!

                Not trying to discourage you at all, just sounding a warning on what you could potentially be getting into with something that is uncommon and potentially unsupported.  Apologies if you have all the required machinery and skills!  If you do not, as mentioned in a previous post Maxitrak (no interest or connection) may well be your best bet as they will be able to supply parts if required.

                Best regards,

                 

                Paul.

                #842679
                karl07
                Participant
                  @karl07

                  Hi Paul,

                  First of all, thank you so much for the explanation, which is quite appropriate! I do have experience working with metals; I own a small lathe and milling machine, and yes, I can make quite a few things myself, though not everything. For soldering large parts like the boiler, I would definitely need a large torch. Yes, it’s true that buying something sight unseen is a problem, especially since it’s supposed to cost around €1200. The Problem is that in Germany there are only a few traction engines. One thing I’m not so familiar with is the imperial screws; there isn’t much of a selection here, as most steam engines use metric sizes. s-2s-1I have a Stuart D 10 and an S 50 as English machines. Anyway, I’ll take a look at Maxitrak. Perhaps the photos will help identify the tractor.

                  Best regards,
                  Karl

                   

                  #842683
                  JasonB
                  Moderator
                    @jasonb

                    It is not unlike a Minnie with a few variations, compare that to my Minnie

                    Minnie1

                    #842741
                    Paul Kemp
                    Participant
                      @paulkemp46892

                      Karl,

                      OK that’s good, with a lathe and mill you should with perseverance be able to address most mechanical issues that you may encounter.  I am sure there will be plenty of advice on here should you need it.

                      Agree with Jason that it looks to be based on the Minnie design.  I would say definitely a freelance representation rather than a scale prototype (nothing wrong with that from the operational perspective!).  Jason can certainly elaborate but I believe the Minnie design is susceptible to issues with the water pump getting hot and stopping it pumping due to it being mounted on the boiler.  I believe some builders have put an insulating joint behind it to try and improve.  I have no personal experience of the design though so best others more familiar make comment on this!

                      With the mechanical side covered the real risk is the boiler as you originally asked.  It looks to be a reasonably well found model in the pictures but looks can be deceptive.  I guess if it is not practical for you to go and inspect in person then it comes down to your appetite to risk and only you can answer that.  It may well turn out to be a sound model but conversely it may turn out that the boiler is problematic.  I would think you could purchase a new boiler from one of the commercial copper boiler makers, certainly should be available in the UK and you could transfer the other parts over – but that would probably result in expenditure exceeding its value!  I have no real idea on price of of a 1” scale copper boiler these days, if I were to guess I would think around £800 but you would need to get some quotes for an accurate figure.

                      Good luck with your decision and if you proceed with a purchase I hope it all turns out well for you.  Be interesting in the fullness of time if you report back on the outcome.

                      Best regards,

                      Paul.

                      #842811
                      Dave Halford
                      Participant
                        @davehalford22513

                        Karl,

                        A Minnie weighs in at about 13kg and nearly 1/2M long and said to be difficult to fire on coal.

                        #842821
                        Andy Stopford
                        Participant
                          @andystopford50521

                          My Minnie is 460mm long, I don’t know how heavy it is, but 13kg sounds about right.

                          It isn’t easy getting steam up, charcoal at first, and then mixing in steam coal helps – I changed the grate to a rosebud type which works much better. A more powerful electric blower is in preparation.

                          I redesigned the feed pump to keep it cooler, and it works alright-ish. I made the mistake of using nitrile balls for the check valves – the pump is quite capable of forcing them through their seatings. One is now, presumably, rolling around inside the boiler. I’ve replaced them with stainless steel, but I haven’t tested this yet.

                          Here’s its first run:

                          #843018
                          karl07
                          Participant
                            @karl07

                            Okay, I think a look at it will be essential. I’ll call him again, especially since he also has other tractors. The risk is simply too high for me. Maybe it’s better to invest a bit more money. By the way, nice video, Andy! And thanks for the tip about not using nitrile balls! I’ve watched a few more videos now, and what I might also like is the Maxitrack 1.5″ – what is just about manageable. The  modell is simple and not so detailed, but is it a nize size.

                            Best regards, and Happy Easter to you all!

