What about a “like” button on the forum?

Advert

What about a “like” button on the forum?

Home Forums Website Questions, Comments, and Suggestions What about a “like” button on the forum?

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 64 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #528390
    andrew lyner
    Participant
      @andrewlyner71257

      "Like" is a quick form of feedback and very popular on many fora. How easy would it be to achieve it – if the MODS decide it's a good idea?

      Advert
      #39576
      andrew lyner
      Participant
        @andrewlyner71257
        #528393
        John Haine
        Participant
          @johnhaine32865

          Has been mentioned in this thread…

          #528400
          Martin Kyte
          Participant
            @martinkyte99762

            Leave the forum as it is. A plain and simple way of exchanging information.

            Like buttons just encourage populist opinion.

            regards Martin

            #528407
            andrew lyner
            Participant
              @andrewlyner71257
              Posted by Martin Kyte on 18/02/2021 22:26:52:

              Like buttons just encourage populist opinion.

              regards Martin

              Do you use any other fora frequently? I use the excellent PhysicForums and most of the discussions are at a very high technical level with contributions from many professional Physicists and Engineers. Definitely not "populist". I also spent years on the Westerly Owners Association Forum. Both those fora had a like facility and I can't say it was anything other than useful to discussions. There are, of course, many (the majority of) fora that are simply dreadful, with or without a few bells and whistles.

              To be honest, the quality of this forum interface is nothing like as good as the quality of the information that's exchanged and he level of knowledge of members. Would the membership change if the site were improved?

              On a similar topic, It's amazing to see the reaction of some people against the Zoom / Webex etc. culture. My French and Astronomy groups all learned to use it and we have all felt the benefit in these dark times. Don't we need to move on, sometimes?

              Andrew

              #528415
              Bill Phinn
              Participant
                @billphinn90025
                Posted by andrew lyner on 18/02/2021 23:27:50:

                On a similar topic, It's amazing to see the reaction of some people against the Zoom / Webex etc. culture. Andrew

                What sort of reaction do you have in mind, Andrew?

                Personally, I've nothing against the culture itself, but the first-named company [and, some suggest, the second] has been complicit in serious human rights violations, particularly against Chinese citizens and other people of Chinese ethnicity overseas.

                Looking at the bigger picture, i.e. the majority of Zoom users, it's fairly safe to say that a belief that content transmitted by these two companies will have any meaningful encryption is ill-founded.

                #528425
                DiogenesII
                Participant
                  @diogenesii
                  Posted by Martin Kyte on 18/02/2021 22:26:52:

                  …Like buttons just encourage populist opinion…

                  regards Martin

                  yes broken heart

                  Edited By DiogenesII on 19/02/2021 07:50:40

                  #528427
                  Steve Neighbour
                  Participant
                    @steveneighbour43428
                    Posted by DiogenesII on 19/02/2021 07:48:43:

                    Posted by Martin Kyte on 18/02/2021 22:26:52:

                    …Like buttons just encourage populist opinion…

                    regards Martin

                    yes broken heart

                    Edited By DiogenesII on 19/02/2021 07:50:40

                    yes yes heart 

                    Edited By Steve Neighbour on 19/02/2021 07:54:20

                    #528428
                    Daniel
                    Participant
                      @daniel
                      Posted by andrew lyner on 18/02/2021 21:37:57:

                      "Like" is a quick form of feedback and very popular on many fora. How easy would it be to achieve it – if the MODS decide it's a good idea?

                      yes

                      #528430
                      Journeyman
                      Participant
                        @journeyman

                        When the forum software is upgraded to Invision in a few weeks time we shall see if a 'like' system is in place.

                        See this recent lengthy thread.

                        John

                        Edited By Journeyman on 19/02/2021 08:31:13

                        #528433
                        Lee Rogers
                        Participant
                          @leerogers95060

                          I'm a regular on a sea fishing forum that's been ''updated'' recently with the result it's lost it's character and general ambience. This forum works for me , the quality of posts and the feedback given is generally very good . Like a lot of my tools it's a bit outdated but theres many a safe journey made on an old bike.

                          #528441
                          andrew lyner
                          Participant
                            @andrewlyner71257
                            Posted by Steve Neighbour on 19/02/2021 07:53:46:

                            Posted by DiogenesII on 19/02/2021 07:48:43:

                            Posted by Martin Kyte on 18/02/2021 22:26:52:

                            …Like buttons just encourage populist opinion…

                            regards Martin

                            yes broken heart

                            Edited By DiogenesII on 19/02/2021 07:50:40

                            yes yes heart

                            Edited By Steve Neighbour on 19/02/2021 07:54:20

                            That post rather makes my point. How much more trouble did you go to, to register a non-specific approval, compared with a simple button press?

                            No one is forced to make use of new fangled bolt-ons (as with lathe fitments and CNC (???)) but they are appreciated by some of us.

                            I realise that the chill wind of change makes all of us shudder at times. secret

                            #528444
                            Anonymous
                              Posted by Martin Kyte on 18/02/2021 22:26:52:

                              Like buttons just encourage populist opinion.

