Alternatives for a DRO display change

Alternatives for a DRO display change

Home Forums General Questions Alternatives for a DRO display change

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 37 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #810435
    John Hinkley
    Participant
      @johnhinkley26699

      After many months of soul-searching and cogitation, I have recently scratched my itch to acquire a mill.  Having down-sized my workshop a couple of years ago, I have purchased an Amadeal XJ12-300 Mini Mill with R8 spindle, gas strut-assisted head lift and fitted with a DRO.  It arrived last Wednesday, as did a new bench to keep it off the garage floor.  On Friday, with help from another forum member and a next-door neighbour it was lifted onto the bench.

      Now, at last, to my question.  The DRO system as fitted “does exactly what it says on the tin”, in as much as it measures movement of the head and table in three axes and displays that motion on the screen. That’s all it does.  No ½ distance calculator, no PCD function or any of the other bells and whistles that higher end displays feature.  No moans from me about the system as supplied – I knew what I was ordering and got what I paid for and am happy to work with it for the time being.  I should add that the scales are magnetic and therefore of small dimensions and ideal for the size of mill, but the leads terminate with 4-pin aviation-style plugs, not the normal 9-pin D-plugs.

      Soon, I want to replace the display with something more “fancy” and as I see it, I have a few alternative routes to follow:

      1)  just replace the display with one like the Ditron D80 and rewire the existing plugs into 9-pin D-plugs, or

      2)  buy a complete kit from cousin Ali and his Express team and discard the existing system (possibly utilise it on the lathe), or

      3)  get myself a ready-built TouchDRO from Yuri and add an Android tablet?

      If simply changing the plug terminations to 9-pin ones and attaching to a new display will work, I favour route 1.  I would rather avoid route 2, if possible on the grounds of cost and added complication.  Route 3 appeals for many reasons including its wide user base.  It’s not a cheap item and I’d have to purchase an Android tablet – but they are readily available on various auction sites.

      Does anybody know, or have a good inkling, if the TTL 4-wire output from the fitted scales will connect to and work with either a new whizzed-up display, or the TouchDRO interface?

      Or maybe you have a different idea on how you would spend my money?

      John

       

      #810473
      Stuart Smith 5
      Participant
        @stuartsmith5

        John

        Can you post pictures of the display, scales and connectors?

        I have made a couple of Touch dro setups, so may be able to advise.

        Stuart

         

        #810499
        John Hinkley
        Participant
          @johnhinkley26699

          Stuart,

          Thank you for your offer of assistance.  Below is a montage of the photos requested. The read heads themselves are approximately 30mm x 23mm x 13mm.  The only maker’s reference that I can find is on the back of the display – “CXM-3”.  Googling that only brings up a Czech web site which appears to market them with no technical info that I could find.  And a USA pdf showing how to connect all the leads to the display, as if that wasn’t obvious. Any other queries ask and I will try to answer them.

          DRO pics

          Regards,

          John

           

          #810665
          Stuart Smith 5
          Participant
            @stuartsmith5

            John

            As you say, those connectors are unusual for dro scales. I suppose no matter what you do, you will have to do some testing to identify the ground and 5v pins. The other two pins will be the A and B signal pins. If I understand correctly, these will be a square wave signal offset by 90degrees.

            This is a link to a page on the TouchDRO website explaining the connections:

            https://www.touchdro.com/resources/scales/glass/glass-scale-pinout.html

            You should be able to make adaptors for a Ditron or other readout with this information.

            I made my two TouchDRO adapters a few years ago using an Arduino on veroboard. For the first one, I used cheap digital calipers. For the second one I had bought some scales with individual readouts from Arceurotrade but found the display too small, so made an adapter to use TouchDRO and a very cheap Android tablet.

            Looking at the TouchDRO website now, you can buy a ready built unit or diy kit or build your own from scratch.

            I suppose it depends how much you want to spend!

            Stuart

            #810675
            John Hinkley
            Participant
              @johnhinkley26699

              Stuart,

              Thanks.  What you say confirms what I suspected regarding the scales and ties in nicely with my own research but it’s nice to get some reassurance.  A little bit of experimentation is called for, methinks.  I’ll pluck up the courage to dismantle a scale lead plug and see what colour code is being used.  Tracing the 5V output from the display shouldn’t present a problem.

              If I go the TouchDRO route, I’ll go for the built-up unit.  In about 2009, I tried building a veroboard based TouchDRO from the details given on the web site,  Couldn’t get it to work (with capacitive caliper-style scales from ARC) and gave that up as a bad job.  TouchDRO has come on leaps and bounds since than and looks a far more professional and polished product.  Only problem as I see it is if I mess up, a significant amount cash goes down the Swanee!  Well, you can’t take it with you, can you?

