Drinking and Driving.

Advert

Drinking and Driving.

Home Forums The Tea Room Drinking and Driving.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 60 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #35177
    Roger Williams 2
    Participant
      @rogerwilliams2
      Advert
      #352501
      Roger Williams 2
      Participant
        @rogerwilliams2

        A rant about our useless drink driving sentences……

        My 43 yr old d…. head of a nephew was caught drink driving for the 4th time, 3 oclock in the afternoon, after crashing his van whilst asleep. 123mg / ****, well over. Just had his courtcase and sentenced as followed ; 32 month ban reduced to 2 years if he attends alcohol rehab course, 200 hrs c/ service and £ 175 fine, which includes court costs !!!!!!!!!!.

        The law really is an ass.

        #352504
        Michael Gilligan
        Participant
          @michaelgilligan61133

          If it was my choice, people like that would never drive again.

          … Some strategic amputations might do the job.

          MichaelG.

          .

          [my father was killed by a drunk driver]

          #352516
          mark costello 1
          Participant
            @markcostello1

            It's no better over here. Newspaper said 20+ convictions are not that rare.

            #352519
            Ady1
            Participant
              @ady1

              It's a probability trade off, the hope is that you learn and improve and become an asset instead of a liability to society. If you do law and order stuff there are an awful lot of muppets and people who do one off dumb stuff

              The USA tried the big stick system, three strikes and you're out

              One guy got life for stealing an ice cream off a kid, third strike mandatory rules

              Now the USA has the biggest prison population in the world, both in total and per 100,000 population

              You've less chance of going to jail in N Korea, Iran, China etc than the USA

              It would be nice if there was a system that works and made sense at the same time

              #352529
              Barnaby Wilde
              Participant
                @barnabywilde70941

                When I ran a recovery company we became aware of this poem through the industry & put a printed copy up in the secure area where folk would sort out the collection of their cars. Several Police forces have printed posters & used it in their campaigns over the years.

                The exact author is unknown, it is believed to have originated in Australia & it has been very highly pligiarised & passed off by many on the internets. This copy is I believe as close to the original as I can remember.

                I think that anyone who chooses to drink & drive should have their faces smashed into it.

                http://www.hendrickscountysso.com/pdf/MOM.pdf

                #352532
                Neil Wyatt
                Moderator
                  @neilwyatt

                  Is sentencing for preventing reoffending, deterrence, punishment or restorative justice?

                  It's one of the biggest conundrums any society faces.

                  Neil

                  #352534
                  Roger Williams 2
                  Participant
                    @rogerwilliams2

                    If it were up to me, the first time you are caught drinking and driving, banned for life. To be banned 4 times is a bloody farce. I know its easy to be " holier than thou ", but making a mistake whilst driving is easy enough without drink inside ones body, never mind being pissed !!.

                    #352540
                    Rainbows
                    Participant
                      @rainbows

                      Once read that the only difference between a murderer and a drunk driver is luck.

                      #352544
                      MW
                      Participant
                        @mw27036
                        Posted by Ady1 on 02/05/2018 15:21:59:

                        You've less chance of going to jail in N Korea, Iran, China etc than the USA

                        It would be nice if there was a system that works and made sense at the same time

                        To be fair, in those countries, especially north korea I don't think they would give you a full count of their real prison population even if that included the "re-education" camps where a lot of people die, for really stupid reasons, you can be prosecuted for just one of your family members doing something.

                        Michael W

                         

                        Edited By Michael-w on 02/05/2018 18:18:36

                        #352546
                        Ady1
                        Participant
                          @ady1

                          At the other end of the scale was a recent Philippines BBC article on some massive prison they have

                          They interviewed a guy who has been waiting 16 years for his robbery trial to even start

                          #352554
                          Mike Poole
                          Participant
                            @mikepoole82104

                            A few pints of beer makes you a fantastic driver, you may be the only person who thinks this though.

                            Mike

                            #352556
                            Ian Skeldon 2
                            Participant
                              @ianskeldon2

                              Having seen how well the go soft approach has worked over the last twenty years (failed completely IMHO) I would build more prisons and fill em with drink drivers etc.

                              My motivation would simply be to keep scum bags away from people like me so that they can no longer inflict misery onto normal members of society, a bit harsh, yeah maybe but all this pussy footing around is an insult to anyone who has ever suffered the injustice of crime to see the offender get handed down a joke sentence.

