What about Woods metal, or one of the other very low temp metals. Comes in all sorts of similar alloys, some without cadmium, which might be preferred since you also suggested kids in the same sentence…?
Woods Metal
The stuff I have is a very whitish silver, and certainly once pewter has started to fester on a shelf for a bit can get quite a dark grey- so possibly inverting your colour choice?
Edited By RichardN on 03/01/2021 13:19:41
Edited By RichardN on 03/01/2021 13:19:55