Lathe run out

Advert

Lathe run out

Home Forums General Questions Lathe run out

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 77 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #544297
    Robin
    Participant
      @robin

      My lathe is turning tapers where I do not want tapers sad

      34" of overhang in the 3 jaw chuck. At the far end it has 0.01" of runout on the DTI, not bad for a rusty old bar of 1" cold rolled.

      However the far end is 0.25mm forward and 1.11mm below where the tailstock wants it. This may or may not agree with the test spec. that came with the machine, they forget to define their units, could be Siamese.

      If I face down a bar leaving a tiny nub in the middle and then dent it with a hard center, I find the tailstock is fractionally low and forward. Unfortunately making everything worse not better.

      Could it be in need of levelling? I never bothered. Seems unlikely but could the uneven garage floor be twisting it?

      The "head stock" appears to be held on by 4 chunky screws. I cannot see any taper pins locking in the misalignment.

      Should I send out for shim and start rotating until it turns cylinders, or, would loosening the four bolts be a huge mistake? surprise

      I never offset a tailstock in my life for taper turning so I am quite hapy to shim it for the vertical alignment.

      Decisions, decisions… What would you do? Has anyone dared loosen those bolts? How did it go?

      Advert
      #28160
      Robin
      Participant
        @robin

        To fix or leave alone?

        #544298
        bernard towers
        Participant
          @bernardtowers37738

          Not sure where you’re coming from.? When is it turning tapers chuck mounted or tailstock supported

          #544299
          Pete Rimmer
          Participant
            @peterimmer30576

            34" of 1" bar is basically a noodle. It could be anywhere. Even if it were held by the tailstock centre it would still not turn parallel because the centre would whip. This is a time that you need to use a travelling steady.

            Edited By Pete Rimmer on 10/05/2021 18:47:57

            #544301
            Journeyman
            Participant
              @journeyman

              There are plenty of threads on here about lathe alignment (often called lathe levelling). DO NOT undo the four headstock bolts that hold the headstock to the bed – Here Be Dragons.

              The long bar is useless as either an indicator or as a means of alignment. Need basically to take any twist from the bed caused by uneven floor before doing anything else, this is done without use of the tailstock.

              Once untwisted the tailstock can be checked for alignment .

              John

              #544302
              Zan
              Participant
                @zan

                “not bad for a rusty old bar of 1" cold rolled.” So did you run the dti all along the bar at the front and on the top? Bet it won’t be held true in the Chuck and it will probably be bent accounting for the difference and this bar even if short  will not be held true due to the rust and  rolling tolerance, it’s not an accurate material 

                is the runout you quote on the rotating bar?
                As said above you need tailstock support and a travelling steady

                have you done the standard bobbin turning test to check for any bed twist?

                have you done the between centres test to check the tailstock position?

                moving the headstock will not be easy due I think it being sat on the v ways on the bed

                tread slowly!

                 

                Edited By Zan on 10/05/2021 19:01:31

                #544305
                Robin
                Participant
                  @robin

                  I was trying to turn 5" of 1" hex steel down to 17mm to fit some bearings and stuff. They didn't go on very far, it got fatter approaching the chuck. Like me, fatter. The tailstock was quite extended due to a DRO scale, not much chance of it forcing a 17mm steel bar into alignment sad

                  #544307
                  Robin
                  Participant
                    @robin

                    I could try it on 3 feet, a tripod, that only involves sticking in a bit of broom handle under the light end so it can rock.

                    #544309
                    Robin
                    Participant
                      @robin

                      The headstock appears to sit on a flat plate which is part of the bed. Two bolts from above, two from below.

                      #544318
                      Dave S
                      Participant
                        @daves59043

                        Do you have a trusted dead centre?
                        I am assuming, as it looks like a fairly new lathe that bed wear can be ignored.

                        Chuck a short piece of scrapbinium ( something like 10mm diameter or so with 1 diameter stick out) and turn a point on it. Move the tailstock up.

                        compare points. They should line up exactly in both planes. Trapping a 6” ruler between them is an often mentioned way to amplify any offset, but I’ve never done that. If they match it’s fairly easy to see with a good light and some magnification (I use an optivisor).

                        IAssuming that the points do match you know the tailstock lines are up.
                        The headstock might still not be aligned with the ways, or the ways may be twisted.

                        I had a Harrison L5 not on a cast stand, so it stood on the headstock plinth and a 2 legged tailstock support.

