Posted by Michael Walters on 12/08/2016 11:04:10:
I always thought the whole idea of a reamer was to create a fixed absolute size. The whole idea of adjustability in that seems bizzare to me. Although they could be useful for cleaning out holes, i can't see myself using them to create an absolute size if i can't set it right anyway. Each to their own but i'll stick to HSS ones thanks.
Michael W
Edited By Michael Walters on 12/08/2016 11:05:26
Normal reamers do create a hole with a certain tolerance and can leave a decent finish if they are sharp.
Adjustable ones are a bit mixed. Differing tightness on the nut can even produce a different sized hole but that's not the main problem. Try measuring diameters over several pairs of blades. They are often all over the place in terms of reamer type tolerances and that can even change when they are adjusted. The lead in is also often a bit short for hand use. Some have a smooth portion on the end intended to act as a guide. I have never had much luck with one of those but maybe I should have used a square to keep checking that the reamer was still axial.
Both types have another problem. If the drilled hole isn't true to the axis of the reamer when it's used the hole is unlikely to come out correct.
There can be another problem as well which isn't as obvious. The part that's been pushed into a reamed hole might not be round. If the parts have a very close fit lathe roundness errors can mess it up..It doesn't take much of an error. Same applies in different way to reamers that aren't running dead true.
I've seen suggestions in ME that precision work should be done on a tailstock drill plate. Assuming that this will all be dead true. Pity decent sized drill plates aren't still around. They are assuming that this set up will be better than many home owned drilling machines. It could be.
You might say bad workers blame the tools but sometime the problem is the tools and not the user.
John
–