              I’ll add to this post when/if I achieve anything.  In the meantime, I’ll check the accuracy of the installed system and get on with that.

              Regards,

              John

               

              #810707
              SillyOldDuffer
              Moderator
                @sillyoldduffer

                Has the bought unit been given a fair trial?    Feels like it’s being rejected for not having features that may not matter in practice.  A DRO that calculates PCDs is a convenience, but not essential unless lots of PCDs are drilled.  For occasional PCDs jobs, any CAD package will calculate the coordinates, there are online calculators, and it can be done with paper and pencil.  Likewise, mid-points are easily calculated.  What essential does the DRO not provide?

                Wanting to replace a unit with “something more fancy”, is understandable, but may not be wise.  Up to you – if money is no object, replace everything – accurate scales matched to a high-end DRO that comes with bells and whistles, needed or not!  Buy the best of all possible DROs and be happy.  The alternatives suggested aren’t the best possible. they’re all more work and risky.  Mix and match, and TouchDRO is DIY.

                Nor for me thanks.  Having plenty of other things to waste money on, I’d stick with the paid for DRO until it let me down.  To me a DRO is just another tool, all they’re chosen by balancing utility and cost to meet a need.  Though bells and whistles are fun, I explicitly avoid them – they’re more to learn and go wrong at extra cost.

                But it’s a hobby so do as you like, whatever a miserable git like me thinks!

                🙂

                Dave

                #810730
                John Hinkley
                Participant
                  @johnhinkley26699

                  Dave,

                  As one miserable old git to another, you won’t be surprised to hear that I agree with the sentiments expressed in your post!  I have not used the mill at all, let alone given it a fair trial.  I will give the as-supplied kit an extended experimental period before taking a deep dive into what could be a significant investment.  (Deep pockets – short arms.)

                  When I had one of these mills over 10 years ago, I was very new to the hobby and through ignorance coped well enough with plain digital displays.  No reason why I couldn’t do the same again.

                  John

                   

                  #810735
                  Nigel Graham 2
                  Participant
                    @nigelgraham2

                    Having spent many years assembling and using electronic wiring, if the connector has only 4 pins it is because it needs only 4 pins: there are only 4 wires in the cable. Nothing wrong with “aircraft”-type rather than D-connectors, especially if genuinely to military or high-grade commercial quality. You’d need change them only to suit the replacement units. Why replace those anyway?

                    My milling-machine is a second-hand one too old to have been designed for DROs and the like, but I installed a 3-axis set by M-DRO, not something unknown from some Internet supermarket; and I am very happy with it.

                    The company knows our needs, and can supply what is right for the machine as well as user. I think I placed my order at the company’s stand at one of our exhibitions – certainly discussed it with the stand staff.

                     

                    [Besides “our” suppliers deserve and need our support even if their goods are imported. Amazexpress and their ilk, don’t!]

                     

                    It has many functions I have yet to use, including the halves. That can be overcome by setting the middle feature to (0, 0, 0) and read plus-so-far one way, minus-so-far the other, although that will lose any prior datum setting elsewhere on the work – often, a corner or a main axis. It also has PCD and arc calculator – oh, and calculator! – among various goodies I have yet to explore in the few years since I bought it.

                    Its only drawback is that switching between mm and inches (not within the same work!) seems to want the whole unit turning off and back on to register, which seems wrong – but that might be my fault. I may have missed something in the instruction-book! Which I have to say is very well written, in British English, not brave attempts without proof-reading.

                    .

                    Calculating pcd co-ordinates is not ever so hard though a bit laborious.

                    The Zeus books even include the appropriate factors. Or at least my editions do.

                    If you use ‘Excel’ or similar, create your own spreadsheet-calculator, using the diameter and hole-count as absolute-reference inputs. You could add further functions to give each hole’s co-ordinates from the primary datum on the work-piece.

                    CAD (2D or 3D) will let you plot a PCD anywhere on the item from its own centre, and obligingly gives that option of dimensioning everything from that primary datum.

                     

                    As Dave says, be accustomed to what you have rather than what you think you want.

                    I think with careful planning you will find your apparently-basic DRO willl cover most of your milling, and the unusual rest by augmenting it with external help by calculator, spreadsheet, CAD or pencil-&-paper.

                    Let’s be honest – we are spoilt! A few decades ago we all had to count little marks on dials! (I still do, for small, simple operations.)