                        IIRC it needed about 50 thou of shim to turn parallel. That was stood on a smooth level concrete floor, and L5s are not exactly “lightweight” – probably a chunk stiffer than your modern lathe.

                        look up the 2 collar test – and do it with a sufficiently large diameter that the bar is stiff enough to not deflect significantly.

                        I don’t know how stiff the cabinet stand is, but you can shim under it or under where the bed bolts to it.

                        I would not touch the headstock bolts until a great deal more measuring and checking has been done. Then *if* you

                        do need to at least you’ll know why.

                        Dave

                        #544322
                        Pete Rimmer
                        Participant
                          @peterimmer30576

                          If I were you I would:

                          Check the bed for straightness with a sensitive level. Adjust to suit (if it's possible). If you have no level or it's not adjustable (maybe it's on three feet) just carry on down this list.

                          Chuck up a stout piece of ally in the chuck (perhaps 2" dia and 6" long) take skim passes and check for parallel. If the bed is not twisted and the part dosn't turn parallel then you have no choice but to loosen the headstock and adjust.

                          Once you have it turning parallel time to adjust the tailstock. Measure the tailstock ram with a micrometer. Turn the piece in the chuck to the same diameter. Bring the tailstock up to the part you have turned.

                          Put a mag base on the saddle with a tenth-reading dial gauge. Put the dial gauge against the side of the ram and move the saddle so it crosses over to the turned bar. It should read the same. If it doesn't adjust using the off-setting adjuster until it does.

                          Now do the same but running the dial gauge along the top of the parts. If the tailstock is low shim between the body and base to suit. Check the ram is level with the dial gauge or very slightly rising (never falling).

                          If you do all that you'll be about as good as you can get.

                          #544345
                          Robin
                          Participant
                            @robin

                            I think Pete has it. I want to turn a cylinder so the obvious test is to turn a cylinder.

                            However, that means it must be nutted down tight which rathe precludes adjustment.

                            Perhaps turn the truncated cone it is set for.

                            Put a DTI on the tool post, which will show perfectly straight.

                            Adjust it until the DTI shows the correct error.

                            But first, I am moving into uncharted territory, I am not a shim person…

                            These are the bolts holding the headstock down at the front

                            I have cleaned the plaster and paint away from where the shim will go. Don't want to do a Hubble.

                            The shim will be 0.26mm thick, 180mm long, have two 12mm clearance holes for those bolts, centred 16mm back from the front edge.

                            How wide should it be? I see problems for both too much and too little. Is there a best practice? thinking

                            #544353
                            Hopper
                            Participant
                              @hopper

                              STOP! STOP! STOP!

                              You are putting the cart way before the horse and getting several separate issues mixed up. Moving your headstock is an absolute last resort and should be avoided if at all possible. It is rarely needed.

                              Your tailstock is adjustable and is usually adjusted to match the headstock, not vice versa.

                              First, you need to realise there are two taper turning causes, with two tests and two solutions:

                              1. Bed Alignment.  Stick a piece of 1" diameter bar in the chuck with about 4 to 6" sticking out. NO tailstock centre in place for this test. Take a fine finishing cut along the length of it and measure the job for taper. It should be within a thou or less (0.025mm). If it's not, the adjustment is made by shimming ONE of the mounting feet where the lathe attaches to the bench, at the tailstock end. This "twists" the bed to get it aligned to your headstock spindle axis.

                              2. Tailstock Alignment. Stick a short piece of bar in the chuck and turn a 60 degree point on it as close to the chuck as possible. Then put a known good centre in the tailstock and slide it up so the two points almost meet. Pinch a thin steel ruler between the two points, with the quill extended about the amount you normally use it at. The steel ruler should stand up vertical and also should lay square to the main lathe axis when viewed from above. If it does not, adjustment is done by adjustment bolts or screws in the tailstock base that move it from side to side. If the tailstock centre is lower than the headstock centre, you will have to put shim between the base and main body of the tailstock to bring it up to headstock spindle level. Further fine adustment is made by turning a piece of 1" diameter bar 6 to 12" long between centres and measuring the resulting taper after a fine cut. Adjust tailstock offset until less than a thou of taper.

                               

                              The best and simplest written/pictorial description of how how set up your lathe's bed alignment and tailstock alignment I have seen is in the front of the Myford ML7 Owners Manual. PDF copies are available free all over the net. It applies to all lathes, not just Myfords. You should read it carefully before adjusting anything. It gives two ways of doing the bed alignment, using either an expensive precision level, or by the simple turning test outlined in 1. above, which is all I ever use in the home workshop. Then they describe the tailstock alignment by turning test as in 2. above.

