The blind leading the blind

The blind leading the blind

Home Forums The Tea Room The blind leading the blind

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #445427
    Danny M2Z
    Participant
      @dannym2z

      I saw a TV advertisment today for the local TAFE (Technical And Further Education) establishment in my nearby town of Wodonga.

      As the place has some nice machinery I have been considering whether to sign up for a course.

      Imagine my dismay when the ad showed a young person operating a running lathe without any eye protection or even a chuck guard.

      So I attempted to contact the TAFE via their website ("Contact Us&quot to register my dismay and my message was rejected by their server.

      This is the message that I attempted to send, I kept it for when I visit the place personally.

      I noticed your TV advertisment today (#9 Go) showing a young person operating a lathe without eye protection. Not only is this a bad practice it is also contrary to OH&S regulations and a terrible example to present to the public.

      Whomever supervised this advertisment requires either re-training or replacement.

      Please edit or delete the advertisment in question.

      * Danny *

      All the required boxes were ticked re: contact details etc so it appears that a trip into town is on the agenda.

      I wonder how many layers of red tape and petty bureaucracy I have to jump through to get the message through?

      * Danny M *

      #35711
      Danny M2Z
      Participant
        @dannym2z
        #445483
        Howard Lewis
        Participant
          @howardlewis46836

          Prior to retirement, I thought about buying the very latest version of my lathe.

          "Is this for you, or for a school or college?"

          "For me. Why do you ask?"

          "You don't need a chuck guard, but a school or college machine must have one"

          When I read to cost, I bought a larger lathe, elsewhere, for a lot less, and got a lot more; chuck guard and toolpost guard included.

          Howard

          #445484
          not done it yet
          Participant
            @notdoneityet

            Video or pic? Could be a difference between ‘looking at’ and ‘using’. However, eye protection should be the order of the day whenever in that working area – there may be others making flying chips! Most certainly not a good advert.

            #445487
            Stuart Bridger
            Participant
              @stuartbridger82290
              Posted by not done it yet on 09/01/2020 11:48:15:

              Video or pic? Could be a difference between ‘looking at’ and ‘using’. However, eye protection should be the order of the day whenever in that working area – there may be others making flying chips! Most certainly not a good advert.

              100% agree. When I worked in industry over 30 years ago, all machine shops were designated eye protection areas. It was mandatory even if just walking down the gangways.

              Edited By Stuart Bridger on 09/01/2020 12:14:11

              #445488
              Hopper
              Participant
                @hopper

                You're lucky your local TAFE offers such courses to the public. Most don't anymore. Our local TAFE only trains apprentices, no public classes. Which is a shame because Clickspring is the Fitting and Machining instructor there.

                #445503
                SillyOldDuffer
                Moderator
                  @sillyoldduffer

                  Posted by Danny M2Z on 09/01/2020 08:15:28:

                  Imagine my dismay when the ad showed a young person operating a running lathe without any eye protection or even a chuck guard.

                  Most likely a miscommunication. Ad probably made by a PR Agency who know all about attracting potential customers whilst caring nothing whatever about the item being sold.

                  Engineers aren't allowed to make adverts because the results tend to be deadly dull. Poor old engineers rarely understand were they went wrong. Trouble is we are blissfully unaware that the rest of humanity doesn't give a sh1t about facts or accuracy! Don't ask how I know…

                  I expect if you did the course, you'd find it run by a techie complete with eye protection and steel toe-caps!

                  Dave

                  Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 09/01/2020 13:41:11

                  #445509
                  Brian G
                  Participant
                    @briang

                    Not the first time, and certainly not the last, but I suppose we should be glad the subject of this famous photo is wearing safety glasses.

                    Brian G

                    #445538
                    Steviegtr
                    Participant
                      @steviegtr
                      Posted by Brian G on 09/01/2020 14:25:21:

                      Not the first time, and certainly not the last, but I suppose we should be glad the subject of this famous photo is wearing safety glasses.

