Strange (to me) chuck jaw design.

Strange (to me) chuck jaw design.

Home Forums Beginners questions Strange (to me) chuck jaw design.

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #448719
    Robin Graham
    Participant
      @robingraham42208

      I was scouting around for a direct mount D1-4 3-jaw this evening and came across this offering from Chronos:

      chronos3-jaw.jpg

      The only reason for doing it like this I can think of is that maybe they can be reversed, and it's cheaper or more accurate than supplying a separate set of outside jaws. I suppose it would also be possible to mount soft jaws on the 'carriers', but Chronos don't seem to list any. Maybe I'm missing something!

      Any comments?

      Robin.

      #10055
      Robin Graham
      Participant
        @robingraham42208
        #448721
        Michael Gilligan
        Participant
          @michaelgilligan61133

          Yes, reversible top pieces screwed on

          … I think Pratt Burnerd calls them ‘American Style’ or some-such

          … Saves having to do matching scrollwork on two sets. enlightened

          MichaelG.

          #448725
          David George 1
          Participant
            @davidgeorge1

            you can make your own bolt on jaws. we used to make external jaws to suit chuck with a 2 foot diameter hold on a 12 inch chuck. just bolt on bore out to suit job if it needs modifying just weld a bit on a bit of metal and re-bore.

            David

            #448738
            jimmy b
            Participant
              @jimmyb

              I have a similar style chuck (160mm one) from Chester. The jaws do reverse and soft jaws are available.

              I converted a set of soft jaws to a master set that takes my own made tops ( I use soft jaws quite a lot!).

              Jim

              #448758
              Gary Wooding
              Participant
                @garywooding25363

                The 3-jaw on my Chester 10×36 lathe is like that. It's so well made and accurate that it certainly wasn't designed to save money. But it is a bit of a palaver to reverse the inserts.

                #448822
                Howard Lewis
                Participant
                  @howardlewis46836

                  Looks like an ideal chuck to take soft jaws! You have to make your own, of course.

                  Howard

                  #448826
                  Ex contributor
                  Participant
                    @mgnbuk

                    Pretty standard industrial setup. I bought a HBM 3 jaw of that pattern from RDG Tools for a Harrison 330 at work & the jaws are still a really good fit after several years of industrial use. In practice it doesn't take much longer (if any longer) to swap the top jaws around compared to replacing conventional internal / external jaws.

                    While Chronos may not list soft jaws, someone like Thame Workholding

                    will probably have them. Not too dificult to make your own, though. The mounting face patterm is proably to a standard – we were able to interchange top jaws between a Chines made Chester 500mm 3 jaw & a Forkhard 700mm 4 jaw at work.

                    Nigel B

                    #448831
                    ega
                    Participant
                      @ega

                      How many of us remove the spring from the chuck key?

                      #448867
                      oldvelo
                      Participant
                        @oldvelo
                        Posted by ega on 25/01/2020 15:44:54:

                        How many of us remove the spring from the chuck key?

                        Never had a new fangled chuck key in the 1950's. Old mentor " It's called a chuck key cos if you leave it in the chuck the lathe can chuck it at you".

                        #448915
                        old mart
                        Participant
                          @oldmart

                          I believe they are called slot & tenon and if you have a mill, it would be easy to make tops in mild steel or aluminium to bolt on to the master base jaws. Because of the bolt together design, they project further from the face of the chuck than one piece jaws.

                          #448917
                          Robin Graham
                          Participant
                            @robingraham42208

                            Thanks for replies – it seems that this a recognised design, just hadn't seen it before myself.

                            I am planning on making a set of soft jaws for the anonymous 3-jaw which came with my lathe using the idea of pins to engage with the scroll, as suggested by Martin Connelly in another thread. I had wondered about this sort of thing having seen wood turning systems where there are 'carrier' jaws to which various things can be attached, but hadn't seen it in an engineering context before.

                            Seems like a good idea.

                            Robin.

                            #448934
                            jimmy b
                            Participant
                              @jimmyb

                              If you get all the sizes of the required jaws, then someone like Rotagrip or Thame Workholding may be able to help.

                              I have allways manged to find soft jaws for all my chucks. They are usually around £30-£45 a set, I then simply turn these in to "master" jaws and make up bolt on tops

                              Jim

                              #448935
                              jimmy b
                              Participant
                                @jimmyb

                                soft top jaws.jpgsoft jaws button.jpgdsc00002.jpgdsc00001.jpgbase jaws.jpg

                                #448941
                                Tony Pratt 1
                                Participant
                                  @tonypratt1
                                  Posted by ega on 25/01/2020 15:44:54:

                                  How many of us remove the spring from the chuck key?