                            Karl

                            #845091
                            karl07
                            Participant
                              @karl07

                              Hello everyone, I just bought the tractor and now I have a few questions. The tractor is generally okay, but it’s leaking in a couple of places. There’s a leak between the cylinder and the boiler, and also at some fittings. The boiler looks okay, but I still need to pressure test it properly once the cylinder is back on. My first important question is, what do I use to seal the cylinder to the boiler? The bolts protrude into the tank; do you use sealant there? Then there’s the question of the piston seal; what kind of seal do you use? Is it a graphit

                              gasket? That’s the one that’s currently installed. I would really appreciate any tips! Best regards, and please excuse my poor English!

                              Best regards Karl

                              k-1k-2k-3k-4

                              #845237
                              Paul Kemp
                              Participant
                                @paulkemp46892

                                Karl,

                                For the cylinder to boiler gasket I would use something like Klinger C4324 available as 1mm to 3mm sheet in combination with Rocol Steamseal on the gasket and on the threads of the retaining bolts (I an assuming something that small uses bolts).  Better solution will be shouldered studs which can the tight end into the boiler with a stud box and potentially a better seal between the boiler and the shoulder but that may be overkill in something so small.  There used to be two grades of steamseal the older conventional grade that stayed relatively soft and was great there was also a second grade “manganese” that set rock solid and made any subsequent dismantling rather difficult!  I think the latest modern version is something of an amalgamation of the two.  Fortunately my old tin is still half full and will save me having to try the new fangled stuff!

                                For the piston “ring” yes one of the traditional methods was graphite packing.  Not the best but Ok?  if what you picture there is still soft then sticking with that may be as good as fitting new.  Try working some steam oil into it with some graphite flake, difficult to say from a picture but what is there doesn’t look too bad.

                                Paul.

                                 

                                #845238
                                Paul Kemp
                                Participant
                                  @paulkemp46892

                                  Karl,

                                  One other thought, make a template the diameter of the boiler and offer it up to the cylinder saddle, this card will do.  That will give an indication of the gasket material thickness to use.  Too thick and you wind get contact through the middle, too thin and it won’t get contact at the outer extremities.  The cylinder saddle radius would normally be machined to the radius of the boiler plus an allowance for the joint thickness – hope that makes sense?

                                  Paul.

                                  #845239
                                  Paul Kemp
                                  Participant
                                    @paulkemp46892

                                    I give up with this forum and an iPad!  The bloody auto correct changes things to what it thinks is better but makes no sense and combined with the form seems the throw ?marks in entirely random places!!!!!

                                    Paul.

                                    #845357
                                    karl07
                                    Participant
                                      @karl07

                                      Hi Paul,

                                      thank you so much for your tips! Yes, using studs would be easier and probably better. But okay, I’ll use the 0.5 mm Klingerit (this thickness was on the boiler before) and then a heat-resistant elastic sealant. I’ve cleaned everything now, and the tractor is almost completely disassembled! A fresh coat of paint might be a good idea. The radus of the boiler and cylinder fit together quite well; that should work. Now I just need to get some BA screws, but are there BA 6 screws with an Allen head?

                                      best regards and thank you !

                                      Karlf-1f-2

                                      #845367
                                      Andy Stopford
                                      Participant
                                        @andystopford50521

                                        You won’t be able to use studs because they point in different directions preventing the cylinder being lowered onto them (if you see what I mean).

                                        EKP do BA Allen screws:

                                        https://www.ekpsupplies.com/ba-socket-cap-screws.html

                                        Take care tightening them – threads in copper may not be that strong.

                                        Paul – thanks for the tip about Steamseal, I’ve got to replace the plumbers’ merchant stuff I used on the Minnie so I’ll give it a try.

                                        By the way Karl, thanks for your comment on the video; in a further test, the stainless steel balls worked fine in the feed pump – it only refused to work once, with the engine being steamed hard, but a quick squirt of cold water on the pump body got it going again.

                                        #845372
                                        bernard towers
                                        Participant
                                          @bernardtowers37738

                                          I used centre nip helicoils in my DNY engine from the get go and made the bolts so the looked like studs with nuts and used rocol steam seal

                                          #845415
                                          Paul Kemp
                                          Participant
                                            @paulkemp46892
                                            On Andy Stopford Said:

                                            You won’t be able to use studs because they point in different directions preventing the cylinder being lowered onto them (if you see what I mean).

                                             

                                            Andy,

                                            Ohh yes you can, my 6” which has the same issue (studs pointing in all directions like a hedgehog) proves it.  You just have to think about it a different way!

