Model Engineer & Workshop

Model Engineer & Workshop

Home Forums Model Engineer & Workshop Model Engineer & Workshop

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #864061
    Tony Watson 3
    Participant
      @tonywatson3

      I’m sitting here looking at the full run of ME from 1898 and of MEW from 1990 sitting on my bookshelves.  I’ve also decided not to renew my current subscription.

      I can only fall back on that old adage – ‘If you can’t say something good about something say nothing’…..

      #864088
      noel shelley
      Participant
        @noelshelley55608

        Hi Tony, I also have a large collection of ME ! I renew now more out of loyalty and that by supporting it I will help it continue – but I’m no longer sure why ? Who cares ? Noel.

        #864089
        Trevor Drabble 1
        Participant
          @trevordrabble1

          I also used to subscribe , but then dropped to  maybe 4/5 issues p.a. but then , after repeatedly travelling the considerable distance to my local WHS (as was ) ,  and failing to obtain any copies I contacted the publishers asking for a publication date in order to improve my chances , and was told they didn’t have a publication date but that I could order individual copies direct . Since I preferred to make any choices based on looking at the articles before purchase , I therefore decided not to bother. It seems to me that they are really only interested in electronic copies , which isn’t for me , hence yet another regrettable drop in paper copies of the magazine.

          #864090
          Andrew Crow
          Participant
            @andrewcrow91475

            Like you Noel, I continue with my subscription to hopefully keep the magazine going in the hope that it might inspire more younger people to get involved, although I think in the longer term it may become an on line publication only.

            By supporting the magazine we also keep this forum going.

            Andy.

            #864113
            Robert Butler
            Participant
              @robertbutler92161

              Many years ago I purchased ME regularly but found the workshop items were my sole reason for buying the magazine and decided this was no longer worthwhile. That is not to detract from the highly skilled and dedicated model engineer contributors.

              i discovered MEW shortly after the first issue and purchased every copy having the full set. However MEW for the last few years was falling short compared to earlier issues and I was intending to stop buying the magazine. When M E & W replaced both publications I deferred my decision.

              M E & W now is much as M E used to be and there is insufficient content of interest to me and so it is highly likely i will purchase for much longer.

              Robert Butler

               

              #864118
              Clive Foster
              Participant
                @clivefoster55965

                Similarly to Andy my primary reason for keeping my subscription going is to retain access to the forum.

                Like Tony I have a complete set of MEW and a significant ME collection, only back to 1964 tho’. I think a fall off of interest by long term subscribers is inevitable due mostly to steadily increasing personal experience and inevitable changes of interests over the years. In the beginning all is new with plenty to learn so a considerable regular novelty helps retain interest well beyond what you actually intend to do or use. Years also add to the personal stock of things. Having bought or built a satisfactory widget inevitable repetition of “useful things” means the fourth or fifth edition is just wasted space.

                My minimum criteria for subscription for the last few years has been an average of one article per month of sufficient interest to go on the might re-read, might make or might steal bits from piles. Not been met for the last half decade, or maybe longer, but one or two stand-outs have just tipped the scales. Decided to give it another couple of years post amalgamation before a final decision.

                I’m a widget person, working primarily in 12 inch to the foot scale, rather than model person which doesn’t help the editors job. Model folk inevitably have more interest in a well executed model, or for that matter clock, than I would.

                Really ought to try and do something with the 6 or so half started articles living in the computer memory.

                Clive

                #864125
                John Haine
                Participant
                  @johnhaine32865

                  It’s worth checking if your library has digital access via (for example) the Libby platform, and subscribes to ME&W.  The Cambridge one does and I scan each issue as it becomes available.  Over the last 18 months or so nothing has interested me enough to read any of the articles. My impression is that ME ate MEW and is becoming even more repetitive and boring. This forum has more of interest but has noticeably declined in posting frequency over the last year or so.

                Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
                • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                Latest Replies

                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                View full reply list.