So i want a mill

So i want a mill

Home Forums General Questions So i want a mill

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 26 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #217824
    Michael Garbutt 1
    Participant
      @michaelgarbutt1

      So im going to buy a mill. Im not bothered if its new but i only have around £600-£700. Where could i find second hand machines and whats the best new option. ?

      #24289
      Michael Garbutt 1
      Participant
        @michaelgarbutt1
        #217834
        Michael Gilligan
        Participant
          @michaelgilligan61133

          Michael,

          I think you will get more helpful responses if you can also tell us roughly what size of machine you are looking for.

          MichaelG.

          .

          Edit: corrected typo.

          Edited By Michael Gilligan on 26/12/2015 15:21:49

          #217835
          Tim Stevens
          Participant
            @timstevens64731

            It would also help to know which of the 198 (+/-) countries you are living in.

            Cheers, Tim

            #217837
            John Rudd
            Participant
              @johnrudd16576

              I'd hazard a guess and say the op is in England from the currency being offered…..

              Horizontal or vertical mill or a combination of both?

              Single or three phase machine?

              The budget doesnt include tooling……plenty of questions to answer.

              Edited By John Rudd on 26/12/2015 15:31:18

              #217842
              Speedy Builder5
              Participant
                @speedybuilder5

                Michael, What did you want to make, small models, skimming cylinder heads ? Do you have a lathe, and did you want a mill to match typical lathe projects. Are you new to model engineering / engineering and could you re-condition a used mill. So many questions and as John said – tooling soon adds up!! There is a possibility of some sort of deal with second hand stuff which may include some useful goodies. Another question, imperial inch or metric ?
                Perhaps there is a model club near to you where you could 'pop in' on a club night perhaps and have a face to face with someone.
                We are not here to discourage, but as others have said, there are a lot of questions to be asked before one can advise. Start off with what you would like to make now and perhaps what you would dream of later.
                Come back to us.
                BobH

                #217854
                Michael Garbutt 1
                Participant
                  @michaelgarbutt1

                  ooh yer more info Sorry. I have a small chines lathe, I also have a chines 6040 cnc. I dont want anything big as im working in my single garage. I just love to tinker making small models and things like that. I dont want to do anything as big as a cylinder head.

                  I just find now i have the lathe i need to make things it can't do with it and my cnc is not up to cutting metal really. Id like to be making stirling engines and the like.

                   

                  is the warco wm14 the best at what it dose ? its alittle ,ore that i want to pay but if thats my best option i may have to wait a while longer 

                  Edited By Michael Garbutt 1 on 26/12/2015 18:05:30

                  #217855
                  Speedy Builder5
                  Participant
                    @speedybuilder5

                    second hand are about – No connection



                    Even this one makes me think twice !
                    BobH >**LINK**

                    #217856
                    mechman48
                    Participant
                      @mechman48

                      Look in the ' More for sale' ads on the right hand side of the forum… there's a couple of mills within your price bracket.

                      I have the WM16 & it's fine for what I do; but outside your price bracket, nowt wrong with the WM 14 that I can pick on.

                      George.

                      #217857
                      Ajohnw
                      Participant
                        @ajohnw51620

                        I had one of these a while back. They have increased the capacity across the width since then. With some pretty careful setting of the gibs it's not too bad to use. Unlike some it has a 3 morse spindle as well.

                        **LINK**

                        Little noisy due to the gears but not over the top. The owner after me was pleased with it too.

                        The one before me wasn't. Reckon to budget on a milling chuck and a good solid vice as well as the machine.

                        There is also a roughly similar machine from Sieg but I know nothing about it.

                        **LINK**

                        Arc are also a good place to look for a milling vice. There is a cheap one about that tilts and the tilt is held up by bits of plate steel – my advice would be don't. Go for a basic decent quality one.