                              Rest assured that should a "like" button be introduced I wouldn't click it on any of your posts. smile

                              Andrew

                              #528445
                              Dave Halford
                              Participant
                                @davehalford22513

                                In the interests of diversity yar if we have a like button we should also have an idiot button for when we don't like.devil

                                #528447
                                Andrew Tinsley
                                Participant
                                  @andrewtinsley63637

                                  I agree with Andrew Johnston.

                                  Andrew.

                                  #528451
                                  JasonB
                                  Moderator
                                    @jasonb

                                    Can I suggest that people follow the two links in this thread to the other thread about forum updates and then follow one of several link to the RCM&E site and see what has been implemented there. I will say that having the facility is optional and can be turned off in the powers that be if they see fit.

                                    You can like or disliike this post as you wish

                                    #528452
                                    andrew lyner
                                    Participant
                                      @andrewlyner71257
                                      Posted by Bill Phinn on 19/02/2021 01:41:09:

                                      Posted by andrew lyner on 18/02/2021 23:27:50:

                                      On a similar topic, It's amazing to see the reaction of some people against the Zoom / Webex etc. culture. Andrew

                                      What sort of reaction do you have in mind, Andrew?

                                      Personally, I've nothing against the culture itself, but the first-named company [and, some suggest, the second] has been complicit in serious human rights violations, particularly against Chinese citizens and other people of Chinese ethnicity overseas.

                                      Looking at the bigger picture, i.e. the majority of Zoom users, it's fairly safe to say that a belief that content transmitted by these two companies will have any meaningful encryption is ill-founded.

                                      I don't want to get into the politics of the situation. That's almost certainly against Forum policy and we could find ourselves banned. Just using the technology that gives us this forum takes us into the same sort of territory.

                                      My question was a general one about using new available technology. I am reasonably elderly and a lot of the people I meet in the pursuit of my hobbies, are even older. I notice a strong reluctance to take up 'new' facilities. I am a member of U3A and I've actually been impressed by the large number of 'really old' members who have embraced the new media. Initially getting through the front door of Zoom is daunting but they arrive at meetings.

                                      I have looked at the thread about changing the forum and I see an amazing reluctance of members to it. So it's not too surprising that "like" is viewed with suspicion. But what a shame. I seriously can't imagine ME ever getting too populist. It's so 'deadly boring' – unless you are into it and then it is one of the best things since sliced bread.

                                      I remember, perhaps forty years ago, at a Computer Fair in Brighton, hearing a guy 'explaining things' to his wife. He told her that a computer mouse was pointless and that he could do everything he wanted to with the cursor keys. I wonder if he ever got round to using a mouse.

                                      PS How relevant to our lives is the encryption that's available on social media? Important transactions are pretty secure when we talk to the bank. It's quite simple to communicate with people with very high levels of encryption, if we are prepared to use appropriate private encryption systems. Does anyone really care about our WhatsApp threads being snooped on?

                                      #528459
                                      Ady1
                                      Participant
                                        @ady1

                                        It's one of those things which can be abused and become pointless

                                        Many forums limit the number of "likes" to 3 or 5 a day max

                                        Personally speaking I don't care for it

                                        #528464
                                        An Other
                                        Participant
                                          @another21905

                                          Definitely don't like. – keep it simple – no complications

                                          #528482
                                          Alan Jackson
                                          Participant
                                            @alanjackson47790

                                            Perhaps there should be a vote on a like button, Like or do not Like. Just saying.

                                            Alan

                                            #528494
                                            Grindstone Cowboy
                                            Participant
                                              @grindstonecowboy

                                              Occasionally I see a post and think "Oh, I like / agree with that" and if there was a "Like" button would probably press it. But unless it was an earth-shattering pronouncement, the feeling soon passes and what real benefit would it be to the original poster (or myself) to know that we agree with each other? If it's something that actually needs to be commented upon one way or the other, then I think it only polite to take the time and effort to actually write something. Even if it's just "+1 on what xxxxx said!"

                                              And all the above goes for "Dislike" as well but in reverse.

                                              Rob

                                              #528495
                                              Oldiron
                                              Participant
                                                @oldiron

                                                I would not use a like button. The more likes people get the more inflated their ego gets.

                                                regards

                                                #528496
                                                andrew lyner
                                                Participant
                                                  @andrewlyner71257
                                                  Posted by Alan Jackson on 19/02/2021 11:43:05:

                                                  Perhaps there should be a vote on a like button, Like or do not Like. Just saying.

                                                  Alan

                                                  LIKE

                                                  That was an effort for me. wink 2

                                                  #528500
                                                  SillyOldDuffer
                                                  Moderator
                                                    @sillyoldduffer

                                                    Like everything else, Like buttons are double-edged, good or evil depending on how they are used.

                                                    The main reason I want one is to show appreciation of work in progress. A Like button sends a no fuss signal of plain encouragement. A forum flaw is many members share excellent photos of their latest achievements and get no response at all. I suspect this is only because most admirers don't have the time or skill needed to dash off an effective written appreciation. So easy for text admiration to be accidentally dismissive or patronising!

                                                    On the other hand chasing 'Likes' smacks of unhealthy egotism, and issuing 'Dislikes' of bullying.

                                                    Worth a try I think.

                                                    Dave

                                                    #528513
                                                    Dalboy
                                                    Participant
                                                      @dalboy

                                                      I personally think that it would encourage less comments on a piece as many are too lazy to type a comment and rather press a like button

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 64 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up