This thread prompted me to measure my Boxford dials. The cross slide is 1.5″ dia but the top slide is 1.6″ – I’ve always assumed they were the same but now they do look different. But then I measured my spare topslide ……1.4″.
1/10″ between ticks would be nice and readable into my old age = 10″ circumference. That would be nearly 3″ dia. maybe a bit big. So 2.5″ might be enough giving 2mm between ticks.