                              Oh and before I end, lets remeber that everyone of the offenders chose to walk that path, they were not forced to offend.

                              #352566
                              larry phelan 1
                              Participant
                                @larryphelan1

                                Any body who drinks and drives should be put off the road for all time,full stop,no second chances ! Their cars should be crushed as should be the cars of anyone foolish enough to provide them with cars.They should also be locked up for at least ten years,during which they should be required to attend every major road crash involving drink driving.

                                Needless to say,they should never,never be allowed on the road again,and I mean NEVER.!

                                I,m sick and tired reading and listening to the crap I hear about this scum,day after day,many a good dog was put down for far less, Make no mistake about it,they are nothing more than SCUM.!

                                #352569
                                Stephen Follows
                                Participant
                                  @stephenfollows82099

                                  Lifetime bans do no good, a lot of illegal drivers, (all offences), have no licence or insurance.

                                  #352585
                                  Ady1
                                  Participant
                                    @ady1

                                    There's a motivation issue

                                    The 2000-2008 Edinburgh Trams were about 8 miles and cost a Billion quid

                                    Anyone who was crap got a big pay-off and walked away

                                    Hadrians wall was 75 miles, had zero power tools or JCBs and took 5 years tops

                                    If you were crap you got crucified

                                    Draw your own conclusions

                                     

                                    edit: Bottom line is criminals get the soft touch and government eejits get rewarded

                                    Edited By Ady1 on 03/05/2018 00:50:52

                                    #352589
                                    Enough!
                                    Participant
                                      @enough
                                      Posted by Ady1 on 02/05/2018 15:21:59:

                                      It's a probability trade off, the hope is that you learn and improve and become an asset instead of a liability to society. If you do law and order stuff there are an awful lot of muppets and people who do one off dumb stuff

                                       

                                      I don't see why permanently removing someone's driving licence (for whatever reason) would make them a liability to society.

                                      "one off" …. I think you need to re-read the OP Ady.

                                      "dumb stuff" …. there's a big gap between dumb stuff and criminal behaviour endangering life. In my book anyway. If I sound intolerant, I am.

                                       

                                      Edited By Bandersnatch on 03/05/2018 01:18:51

                                      #352592
                                      Sam Longley 1
                                      Participant
                                        @samlongley1
                                        Posted by Neil Wyatt on 02/05/2018 16:43:36:

                                        Is sentencing for preventing reoffending, deterrence, punishment or restorative justice?

                                        It's one of the biggest conundrums any society faces.

                                        Neil

                                        You are referring to sentencing, not necessarily sending to prison, but taking it to the full step of internment & knowing that a the large part of the prison community is of a particular religious sector (have to be careful here not to break forum rules) It is a fact that a large proportion of those leaving prison are leaving "radicalised".

                                        Now I am not suggesting that a drunkard (& one can include any sector of the community & for any crime not just alcohol related) might be radicalised in a religious way but with the prison system breaking down to the extent that this can be allowed to happen, I can make a fair bet that the atmosphere is such that of those that are not radicalised in a religious way may well be radicalised in a criminal way.

                                        In other words i would not be surprised that instead of coming out having learned a lesson they are coming out with the attitude that they intend to be more " criminal" than when they went in.

                                        So when one reads in the media about the number of those released who go on to commit crimes, I am not sure that prison is actually working as a "deterrent". It is only any good for keeping really dangerous types away from the public for good, rather than being a means of preventing re-offending.

                                         

                                        Edited By Sam Longley 1 on 03/05/2018 07:39:29

                                        #352597
                                        Bill Pudney
                                        Participant
                                          @billpudney37759

                                          A long time ago I could walk to work. One day, on my journey, I came across the Fire Brigade washing down the pavement. I asked a Firey what was going on. He said a drunk driver had ploughed into a bus queue and it was a miracle that nobody had been killed, but there was a lot of blood. Up until then I had taken a fairly generous approach to drink driving (well I was young!!) Since then I have not drunk and driven, do not tolerate anyone who does, and have absolutely no sympathy for anyone who gets caught. Bring back the stocks I say!! Sounds a trivial punishment but it's not intended to be.

                                          cheers

                                          Bill

                                          #352600
                                          Mick B1
                                          Participant
                                            @mickb1
                                            Posted by Bill Pudney on 03/05/2018 08:38:31:

                                            Bring back the stocks I say!! Sounds a trivial punishment but it's not intended to be.

