I have used the freezing kits to good effect with soldering in new sections of pipe; I suspect the dissatisfaction expressed earlier was down to rushing the job and not letting a proper ice plug develop in the pipe.
I don't think I am breaking any national secrets by saying that a variation of the method is applied to nuclear submarine repairs, using liquid CO2 as the freezing agent. This is a dockyard job to replace components such as a faulty valve in the reactor system, for those operations they install a manned watch to be quite certain a leak in the primary circuit does not take place.
The rest of the system is still kept pressurised for reactor cooling purposes to about 1200 psi and close to 180 degrees centigrade. The ice plug itself is maybe 12 to 15 inches long in these jobs
These repairs are carried out on thick walled stainless steel piping of about 1 inch wall section and the new components are welded into the circuit; all a very far cry away from domestic operations in copper pipe
Brian.