Chinese dovetail cutter

Advert

Chinese dovetail cutter

Home Forums Workshop Tools and Tooling Chinese dovetail cutter

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #404088
    RMA
    Participant
      @rma

      Hi. Does anyone have any experience with Chinese dovetail cutters? I'm proposing to cut a couple of dovetails about 230mm long, in a block of aluminium, and I looked on ebay and I can get one for around £10.

      British ones are also listed but 5 or 6 times the price, Realising you only get what you pay for, I don't really want to pay a lot for a couple of cuts, do you think the cheap one would be up to the task?

      Advert
      #19302
      RMA
      Participant
        @rma
        #404089
        Baz
        Participant
          @baz89810

          Only one way to find out!

          #404091
          RMA
          Participant
            @rma

            I was really looking for an answer to my first question. If no one has any experience I might try the Chinese option.

            #404096
            The Novice Engineer
            Participant
              @thenoviceengineer

              Hi,

              I have used a number of Chinese sourced cutters over the past few years Carbide and HSS and generally they have been value for money.

              I have not specifically used Dovetails cutters but I have used T Slot cutters to successfully make an Aluminium Slotted Table for a small mill.

              Give them a try, its not a lot of money !

              #404097
              Brett Hurt
              Participant
                @bretthurt41827

                I got one off ebay and it worked very well and cheap.

                #404104
                David George 1
                Participant
                  @davidgeorge1

                  Hi I bought one only to find the stem between the cutting angle and the holding stem ran out by about 0.75mm and when I cut it rubbed there and had to relieve it to cut the dovetail I was cutting. The cutting angle and the stem was ok but I was woried by thinning the middle part.

                  David

                  #404107
                  not done it yet
                  Participant
                    @notdoneityet

                    Question of chinese or british might be addressed by comparing the quality (not the price). Cheap chinese might be poor value for money, but more-expensive chinese might well compare favourably with british but still at lower cost. Are you sure the ‘british’ ones are actually made in the UK?

                    If the epay quality is as much hit or miss as the likes of bang good, try by all means – but only if you can afford to throw the item away if it is sub-standard.

                    I’ve compared cheap chinese dies with second-use UK manufacture. Uk manufacture wins hands down when doing a tough job. I’ve compared chinesium bang good carp with UK sourced better quality chinese manufactured items and the UK sourced chinese item wins hands down. Your choice entirely.

                    #404108
                    HOWARDT
                    Participant
                      @howardt

                      I bought a HSS dovetail cutter from Tracy Tools at a show about 12 months ago, £15, has performed well in steel. Probably cut about 1000mm so far with occasional use of aerosol lubricant. Make sure the cutter diameter is big enough for the depth you need to cut, and small enough to get between the inner corners of the ways.

                      #404113
                      Jon
                      Participant
                        @jon

                        Have to admit i do use the HSS chinese dovetail cutters at least a couple of days a week pro.

                        If its £10 delivered it must be something like 18 or 20mm theyre good on 6082 and will do well in excess of 40 metres as a general guide.
                        Equally use the 3/8"/10mm a lot, same again 10's of metres.

                        Just chop out or slot out material first and use cutter purely to cut the dovetail/s to size.

                        #404131
                        RMA
                        Participant
                          @rma

                          Thanks for all the replies folks, I'll now order a cheapy and see how it goes.

                          #404191
                          Brian Rutherford
                          Participant
                            @brianrutherford79058

                            I bought a 10mm dovetail cutter for telescopic sight rail in mild steel. Suprised it did the job but took very light cuts

                            #404192
                            Brian Rutherford
                            Participant
                              @brianrutherford79058

                              I bought a 10mm dovetail cutter for telescopic sight rail in mild steel. Suprised it did the job but took very light cuts

                              #404197
                              Richard –
                              Participant
                                @richard-3

                                I made one, based on the Randy Richard's design he has a channel on YouTube.

                                It works brilliantly and uses a 60 degree carbide lathe tool insert.

                                Check out his channel

                                Richard

                                #404199
                                Tim Stevens
                                Participant
                                  @timstevens64731

                                  Be sure to use paraffin, or kerosene (or whatever our friends over the pond call it) as a lubricant, and you should avoid the tendency of aluminium to stick to the cutter and gouge the work. But of course, I expect you knew that

                                  Tim

                                  #404258
                                  RMA
                                  Participant
                                    @rma

                                    Thanks Tim and everyone, I'm still trying to locate one of the right size….and price.

                                    #404266
                                    Tim Chambers
                                    Participant
                                      @timchambers76147

                                      Dovetail Cutters

                                      I know it says wood but they worked very nicely in mild steel when I made some toolholders for my lathe a few weeks ago.

                                      Edited By Tim Chambers on 09/04/2019 00:02:38

                                    Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                    Advert

                                    Latest Replies

                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                    View full reply list.

                                    Advert

                                    Newsletter Sign-up