                                            cheers

                                            Bill

                                            That'll only work where there is still:

                                            i) a sense of coherence in the community, and

                                            ii) a sense of shame in the individual.

                                            #352601
                                            Hopper
                                            Participant
                                              @hopper

                                              Fourth time the nephew in the OP has been done? Fell asleep at the wheel? If he's that slow a learner it's unlikely the stocks would make any difference.

                                               

                                              Edited By Hopper on 03/05/2018 09:31:21

                                              #352605
                                              SillyOldDuffer
                                              Moderator
                                                @sillyoldduffer

                                                Interesting to see the desire to inflict severe punishment on drunk-drivers now I've decided to run the country and need to whip up popular support. Quite, right, string em' up from the nearest lamp-post I say!

                                                But chaps, when I'm in charge, you will find I have even stronger views on speeding. If I catch you speeding, it will be a mandatory thrashing and public humiliation before lynching puts you out of your misery. And to make sure drivers understand, punishment will include sending the offenders entire family to a Work Camp.

                                                Mealy mouthed liberal intellectuals might consider my views a little extreme. But someone has to take a grip. Reasons why society must take a hard-line on speeding include:

                                                • Just like alcohol, speeding is one the main factors in fatal road accidents.
                                                • Unlike drunks, whose normal judgement has been impaired by a drug, there is no excuse for speeding; the offence is entirely deliberate.
                                                • Stand by any roadside and see for yourself that drivers rarely obey the law. A speed limit is the maximum allowed, not the target. Watch and you will see it is rare to see traffic travelling at less than the limit, which proves that most drivers are habitual law breakers. And if they break the law on the road, then they will break it elsewhere; drivers are anarchists. Responsible motorists travelling below the speed limit are often bullied by aggressive and inconsiderate road-users proving that most drivers are vicious. You must conclude that car drivers are a bad lot who need to be corrected.
                                                • The consequences of law-breaking are all too often evaded by offenders exploiting our weak justice system. We must put an end to this: there is no reason at all why Traffic Wardens shouldn't dispense summary justice up to and including the death penalty.

                                                Severe punishment at minimum cost to the tax-payer is the way to fix this scandal. By the way, I'm an expert. I've read Dostoevsky on Crime and Punishment; and I watched an excellent documentary about policing in the US – a chap called Judge Dredd is doing a marvellous job over there. Also mother taught me right from wrong and she reads the Daily Mail.

                                                Vote for Silly Old Duffer! What could possibly go wrong… smiley

                                                 

                                                 

                                                Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 03/05/2018 09:31:10

                                                Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 03/05/2018 09:32:46

                                                #352607
                                                duncan webster 1
                                                Participant
                                                  @duncanwebster1

                                                  Hear Hear

                                                  when I'm the benevolent despot, speed cameras will be multiplied and camouflaged, BUT there will be a general review of speed limits as some are set lower than they need to be, and there will be some pragmatism, speeding past a school at 2am does not really pose a safety issue, at 8:45 am it does

                                                  Old guys rule OK!

                                                  #352608
                                                  Mike
                                                  Participant
                                                    @mike89748

                                                    Is Silly Old Duffer speaking with tongue in cheek, or not? Personally, I'm totally fed up with soft sentences for drunk drivers, speeders, child molesters, and other parasites. And as for those who make excuses for them, I can do without bleeding-heart liberals in my life.

                                                    #352609
                                                    Zebethyal
                                                    Participant
                                                      @zebethyal

                                                      A former work colleague of mine had a radical idea for the prison system to deter re-offence, and that was to outsource the prison system to Turkey/Thailand!

                                                      First offence – a suitable fine (slap on the wrist) along with community service (make them give back to the community).

                                                      Any subsequent offences – you go to Bang Kwang in Thailand or Diyarbakir in Turkey, for extending periods of time starting with a 1 month period.

                                                      His view was that prison in this country is more like a hotel that is paid for by the tax payer – where is the incentive to improve and not re-offend, many of the prisoners would prefer to be inside that out, which is why they re-offend within weeks of leaving!

                                                      He appreciated that there would also need to be some level of oversight, such that you are not sending someone off to Big Tiger (Bang Kwang) for stealing an ice cream, or some other such misdomeaner.

                                                      Edited By Zebethyal on 03/05/2018 10:00:57

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 60 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums The Tea Room Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up