                              The test you have described with a very long piece of unmachined bar does not really give an accurate reading of anything. Ditto mounting a DTI on the toolpost at this stage. Do the above tests 1 and 2 before adjusting anything and you will at least know where you are starting from . At first blush it sounds like your main problem is a tailstock that needs adjusting. You may possibly not have to do any more than that.

                               

                               

                              Edited By Hopper on 11/05/2021 04:37:28

                              #544360
                              Tony Pratt 1
                              Participant
                                @tonypratt1

                                I strongly suggest you listen to Hopper!!

                                Tony

                                #544362
                                JasonB
                                Moderator
                                  @jasonb

                                  Do the tests Hopper suggests and make sure the tool is sharp so you get zero deflection of work and tool

                                  You say the tailstock is forward of the "dent" you make with the ctrsurprise this can simply be cured by adjusting it horizontally and this will likely get rid of the taper you describe turning as the tailstock end will now be thicker.

                                  From the same test you say the tailstock is low. So pack up the tailstock, can't see why you are packing the head up as that will make it worse.

                                  Edited By JasonB on 11/05/2021 07:45:17

                                  #544363
                                  Dave S
                                  Participant
                                    @daves59043

                                    Re reading my post it isn’t clear that the 50 thou of shim was on the floor, under one of the tailstock end feet.

                                    I wouldn’t touch the headstock until proven that it needs it. Then again it’s your machine. I recently took the spindle on my surface grinder to pieces to reset the end play, even tho the “internet” said don’t do it, that’s never a problem and your poor surface is caused by “xyz”

                                    However I did all the tests and measurements to be certain that was the issue and went ahead and fixed it.

                                    Now grinds beautifully.

                                    Do the legwork first and eliminate the obvious things.

                                    Dave

                                    #544388
                                    Hopper
                                    Participant
                                      @hopper
                                      Posted by Robin on 10/05/2021 19:07:07:

                                      I was trying to turn 5" of 1" hex steel down to 17mm to fit some bearings and stuff. They didn't go on very far, it got fatter approaching the chuck.

                                      BTW, how much taper are we talking about on this 5" long job? What are the diameters at each end as turned?

                                      #544428
                                      Robin
                                      Participant
                                        @robin

                                        This listening to good advice trick really works, I must do it more often.

                                        I removed all twist from the bed by replacing the oak block with a steel roller.

                                        I turned 6" of steel down without the tailstock and measured the ends 25.14 and 24.975

                                        It tapers 0.165mm, 0.0065 inches.

                                        Pretty crappy BUT it's going the other way.

                                        Somewhere between what I had and what I have now lies perfection.

                                        I think I feel a quest coming on face 22

                                        #544440
                                        Tony Pratt 1
                                        Participant
                                          @tonypratt1

                                          Robin, your 'roller' is actually a tube, I would suggest taking out all the bits & pieces & let the stand sit directly on the concrete floor, then just shim/pack the corner[s] to remove rocking & also bring level if you want. You can then proceed to add appropriate shims between the lathe bed tail stock end [front or back] & the stand so the lathe cuts parallel. I strongly suggest you read the Myford manual so you understand what is going on. P.S. Just replacing the wood block with a roller tube may or may not eliminate lathe bed twist.

                                          Tony

                                          Edited By Tony Pratt 1 on 11/05/2021 15:13:01

                                          #544444
                                          ChrisH
                                          Participant
                                            @chrish

                                            Robin, at the risk at sounding a bit Irish (no offense intended to the Irish of course) your lathe does not have to be level to be level. By which I mean, the lathe bed has to be level to itself but not necessarily perfectly horizontally level.

                                            That is why people suggest using a sensitive and accurate engineering level across the bed – it needs to be reading a constant anywhere along the bed, but the bed doesn't have to be level to any horizontal line.

                                            Consider a lathe on a ship, That lathe bed is very rarely if ever level to the horizontal, but providing the bed has been set level to itself all along the bed then it will turn true.

                                            Just saying!

                                            Chris

                                            #544461
                                            Journeyman
                                            Participant
                                              @journeyman

                                              If not already done the cabinet stand should preferably be bolted to the floor. These stands are not particularly stiff compared to the lathe bed and trying to shim the tailstock end of the bed to the cabinet is just as likely to move the cabinet as untwist the bed.