                                  Me.

                                  Tony

                                  #448975
                                  Nick Wheeler
                                  Participant
                                    @nickwheeler
                                    Posted by ega on 25/01/2020 15:44:54:

                                    How many of us remove the spring from the chuck key?

                                    The second key I made for the four jaw chuck feels so wrong without a spring, I'm tempted to fit one…….

                                    #448996
                                    SillyOldDuffer
                                    Moderator
                                      @sillyoldduffer
                                      Posted by Tony Pratt 1 on 26/01/2020 07:37:46:

                                      Posted by ega on 25/01/2020 15:44:54:

                                      How many of us remove the spring from the chuck key?

                                      Me.

                                      Tony

                                      Really. Why?

                                      Big employers are hot on best-practice because they've been sued, prosecuted, had expensive machines damaged, paid hefty legal fees, and then been walloped with increased insurance premiums! Once you get beyond near misses and trivial incidents, even small accidents cost tens of thousands. A fatality is likely to cost millions.

                                      Model Engineering has an excellent safety record. But I don't see any advantage in deliberately defeating basic safety features, especially anything like a chuck spring that only slows me down by a few seconds. Real men take up wood-working and start by removing all those inconvenient power-saw guards. Chop, chop!

                                      Dave

                                      #449000
                                      Tony Pratt 1
                                      Participant
                                        @tonypratt1

                                        SOD,

                                        Of course you are right but after 50 years I will go continue to go spring less, in fact the only key I have used which came with a spring was on my Warco lathe purchased last year, after an incident on a school lathe over 50 years ago I have never been caught out, but it could happen.

                                        Slightly OT, a few months ago I replaced my power saw guard, with a lifetime in metal cutting I still find band / power saws and angle grinders the most frightening [maybe not the right word]

                                        Tony

                                        #449057
                                        Ex contributor
                                        Participant
                                          @mgnbuk

                                          Big employers are hot on best-practice because they've been sued, prosecuted, had expensive machines damaged, paid hefty legal fees, and then been walloped with increased insurance premiums!

                                          I have been in a great many engineering workshops in the last 43 years & have yet to see a spring on a chuck key in any of them. A spring is no substitute for safe working practice. At the Apprentice training school I did my "First year off the job" training at, the Lord help you if you were lax enough to leave a chuck key in the chuck. Those who did so did not do so a second time !

                                          Nigel B

                                          #449087
                                          Dave Halford
                                          Participant
                                            @davehalford22513

                                            There's a different version that has lots teeth at 1/16" centers instead of a single slot, not so easy to reverse, but more flexible.

                                            #449287
                                            old mart
                                            Participant
                                              @oldmart

                                              Funny you should mention the other type of top jaws, Dave, these serrated with 1/16" X 90 degree pointed jaws for a 6 1/2" Pratt chuck came through the post this morning. I was lucky and put in the only bid on ebay, and got them for £8.75 including postage. I looked up the Thame code, AJ06 before bidding.

                                              _igp2550.jpg

                                              #449346
                                              Dave Halford
                                              Participant
                                                @davehalford22513

                                                They'll fit mine too.

                                                I've just got the hard jaws on my 61/2", they seem to be a bit touchy on positioning as you have to have all three numbers matching. Number 3 position, number 3 tee nut, number 3 jaw otherwise they go well out of center.

                                                #449381
                                                old mart
                                                Participant
                                                  @oldmart

                                                  I have lots of the serrated jaw sets, some were for larger chucks. You can get larger 1/16" serrated jaws to fit if you make custom tee nuts with the threads and pitch to suit the bigger jaws. the edges of the jaws where the serrations are may have to be narrowed slightly. I also have two sets of hard jaws, one standard and one a size larger. They did not run very well, and were slightly bellmouthed, so they got ground and run dead true now. I also had to number them to match properly. The underside of the larger ones had to be narrowed slightly, and as they are hard, I used a solid carbide end mill on them.. You sometimes get job lots of used ones on ebay really cheap, which is where mine came from, some well used and some nearly new.

                                                Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
                                                • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                Latest Replies

                                                Home Forums Beginners questions Topics

                                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                View full reply list.