Posted by SillyOldDuffer on 26/05/2019 13:00:17:
Posted by Neil Wyatt on 26/05/2019 12:27:16:
Posted by Nicholas Farr on 26/05/2019 08:34:46:
Hi Neil, nice piece of kit. What size are the units in the combo and power rating?
Regards Nick.
Combo is the classic 4×10" but the original celestions have been replaced with Eminence Alpha 10As rated 100W each. The cab on top is 2×12" Mackenzies (not sure but probably 100W each).
That's the original Trace Elliot GP11 Mk V combo so it's an apparently feeble 150 watts, but they have a reputation for being very loud and I am sure it's as loud or louder than an 500W ashdown amp and head I played with recently.
Trace gave very conservative ratings and headroom is more important than RMS for bass. The power supply is easily sufficient to put around 400 watts into 4 ohms. Today that would probably mean an amp with a sticker saying "1000 watts"…
Neil
Edited By Neil Wyatt on 26/05/2019 12:30:30
This table from Hyperphysics lists the power outputs of various instruments and rates a large orchestra at under 70W. I'm always a bit surprised how weedy musical instruments are. Are big amplifiers only needed because loudspeaker efficiencies are so low, or is it because rock and roll sounds best with the Volume at 11?
Source
|
Power Output (watts)
|
Large orchestra |
67
|
Bass drum |
25
|
Snare drum |
12
|
Cymbals |
9.5
|
Trombone |
6.4
|
Piano |
0.44
|
Trumpet |
0.31
|
Tuba |
0.20
|
Double bass |
0.16
|
Flute |
0.055
|
French horn |
0.053
|
Clarinet |
0.050
|
As all true music fans know even the best amps and speakers are garbage unless connected with Industrial Gauge Oxygen Free Gold Plated Silver Litz Wire Tri-filar wound on a helical PTFE core, and then fitted with bespoke insulating jackets hand-knitted in special-mix Kevlar, Carbon Fibre, and Vucana by nubile maidens. Nothing is too much trouble for proper audio pleasure…
Dave
I remember reading a book as a teenager where the author recounted doing an A/B test with an orchestra, audience and a speaker and concluded about 10 watts was right, but with a very efficient horn speaker.
I think the answer is complex. The easiest answer is to go to a concert by a big rock band and then you will know why.
Worth bearing in mind that a rock band with a massive PA throwing out 6,700watts is only going to sound four times as loud as that orchestra…
In practice, a lot of it is about headroom; I use a compressor which has three useful effects: it limits the peaks, reducing potential for hearing damage, it raises the quiet bits so I don't need to be as loud (and most importantly it helps mask volume differences due to deficiencies in technique
)
As for the green pen hifi brigade, I suggest an 'oxygen-free environment'…
Neil.
Edited By Neil Wyatt on 26/05/2019 17:46:33