                     

                    #810776
                    John Hinkley
                    Participant
                      @johnhinkley26699

                      Nigel,

                      I concur with all that you say.  You are obviously not a viewer of my YouTube channel or you would know that I’m not new to DRO operations, having had a all-singing, all-dancing, DRO set-up fitted to my Warco VMC mill, bought in 2015. Consequently I’m used to and well versed in the extended functions available. Spoilt, if you like. Since selling all my machines a couple of years ago, the itch I mentioned in the first post got worse until the cream was no longer effective. Hence the situation in which I now find myself!

                      Perhaps, knowing what I do now, I should have purchased the more basic machine and fitted a “proper ” DRO system later. But I was too impatient. That’s my fault and I’ll have to live with that decision.

                      John

                       

                      #814592
                      John Hinkley
                      Participant
                        @johnhinkley26699

                        Just a quick update to this posting.  While perusing the Aliexpress web site a couple of days ago, I noticed a DRO display on offer for less than £40 , so I thought I’d take a punt.  This is the unit and the pinout diagram:

                        DRO display - package contents  DRO display - pinout details

                         

                        I’ll maybe order a couple of suitable connectors and make up a cable to link this display to one of my existing sensors and see what happens. I’ll post the results on here later. (When the smoke has cleared!)

                         

                        John

                         

                        #814608
                        John Hinkley
                        Participant
                          @johnhinkley26699

                          Just noticed that that is the 2-axis version  Too late to edit the post.  I confirm that I’ve ordered a 3-axis display.

                          John

                           

                          #814675
                          Jim Mason
                          Participant
                            @jimmason14480

                            I bought one of these to replace a dead DRO, unfortunately the inputs are RS422 and my scales are I believe TTL. It is languishing in a cupboard until I can work out how to convert the output of my scales to 422.

                            #814677
                            John Hinkley
                            Participant
                              @johnhinkley26699

                              That’s disappointing to hear, Jim. I am basing my optimism on the fact that my magnetic scales have a four-wire output and I’m hoping that they’ll be compatible. Time will tell. My lack of electronics expertise often lets me down.

                              Amadeal sell a slightly larger mill with DRO fitted, originally with the same display that I have. This mill is now fitted with an uprated display similar to the one that is winging its way to me.  I emailed Amadeal to enquire about this about a week ago but have yet to receive a response.  Soon I’ll know for sure, one way or another.

                              John

                               

                              #814682
                              Michael Gilligan
                              Participant
                                @michaelgilligan61133
                                #814684
                                John Hinkley
                                Participant
                                  @johnhinkley26699

                                  Thank you, Michael, for those links.  If only I could understand what the words meant! I’m content, at least for the time being, to wait and see what urns up – possibly as early as Thursday – and, after my experiments, decide whether it’s fit for purpose or only fit for cupboard languishing, as Jim has found.

                                  John

                                   

                                  #814741
                                  Jim Mason
                                  Participant
                                    @jimmason14480

                                    Thanks Michael, I’ve ordered a couple and I’ll give them a go. I’ll update the forum on the results.

                                     

                                    #814745
                                    John Hinkley
                                    Participant
                                      @johnhinkley26699

                                      Referring to my post with the screenshots, the description does state ‘TTL’ for the connections, so I remain hopeful that my investment is just that.

                                      John

                                       

                                      #814810
                                      SillyOldDuffer
                                      Moderator
                                        @sillyoldduffer
                                        On John Hinkley Said:

                                        Referring to my post with the screenshots, the description does state ‘TTL’ for the connections, so I remain hopeful that my investment is just that.

                                        John

                                         

                                        I noted the same thing!

                                        rs232

                                        I’m 90% confident this is TTL, not RS-422.

                                        Fingers crossed, sacrifice a virgin, wire it up correctly, and there’s a reasonable change it will ‘just work’.

                                        What’s needed:

                                        • Match the wiring from the scales to the head.  With luck the colour code used by the scales matches the colour code above.   If not some detective work is required, difficult without test equipment and a basic understanding of the electronics.
                                        • Confirm the signal level voltages are compatible:  TTL is 0 to 5V.   Experiment by all means, just be aware that poking 5V into a 3.2V device, or 12V into a 5V is likely to kill them. I’m fairly sure the head is 5V TTL, not so sure about the sensors.
                                        • If the DRO doesn’t fire up (in a good way) the next stage is to match the protocol.  The sensors send the head a stream of binary data that can be encoded in many different ways, transferred at any of several speeds, with or without error checks, and possibly intermixed with stop/start and other control signals.  Potentially complicated and both ends have to be correctly set in agreement for it work.  Thankfully there’s a simple common method, but no guarantee that’s what John has.  Early DROs and scales often implemented secret proprietary schemes.  Decrypting an unknown system isn’t for the the faint hearted, and it helps to own a logic analyser!  Likely to be too difficult for a beginner, even with expert advice.