                                            Twigged it yet?

                                            Ok, you put one stud in on the top centreline of the boiler front and back.  Lower the block and gasket on, then use a stud box to insert the others with the cylinder in position.  Why bother I hear you ask, is that not the same as a bolt?  Well no it isn’t!  With a shouldered stud (plain bit in the middle) you can screw the stud into the boiler right up to the shoulder.  Then give the stud box a whack with a hammer and nip up a bit more, this (should) ensure the shoulder contacts the boiler barrel hopefully improving the seal combined with steam seal on the thread (mine didn’t leak anyway!).  The nut is then free to properly clamp down the flange.  If you use a shouldered bolt it would be very difficult to make sure the shoulder seats when the bolt is at the correct tension.  As I think I said probably overkill for something of that scale anyway but unless using carrot bolts it’s probably the correct way.

                                            Steamseal (well the original) is wonderful stuff, not used the new version.  Another option if you can get it is stag A. That is like a grown up’s red hermetite used extensively on steam flanges in the old naval dockyard that stays relatively soft too but don’t get it on your fingers.  Cylinder cover joints and the like shouldn’t need any sealant at all just a thin joint smeared with grease or steam oil.

                                            Paul.

                                            #845416
                                            Paul Kemp
                                            Participant
                                              @paulkemp46892

                                              Karl,

                                              Be careful if you are putting a joint under the motion bracket, did it have a joint originally?  You will need to preserve its alignment with the cylinder for the slide bars to be correctly aligned and not bind up the cross head.  Might be an idea to make up a jig block and fit the cylinder and bracket together so everything is in the right place. I had lots of fun with a mate fitting the cylinder back to a full size engine that had a new boiler where the boiler maker had not quite lined up the cylinder pad with the crank – it is usual to make a jig off the old boiler to get things right but in this case it seems they didn’t or got it wrong!  Got there in the end but it was a lot of juggling!

                                              Paul.

                                              #845459
                                              Andy Stopford
                                              Participant
                                                @andystopford50521
                                                On Paul Kemp Said:
                                                On Andy Stopford Said:

                                                You won’t be able to use studs because they point in different directions preventing the cylinder being lowered onto them (if you see what I mean).

                                                 

                                                Andy,

                                                Ohh yes you can, my 6” which has the same issue (studs pointing in all directions like a hedgehog) proves it.  You just have to think about it a different way!…

                                                …Paul.

                                                Fair enough! I don’t really fancy trying it in 1″ scale though – it’s fiddly enough getting some of the bolts in as it is. I do slightly regret not having turned a fake stud end on the heads though.

                                                #845645
                                                karl07
                                                Participant
                                                  @karl07

                                                  Yes, I agree, studs would be best, but I can’t get them anywhere here. And unfortunately, Paul, the tip about EKP was good, but they don’t ship to Germany; it’s not allowed due to some regulations. Anyway, I’ll try to get some more screws. The most difficult part seems to be aligning the piston and crosshead, just like you all said. It’s difficult in general, but especially since I have to align and compress it, and I really don’t have time for that. Maybe I should tighten the cylinder first and then the crosshead holder. Puh !, this is going to be something! Meanwhile, I’ve stripped the front part of the boiler to paint it red. I don’t have a burn-in kit, but wouldn’t car paint work?

                                                  showman
                                                  A completely different question: I received an offer for a Markie Showman, brand new, never used. Are they any good? Or are they just made to look nice?

                                                   

                                                  Best regards

                                                  Karl

                                                  #846754
                                                  karl07
                                                  Participant
                                                    @karl07

                                                    Sorry for an other question, but can you tell me something about the Maxwell Hemments traction engine.

                                                    Is it a good manufacturer, or on the same level as Markie?

                                                    The thing is, I’ve been offered both this one and the Showman.

                                                    I would be very grateful for your input!

                                                    Best regards

                                                    Karl

                                                    #846766
                                                    Paul Kemp
                                                    Participant
                                                      @paulkemp46892

                                                      Karl,

                                                      Sorry, not able to comment, I have zero experience of either manufacturer.  I can’t imagine coal firing a boiler that small, I think it would be quite frustrating.  I think most people buy them to display rather than seriously run them and if they do run them I think they would run them on air.

                                                      Paul.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums Traction engines Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.