                                              As Tony says above, get the cabinet as level as needed (doesn't have to be perfect and you may want to slope the tray to the suds drain point) shim under the cabinet feet to stop it rocking then bolt it to the floor. You now have a solid immoveable foundation from which to untwist the lathe bed. Loosen the tailstock end bolts between cabinet and bed, slide in shims as required, tighten bolts and test. Repeat as necessary turning and checking the test bar between tries. If the right hand end of the test piece is bigger than the left hand end put a shim under the front tailstock foot and of course 'vice versa' shouldn't take more than a couple of goes to get it bang on.

                                              John

                                              #544467
                                              Ian Skeldon 2
                                              Participant
                                                @ianskeldon2

                                                Hi Robin,

                                                I feel your pain, I have been there and done that as they say. I agree that if your lathe is not sitting securely with the head and bed lined up you will have the sort of problems you are currently getting, I started out with the same problem on my DB10. Don't get me wrong, it wasn't out by much, but it was out and giving a slight taper. I used the ‘Rolly’s Dad Method’ as it is sometimes referred to which amounts to twisting the bed slightly. At first I thought that it had provided the cure and that my lathe could not have been set up truly in the first place. However, I produced some test pieces and found that I had exchanged my taper cut for a bobbin effect whereby the centre of the piece is narrower and thus more material has been removed from the central area of the work when compared to the chuck or tail end, again we are talking very small discrepancies but I wanted as good as I could get. So looking again what was happening and the penny dropped, in twisting the bed the tool travels along a helix around the workpiece, in my case the tool was slightly higher than the workpiece centre line at the start of the cut, on the centre line of the work in the middle of the cut and then slightly lower than centre at the chuck end of the cut. So when the tool was cutting the middle part of the cut it was removing very slightly more material and hence producing a bobbin effect. Altering the amount of twist resulted in either the taper returning or a greater bobbin effect. I suppose I should really have left it at that but it ate away at me, in the end I decided to take the head off and check it, I very carefully and very lightly scraped the corner I thought was causing the problem and then reassembled the lathe, BINGO, no taper and no bobbin or any other problems or was there?

                                                So happy that I could cut normally using the feed and carriage etc I decided to look at the rarely used top slide, I wish I hadn’t, it runs downhill so when wound back towards the tail the tool is higher than when it is wound forward towards the chuck, I used a shim to provide a temporary fix and to my shame it is still there, one day I will get it re-ground ….maybe.

                                                #544483
                                                Phil Whitley
                                                Participant
                                                  @philwhitley94135

                                                  Hi All,

                                                  here we go down the rabbit hole again! A couple of observations:

                                                  First, never enter this rabbit hole unless the lathe is not producing the parts you need to the accuracy you require.

                                                  With an engineers level, check across the bed at either end, and shim the cabinet untill the readings are as near identical as possible. you need to shim at four points, front and rear, at the headstock and tailstock end. The idea of this is to twist the bed into as near perfect alignment as possible. this process is best done over a few days to allow the bed to settle, and then be checked again, when you are happy with this, proceed as follows

                                                  It is pointless to try to align using the three jaw chuck, the very best of which are usually at least 3 thou out WHEN NEW!

                                                  Remove the chuck, check and clean the spindle bore, fit the bush and a known good centre, and then put a DTI on the spindle, and then on the centre.

                                                  If there is run out on the spindle, tighten headstock bearings to eliminate it.

                                                  If there is runout on the centre, remove the centre and bush, check the bore again, check the bore in the bush, and re seat the bush and the centre.

                                                  Buy a test bar,, remove the centre from the headstock and fit the test bar in its place, and check with dti at the remote end, you may need to remove and reseat the test bar till you get the absolute minimum possible run out.

                                                  Place the DTI on the saddle with its foot on the front of the test bar at centre height, and wind the saddle from the headstock towards the tailstock, If the headstock is misaligned you should see the DTI needle move steadily in one direction, if the reading is erratic, you may be looking at bed wear.

                                                  Take note of the runout at the remote end, rotate the spindle 90deg, and try again, note the reading and repeat till you get the spindle back to its original position.

                                                  You should now have a good idea about headstock to bed alignment, and will be able to make a decision as to whether you need to realign the headstock front to back, and whether the bed is worn or not

                                                  Now move the Dti to the top of the test bar and test from headstock towards the tailstock to see if the test bar is parralell to the bed, again be aware that you are looking for a constant downward or upward trend, and any erratic movement in the needle may be bed wear.

                                                  You now have a good idea whether you need to shim the headstock to correct any "nod" in the alignment.

