Emco FB2 Quirks and Additions

Emco FB2 Quirks and Additions

Home › Forums › Manual machine tools › Emco FB2 Quirks and Additions

Viewing 4 posts - 101 through 104 (of 104 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #871406
    mgnbuk
    Participant
      @mgnbuk

      Mine broke when I was facing at 1200rpm, 1mm depth of cut in steel (355N/mm2) with a 40mm cutter with 3 carbide inserts.

      That was optimistic !

      Not surprised the gear gave up at that.

      I am on my second Taiwanese FB2 clone. The first had a brass gear fitted by the original owner after he had lost enthusiasm for paying £100+ (30 years ago) for replacement fibre gears & had a friend in a gear company make a brass replacement (and a spare I still have). I made up an arbor to hold a 40mm 3 flute insert face cutter for that machine and used it once – not happy with the noises coming out of the gearbox, even with the brass gear !

      Current machine still on it’s factory fibre gear after 25 years + – but not used inserted cutters on it (prefer HSS cutters – mainly 3 flute coated end mills –  in 2MT collets), rarely use a fly cutter & always use the awkward spanner to hold the spindle when using the drawbar.

      John MC – cutting a replacement helical gear from another material is an option, if you have the tooling and machinery to do so. Difficult, though, if the only mill you have is the one that requires the replacement gear.

      If a 3D replacement can be quickly and inexpensively produced (my test items take about an hour to print at 100% infill & use less than 50g of filament that costs around £10 kilo) that will work at least as well as the original Tufnol gear, then why not use this route ? Feedback from Richard for a PETG gear is that the machine runs more quietly with this than the fibre original, but durability is yet to be determined.

      Jim – thanks for the feedback. Did you anneal the nylon print after printing ? Seen filament testing videos that suggest that PA6 gains strength from annealing (100C for about an hour IIRC). Hoping that “Black Friday” will have offers that make an enclosed heated chamber printer with a higher temp hot end affordable to play with “engineering” filaments.

      Nigel B.

      #871454
      engineeredbyhansson
      Participant
        @engineeredbyhansson
        Jim – thanks for the feedback. Did you anneal the nylon print after printing ? Seen filament testing videos that suggest that PA6 gains strength from annealing (100C for about an hour IIRC). Hoping that “Black Friday” will have offers that make an enclosed heated chamber printer with a higher temp hot end affordable to play with “engineering” filaments.

        Nigel B.

         

        No I didn’t anneal it afterwards. It holds up very well still, but I don’t take that heavy cuts anymore. More like 0,5mm at 680rpm maximum.

        I printed my gear in a Bambu Lab P1S  so nothing fancy. Let it heat soak for a while and don’t open until it has properly cooled down. 3D printing the gear is probably the most economical way. I actually tried PETG first, but it’s too brittle. Mine broke after just some medium cuts..

        Jim

        #871537
        John MC
        Participant
          @johnmc39344

          Nigel B., my suggestion was for a properly engineered long term solution to a possible problem.  I would guess that very few home workshops have the equipment that can generate gear forms so it would need to be done by a third party.

          Expensive?  Possibly,  I recently had 6 steel (EN36) gears hobbed and heat treated for a little over £400. I thought this to be good value.  What kept the cost down was making the the (non-standard splined) mandrels for mounting in the hobbing machine.

          #871578
          Graham Meek
          Participant
            @grahammeek88282

            One of the reasons for publishing the details of the gear and showing how I did it on my BF2. Was to allow others to have the opportunity to make a spare, or two.

            The cost was zero as the materials were all to hand. Plus I had the pleasure of making the part and proving an approximation for a Helical Gear would work.

            I have always found if you have a spare part it is never needed, but one never knows especially if the machine is purchased second hand.

            Regards

            Gray,

          Viewing 4 posts - 101 through 104 (of 104 total)
          • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

          Latest Replies

          Home › Forums › Manual machine tools › Topics

          Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
          Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

          View full reply list.