A pressing query

A pressing query

Home Forums Workshop Tools and Tooling A pressing query

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #222553
    Windy
    Participant
      @windy30762

      Have bought a relatively cheap Chinese 12 ton press for some of my projects unfortunately a 31mm shaft would only go in so far.

      I decided to press it out and remove a bit more off the shaft the so called 12ton press would not push it out.

      I decided to beef the press up and went to a local engineering firm for some steel as the chap I was dealing with knew me he removed the shaft on a professional hydraulic press the gauge showed 5 tons to push the shaft out.

      My query are these Chinese hydraulic presses optimistic on their tonnage a bit like some of their sizes of clothes eg. XL is more nearer large or medium at times.

      #17972
      Windy
      Participant
        @windy30762
        #222554
        michael darby
        Participant
          @michaeldarby61557

          I would ask for a letter (you type it) and have the engineer sign it and get your money back. it sounds like a useless piece of kit

          #222556
          Bubble
          Participant
            @bubble

            Hello Windy

            Not sure what your shaft is being pressed into.

            However, on the full-sized railway, when pressing axles into wheels, the axle pressing-in force varied with the way that the wheel was supported. If the wheel was supported at the hub, close-in to the axle, the force required was correct to design. However, if the wheel was supported at its rim, the force required was too high. This was because "dishing" of the wheel under the pressing in force caused it to nip onto the axle. I experienced this on (as I recall) a Eurostar wheelset (under lab test, not production) and asked an old hand what was going on.

            Jim

            #222596
            Windy
            Participant
              @windy30762

              Hi Jim,

              The shaft was pressed into a very solid piece of metal so there was no dishing affect my conclusion is these cheaper presses have too much give in the framework hence I'm beefing the frame also I have a higher tonnage jack.available for free if required.

              The basic frame design is reasonable but for a retail price of £12 for extra steel and a bit of welding it can be made more rigid to buy a press of that size it will be converted to would cost between £120 to £250 or more than I paid for the 12 ton type.

            Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
            • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

            Latest Replies

            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

            View full reply list.