                                        Personally, I prefer to avoid such hassle by reading specifications before buying anything.  Guesswork is liable to be severely punished!   But let’s not start a gloom-fest – as I say it might “just work” – things are more standard than they used to be.

                                        🙂

                                        Dave

                                         

                                         

                                         

                                         

                                        #814818
                                        John Hinkley
                                        Participant
                                          @johnhinkley26699

                                          Dave,

                                          Your post gives me renewed hope! The existing simple display is powered by a 5V wall wart, so that’s comforting. Of course, there’s nothing to prevent the internal circuitry  reducing this to 3.3V I suppose.

                                          John

                                           

                                           

                                          #814838
                                          Nealeb
                                          Participant
                                            @nealeb

                                            I suspect that Dave is being a little pessimistic in suggesting that there is any particularly complicated data protocol involved here. The sensor almost certainly just produces two quadrature pulse trains via the A and B channels, which is again almost certainly what the display head expects. And it doesn’t even matter which one is A and which one is B! The worst that would happen is that the DRO reads “backwards”, that is, the reading goes up when it should go down, and I would be surprised if there were not a setup option to correct this. It is important to get the 0V and +5V right, of course. The sensors I have played with (some glass, some magnetic strip) have just produced nominal 5V TTL pulse trains. I would even skip sacrificing the virgin and just rely on old-fashioned crossed fingers!

                                            #814845
                                            mark costello 1
                                            Participant
                                              @markcostello1

                                              Where is a place to buy virgins? Seems like in short supply nowadays?

                                              #814947
                                              Jim Mason
                                              Participant
                                                @jimmason14480

                                                I stand corrected, the DRO I bought from aliexpress is not the same model, so it looks like I was unlucky that mine was not TTL. In mitigation I had no idea there were different interfaces available. At these prices I’m now tempted to just buy the right one rather than fiddle about with converters.

                                                #814960
                                                Michael Gilligan
                                                Participant
                                                  @michaelgilligan61133

                                                  To the best of my limited knowledge … the advantage of RS422 is that it’s reliable over long cable lengths

                                                  I doubt that’s of any great concern to you.

                                                  MichaelG.

                                                   

                                                  #815041
                                                  SillyOldDuffer
                                                  Moderator
                                                    @sillyoldduffer
                                                    On Michael Gilligan Said:

                                                    To the best of my limited knowledge … the advantage of RS422 is that it’s reliable over long cable lengths

                                                    I doubt that’s of any great concern to you.

                                                    MichaelG.

                                                     

                                                    That’s so.  The problem is that we don’t know what the designer had in mind, and he has plenty of choices. For example, RS422 vs TTL:

                                                    • RS422 is attractive because, in addition to long distance, it’s also fast with good immunity to electrical noise.  That might be considered important in a posh unit intended for reliable operation in a crowded industrial setting, and error correcting encoding might be added as belt and braces.
                                                    • TTL is cheaper, usually “good enough”, and many customers don’t need RS422’s extra features.

                                                    Therefore, a designer aiming at the economy market is well-advised to go with 5V TTL.  Except, keeping an eye on what’s available, he might notice a new chip is available that delivers RS422 for the same price.

                                                    There’s also a tendency to standardise, though it can take decades for a manufacturer to realise he’s losing business because his proprietary offering is incompatible with everyone else.  Might also force a design change.

                                                    Trouble is, what we buy is often poorly specified, making it tricky to be sure black boxes are compatible. Sometimes things connect easily, other times it’s a nightmare.  I blame salesmen!  Too many puff features whilst removing anything they don’t understand, especially important technical details!!!

                                                    Dave

                                                     

                                                     

                                                     

                                                    #815078
                                                    Barry Smith 4
                                                    Participant
                                                      @barrysmith4

                                                      I use similar sino ttl dro screens and they are good my only comment would be that if you have any thoughts on adding further dros/encoders for dividing heads, rotary tables, tachometers etc then the TouchDRO approach is a good option.  Adding an additional axis at a later stage can get expensive.

                                                      I do prefer the traditional seven segment dro displays in the shop as they are bright, easy to see and dont mind grubby oiley/gloved hands.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 37 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.