Thanks. To clarify, this wasn't an attempt to do the job – I just wanted to see if I could get the work anywhere near temperature with setup in the photo using scrap of the same size. If I had, I'd have been encouraged to look around the dungeon for a bigger torch, but I couldn't get beyond dull red and wondered if it was worth pursuing this approach. I've done a fair bit of silver soldering, but on much smaller parts and didn't know if was feasible on this scale without a forced air or oxy torch. Sounds like it may be doable with a bigger torch though – nobody's said it can't be done.
The DIY firebricks are vermiculite with ciment fondu binder – not pretty but they get to an orange surface heat within a minute or two, and they're barely warm on the outside after twenty minutes. So I don't think they're soaking heat.
The blobs on the work are witnesses of failed welding attempts, not solder – I gave up and thought soldering might be less frustrating,
I need to work on welding! I can run a decent bead (stick welding) but tack welding seems harder, with stick anyway. However, since starting this thread I have come across a YouTube video showing how to do it by holding the business end of the electrode like a pen, rather than trying to control it from the handle. Looks good.
Even if this works, I'll still be interested in the silver soldering alternative – thanks for your kind offer of advice Keith, I'll PM you.
Robin.