                                                  You will usually find that by slackening the headstock bolts slightly, and bumping the headstock with a soft faced mallet in the desired direction, front to back alignment can be corrected.

                                                  Sometimes, selective retightening of the bolts can correct up or down nod, but if not you will have to shim, or scrape, but it may be a case of removing the headstock, cleaning the plate it sits on, identifiying and removing any dings or burrs with a flat stone or small scraper.

                                                  Now you have the spindle sorted and the headstock alignment as accurate as possible, you can move on to the tailstock. Whilst any of the above tailstock methods will work, I usually put my best centre in the tailstock, and with a dti on the side of the test bar, wind the centre into the centre drilling whilst watching the reading. Any discrepancy here can be corrected with the tailstock alignment screws.

                                                  Now repeat with the DTI on top of the test bar, and you will see if you need to shim the tailstock, by how much, and whether it needs to nod down or up.

                                                  Now move on to the turning tests ans see what results you get!

                                                  I must add that this is the way I do it, based on as much logic as I can muster at the particular moment. I am not suggesting that you go this far, indeed, you should only correct a fault if it occurs, and not go looking for trouble, because it is all to easy to imagine there is a problem. As I said at the top, only dive down the rabbit hole if your machine is unable to make the parts you want to the accuracy you require, and I will add to that that most lathes and associated chucks/tooling etc benefit from a complete strip down, clean, debur, lubricate, and carefull reassembly

                                                  The best of luck!

                                                  Phil

                                                  #544518
                                                  Hopper
                                                  Participant
                                                    @hopper
                                                    Posted by Robin on 11/05/2021 14:18:15:

                                                    This listening to good advice trick really works, I must do it more often.

                                                    I removed all twist from the bed by replacing the oak block with a steel roller.

                                                    I turned 6" of steel down without the tailstock and measured the ends 25.14 and 24.975

                                                    It tapers 0.165mm, 0.0065 inches.

                                                    Pretty crappy BUT it's going the other way.

                                                    Somewhere between what I had and what I have now lies perfection.

                                                    I think I feel a quest coming on face 22

                                                    Very good!

                                                    It looks like you might be best to replace the two wooden riser blocks with a couple bits of 4" square steel tubing, thick walled etc. Bolt them to the floor and then bolt the lathe cabinet to the square tube, after inserting suitable shims to stop any rocking if the lathe is not sitting flat on the tubes at all 4 points. Then you can start your turning tests and shim either the cabinet base or the lathe base accordingly to get a nice straight cut.

                                                    Some of these larger Chinese lathes I have seen have some very thin cross sectional areas along the bed just below the ways, so can be quite flexible. They are nowhere near as rigid as they appear at first glance. I was recently looking at a bed repair done to one that fell off the back of a truck — literally — and the casting below the front way was only 9mm thick, so weak under load or twisting forces etc. This one had snapped clean off.

                                                    Another thing you should check on yours: It looks in the pics like you have a removable gap piece in the bed at the left hand end. These can cause trouble if the securing bolts and dowels come loose. There are two tapered dowel pins that locate it. Each has a threaded section on top with a nut for extraction. I can see one of them in your first pic. You need to loosen the nut and gently tap the threaded section with a brass drift to make sure the tapered dowel is "home". Then check tightness on the allen bolts holding the gap piece down. And check the removeable piece is not obviously misaligned at the join on the bed ways etc.

                                                    It's best not to remove the gap piece unnecessarily as they can be a pain to get seated correctly again. If you do, make sure all burrs and grit and swarf are meticulously removed before reassembly.

                                                    #544653
                                                    Chris Mate
                                                    Participant
                                                      @chrismate31303

                                                      New here but always interested in this topic…
                                                      Am I right to roughly assume the following:
                                                      -As soon as you bolt the lathe Headstock-to-Bed combination(Maybe new from factory) down to something, in most cases the cabinet, your bed twist is linked to that, if all that weight is placed on the cement floor the Bed straightness/twist is linked to the cabinet and weight pulling it down to floor, so the bed is naturally not as straight as at the factory without the cabinet as grinded. So now you always forced to shim it at some stage of the fitment.

                                                      I my case I fitted a 12mm steel plate(70Kg) between cabinet and lathe bed, forcing me to shim it at the bed end points to cut a testpiece sticking out straight, luckily not at the headstock side, it took some time(Long).
                                                      I bolted the cabinet to the floor as well, but did not do my adjustment at the floor due to the plate stronger than the cabinet

                                                      Edited By Chris Mate on 12/05/2021 19:46:47

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 77 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up