Big issue when choosing between so many look alike and very similar products is how to assess quality. The inexpensive ones can be fearfully cheap and flimsy. Can't go by price alone as their is a huge variation. Some of the inexpensive ones can be more than acceptable. Others so bad you'd almost have to pay someone to take them away. If you buy mail order you can't inspect them so about the only guide to sturdiness is the weight. I figure you need to be around 2/3 rds or upwards of the weight of the equivalent Snap On to be confident of something decently sturdy.
Doesn't strictly apply in this case as Richard F clearly wants it for small tools but the rated capacity of the drawers, and whole cabinet, from some suppliers can be fearfully small. In the absence of other information if a supplier also offers roll cabinets checking the quoted drawer loading may give an indication of the quality of the rest of the range. All sticker brands tho' which doesn't help. Before buying my used Snap On I looked at some of the stainless roll cabs, presumably similar to those Clogs is considering, and found one whose total rated capacity was rather less than one Snap On drawer. A 56" cabinet I think, memory says rated at about 20 lb per drawer, which would have got me nowhere.
Muzzers Homebase link shows two versions of the style in question. One at £63 and one at £146. The cheap one is about half the weight of the more expensive one. OK its a bit smaller but I'd expect the more expensive one to be significantly sturdier. To me a flimsy tool chest, along with drawers that don't open fully, is one of those fingernails on the blackboard things that would drive me nuts in short order. From what I've seen the £150 to maybe £220 price range is most likely to turn up something Mr Average Home Shop Guy would be happy with.
Ever since the import tool thing went mainstream its been nearly impossible to get a handle on the sensible quality / best price / best value thing. For example maybe a decade back I bought a toolchest of similar style to that under discussion containing a mostly decent set of mechanics tools from Halfords on special offer at essentially the same price as a significantly flimsier empty tool chest of similar size. Basically I swopped a set of tools for three small drawers. The basic Halfords empty tool-chest was definitely not up to standard but this one did me fine until I outgrew it and sold it on. The tool quality was a bit variable and the socket size selection more than a little odd but I still have most of the tools. OK some live in the loaner drawer. Saved me a ton of back'n forth from workshop to garage over the years. Something like this **LINK** but mine had an extra row of small drawers. Also, judging by the reviews, mine was much higher quality in both box and content. As I remember it sticker price was similar making real price maybe double so the stuff should have been better. Really its the sort of bargain you only find by chance and inspection. I just went in for a bottle of screen wash whilst HerLadyship was scoffing a burger at McDonalds next door.
Clive.
Edited By Clive Foster on 25/03/2017 19:46:24