                        John

                        #217865
                        Michael Garbutt 1
                        Participant
                          @michaelgarbutt1

                          this looks ok at £600 http://www.chesterhobbystore.com/champion-16v-mill-3991-p.asp but how dose it stack up against the more expensive wm14

                          #217870
                          peak4
                          Participant
                            @peak4
                            Posted by Speedy Builder5 on 26/12/2015 18:22:47:

                            second hand are about – No connection

                            Even this one makes me think twice !
                            BobH >**LINK**

                            Certainly worth considering. I've actually got the 2B, which does the job well enough SEE HERE too.

                            #217882
                            Michael Garbutt 1
                            Participant
                              @michaelgarbutt1
                              Posted by peak4 on 26/12/2015 19:53:06:

                              Posted by Speedy Builder5 on 26/12/2015 18:22:47:

                              second hand are about – No connection

                              Even this one makes me think twice !
                              BobH >**LINK**

                              Certainly worth considering. I've actually got the 2B, which does the job well enough SEE HERE too.

                              how hard would it be to get a motor for this ?

                              #217897
                              John Rudd
                              Participant
                                @johnrudd16576
                                Posted by Michael

                                how hard would it be to get a motor for this ?

                                Shouldnt cost too much….< £100 I'd have thought….but dont forget the dreaded vat on top of he price for the mill….could push you over the limit of funds

                                #217899
                                Another JohnS
                                Participant
                                  @anotherjohns

                                  Michael; as an owner of a Centec 2B with vertical head, and an equivalent type of mill to one of the Warco mills, I'd say that the Centec is hands and feet above the Asian mills.

                                  I just got a belt drive kit for my Asian mill, as I did not like wearing hearing protectors when running the mill – I found the gears noisy. The belt drive kit makes it quieter. (much). But then – maybe I got a bad sample.

                                  My Centec does not have a powerful motor in it, so when cold, it will not run at top speed until it is warmed up. Not a problem, but something I have to keep in mind as the capacitor start motor makes a bit of a complaint. I have NEVER stalled the Centec, even with this lesser strength motor.

                                  Saying that, the Asian mills are incredible value for the money; you can certainly do very good work on them.

                                  You'll be fine which ever way you go – just get to it, and make things. (smile)

                                  #217910
                                  MalcB
                                  Participant
                                    @malcb52554

                                    Hi Michael, when Chester are open again after the holidays I would give Tony a ring and ask him what ex demo machines he may have available. They don't list all they have on their web site. You may be lucky and have something at the next level or two up to what you are currently looking at..

                                    Warco are good at listing their but sell them pretty quickly.

                                    #217914
                                    SteveM
                                    Participant
                                      @stevem36008

                                      Hi Michael,
                                      A carefully selected used machine will give you much more bang for your buck. It will usually come with tooling which would be very expensive to buy separately, and you won't be limited to the Asian imports which would otherwise be your only affordable option.
                                      One milling machine that rarely gets a mention when people talk about a small footprint machine is the Downham Mini Jig Borer (AKA Elliott or Gate or Linley). Perhaps that's because many people regard jig borers as just a machine for drilling accurate holes, and I guess in some cases that's true. But the Downham is a true milling machine and is a great miller for the home workshop. They come up on ebay occasionally and sell for around £650. Full details are on the Lathes website here: Link

                                      Steve

                                      #217917
                                      Michael Gilligan
                                      Participant
                                        @michaelgilligan61133

                                        SteveM,

                                        That's a fine-looking machine star

                                        A decent example should be money very well-spent.

                                        MichaelG.

                                        #217920
                                        Tractor man
                                        Participant
                                          @tractorman

                                          Where I the UK are you Michael. There are dealers about worth visiting rather than waiting for the eBay lottery to come up. I have just bought a version of the Linley jig borer mentioned a few posts ago and it is a beautiful machine. Excellent for drilling but capable enough for light milling. Mick

                                          #217934
                                          Michael Garbutt 1
                                          Participant
                                            @michaelgarbutt1
                                            Posted by SteveM on 27/12/2015 09:11:26:

                                            Hi Michael,
                                            A carefully selected used machine will give you much more bang for your buck. It will usually come with tooling which would be very expensive to buy separately, and you won't be limited to the Asian imports which would otherwise be your only affordable option.
                                            One milling machine that rarely gets a mention when people talk about a small footprint machine is the Downham Mini Jig Borer (AKA Elliott or Gate or Linley). Perhaps that's because many people regard jig borers as just a machine for drilling accurate holes, and I guess in some cases that's true. But the Downham is a true milling machine and is a great miller for the home workshop. They come up on ebay occasionally and sell for around £650. Full details are on the Lathes website here: Link

                                            Steve

                                            there is one of these on ebay for sale just now if any one is interested . it looks a really nice machine but

                                            alittle out of my price range

                                            Thanks every one for the input i will take it all on board

                                            #217939
                                            Ajohnw
                                            Participant
                                              @ajohnw51620

                                              The Downham looks to be an excellent small machine BUT it would pay to remember that it uses collets and it would be best to find one with them, both metric and imperial. It might take a while to find one let alone the collets. It's the sort of machine that might crop up on the lathes co uk for sale section.

                                              I have a Dore Westbury. A few other people on here have them. They are compact and can machine a fairly large area for their size. They have a 2 morse spindle which is a limitation but it's in a Myford lathe type spindle nose so things can also be attached via that. 2 Morse collets can be used and I also use an 2 Morse ER16 collet holder. Other sizes of ER collet holder are available. The only unhappy owner I have come across is the one I bought mine off. Usual things, inadequate vice and slides way too loose. They were built from kits and crop up now and again. There are details on Lathes co uk.

                                              You can visit and buy used machines off dealers but prices are generally rather high compared with private sales and usually any extras will have been split of from the machine and will be sold separately. If people are prepared to take their time machines crop up that are sold with all sorts of things. Often sadly because some one has died or had to give up for one reason or another. My general advice on buying any machine is to wait until something crops up with plenty of kit.

                                              Over budget but this far eastern milling machine deserves far more attention than it gets

                                              **LINK**

                                              Similar machines will be available from other sources.

                                              People are inclined to say I want to change speed with a knob but there is no getting round the extra power available when speed is changed mechanically. This style of machine has been made in various sizes for as long as I can remember. You'll notice it weighs in at 300Kg which gives some idea of the rigidity it has. In real terms they are pretty serious machines for people who need that. It's what I would have if I had a little more space. Dore Westbury machines are also rather heavy for their size. Decent machines generally are.

                                              Emco and Wabeco millers turn up used at times. Probably the best of the lighter weight machines. These do crop up used at times.

                                              Don't rush what ever you buy especially if it's a used machine.

                                              John

                                              Edited By John W1 on 27/12/2015 11:23:37

                                              #217956
                                              Anonymous

                                                I've just bought an SPG 2217-ll after a fair bit of looking round, bigger and cheaper than a WM14 and near enough the same spec as a WM16 with the added bonus of being MT3 against the Warcos' MT2. Showing as out of stock until January as I bought the last one in stock smiley it was £730. Pleased with it up to now, came nicely set up, cleaned, oiled and smooth..

                                                Edited By Mick Berrisford on 27/12/2015 12:40:38

                                                #217974
                                                Vic
                                                Participant
                                                  @vic
                                                  Posted by Mick Berrisford on 27/12/2015 12:40:12:

                                                  I've just bought an SPG 2217-ll

                                                  Here's a link for it:

                                                  **LINK**

                                                  #217985
                                                  Michael Garbutt 1
                                                  Participant
                                                    @michaelgarbutt1

                                                    All very useful information. Thanks for taking the time to reply. I am very impatient most of the time. but i think i will wait this one out

                                                    #217994
                                                    Anonymous
                                                      Posted by Vic on 27/12/2015 14:34:01:

                                                      Posted by Mick Berrisford on 27/12/2015 12:40:12:

                                                      I've just bought an SPG 2217-ll

                                                      Here's a link for it:

                                                      **LINK**

                                                      That's the dearer lll model Vic, I've got the ll **LINK**

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 26 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.