                      Brian G

                      Brilliant. laugh

                      #445558
                      not done it yet
                      Participant
                        @notdoneityet

                        At least the first lady was almost dressed suitably, even if not in ‘working togs’. The one in the second pic is asking for trouble. If one needs to protect ones eyes, lower body parts might also be in the firing line! Perhaps not so potentially ‘life changing’ but not comfortable…

                        #445561
                        Howard Lewis
                        Participant
                          @howardlewis46836

                          Remember the press motto, "Don't let the facts stand in the way of a good story"

                          "You mean soldering irons get hot?????????"

                          Howard

                          #445586
                          Danny M2Z
                          Participant
                            @dannym2z
                            Posted by not done it yet on 09/01/2020 11:48:15:

                            Video or pic? Could be a difference between ‘looking at’ and ‘using’. However, eye protection should be the order of the day whenever in that working area – there may be others making flying chips! Most certainly not a good advert.

                            It was a video ndiy, the chuck was spinning and the young operator had his hand on the controls.

                            When my son attended a basic electronics course at the same TAFE (prior to joining the Royal Australian Navy) he mentioned that all of the function generator kits that the students were constructing were going up in smoke. As he was yet to complete his I asked him to bring home the circuit diagram and the suspect part.

                            It was a 50µA analogue meter that had been 'converted' to read to 1A by somebody sticking a new scale onto the face. No shunt had been fitted. The students were also required to pay $20 for this 'conversion'.

                            I sat down with my son, explained the problem and asked him to calculate the value of the required shunt. It was some fraction of an Ohm and I said that such a low value would be impossible to purchase so we would make one. Went to the workshop, gave him a coil of nichrome wire and showed him how to measure the resistance of about 5m then calculate the required length, This was wound onto a 4.7MΩ resistor and worked perfectly. He also made one for his friend. They were the only two people to pass that phase of the course. (I still have the device in my workshop).

                            I went to the TAFE to complain, had to make an appointment in writing then went to a meeting a week later with the head of the department, his assistant and the teacher in question. Was served nice coffee and biscuits and told that mistakes happen. I simply requested that the students who had failed be re-tested and refunded for the faulty meters,

                            It was only after I threatened to visit the local newspaper editor that they reluctantly agreed. I also asked the 'teacher' to explain how to calculate the value of the required shunt resistor. He could not – mumbled something like 'he never had his calculator with him'.

                            Sorry about the saga but it still makes me mad that such people are out there and protected by the system.

                            * Danny M *

                            #445636
                            Cabinet Enforcer
                            Participant
                              @cabinetenforcer

                              Danny, I don't really understand why you are complaining to the TAFE, they will obviously ignore you, why not make a complaint to your local H+S regulator, who might even have the actual power to do something???

                               

                              **LINK**

                               

                               

                              Or alternatively, Australian ad standards might also have some teeth they could use.

                               

                              https://adstandards.com.au/lodge-complaint

                               

                              Edited By Cabinet Enforcer on 10/01/2020 10:56:31

                              #445817
                              Danny M2Z
                              Participant
                                @dannym2z
                                Posted by Cabinet Enforcer on 10/01/2020 10:40:46:

                                Danny, I don't really understand why you are complaining to the TAFE, they will obviously ignore you, why not make a complaint to your local H+S regulator, who might even have the actual power to do something???

                                All resolved.

                                I received an email from the head of the department (my message got through) and he said that the young person in the video was wearing eye protection but being of the wrap around acrylic type they were indeed not easy to see.

                                This would be addressed in any future videos and he assured me that OH&S is taken very seriously at the TAFE.

                                I am satisfied with this and plan to visit the TAFE to further investigate what courses they are offering and to check out what sort of equipment they have.

                                I shall get back.

                                * Danny M *

                                #445887
                                Hopper
                                Participant
                                  @hopper

                                  OK Boomer. laugh

                                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                Latest Replies

                                Home Forums The Tea Room Topics

                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                View full reply list.