Single Phase Motor Soft Start

Single Phase Motor Soft Start

Home › Forums › General Questions › Single Phase Motor Soft Start

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 26 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #871599
    Bob Sillitoe
    Participant
      @bobsillitoe83708

      Just wondering if anyone has had any experience of using a single phase motor soft starter to give a smoother start up of a lathe. I am thinking about the items which are available on ebay for between £20 and £30.

      Thanks

      Bob

      #871624
      noel shelley
      Participant
        @noelshelley55608

        Not come across such a thing for an induction motor ? What sort of lathe or motor ? Noel.

        #871635
        Bob Sillitoe
        Participant
          @bobsillitoe83708

          It is a standard capacitor start motor 1/3rd hp, it is fitted to my Southbend 9 lathe. Amazon sell the devices as well

           

          I like the soft start I get with the VFD on my miller but don’t want to go to the expense of fitting the same to the lathe

          #871638
          duncan webster 1
          Participant
            @duncanwebster1

            I’d never heard of them either, but Mrs Google led to Farnell. Not cheap at £66 plus vat, but this is a 25A model, perhaps lower rated availabe

            #871718
            Hollowpoint
            Participant
              @hollowpoint

              That’s interesting, I’ve never seen these before either. If you go ahead, I’d like to know the results! My milling machine has a 2hp motor that starts with quite a bang. I intend to fit a 3 phase motor and vfd in the future but thats a £500+ expense. It would be nice to smoothen the start.

              #871729
              Clive Brown 1
              Participant
                @clivebrown1

                My layman’s view is that these devices don’t alter the supply frequency and therfore will not soft start the type of induction motor normally fitted  to a machine tool. I presume that they are suited to ac brush motors etc. Happy to be corrected.

                #871739
                John Haine
                Participant
                  @johnhaine32865

                  They appear to be thyristor controllers that increase their “on” phase angle over a period after switch on, so gradually in effect ramping up the supply voltage. According to…

                  https://united-automation.com/soft-start-controllers-how-they-work/

                  …they can be used with induction motors.

                  #871742
                  not done it yet
                  Participant
                    @notdoneityet
                    On Clive Brown 1 Said:

                    My layman’s view is that these devices don’t alter the supply frequency and therfore will not soft start the type of induction motor normally fitted  to a machine tool. I presume that they are suited to ac brush motors etc. Happy to be corrected.

                    On Hollowpoint Said:

                    That’s interesting, I’ve never seen these before either. If you go ahead, I’d like to know the results! My milling machine has a 2hp motor that starts with quite a bang. I intend to fit a 3 phase motor and vfd in the future but thats a £500+ expense. It would be nice to smoothen the start.

                    Unless you are determined to pay top dollar for a new plug’n’play system, there are far better (cheaper) options, IMO.

                    I’ve used cheaper chinese VFDs for several years and have a good surplus 1.5kW three phase motor available at far less than the cost of a new motor – even worn motors are generally recoverable at minor cost.

                    Obviously a more expensive VFD would be required for a 415V output, but one could purchase a 3 HP three phase motor @ 415V star and run it on a 220V output VFD without changing the motor to delta configuration – but at a bit less than 2HP output.  There are options.🙂

                    #871760
                    Hollowpoint
                    Participant
                      @hollowpoint

                      I priced up a new motor @ £200 and a VFD @ £170 then the cables and buttons etc say £30.

                      Total £400ish so I was a bit off with my estimate. I won’t be doing it anytime soon though. Too busy.

                      #871763
                      Bob Sillitoe
                      Participant
                        @bobsillitoe83708

                        That is a very useful link from John. I am very very tempted to get one, so the next question is do I get a £30ish one from fleabay or a £60ish one from United Automation?

                        #871791
                        Roderick Jenkins
                        Participant
                          @roderickjenkins93242

                          One problem of having a reduced voltage at the start may be that there is insufficient torque to overcome the inertia of the mechanism –  OK for a fan but maybe not for a lathe gearbox and chuck.  There could also be an issue of achieving insufficient speed to throw the centrifugal switch if that is how the motor is started.

                          Rod

                          #871797
                          duncan webster 1
                          Participant
                            @duncanwebster1

                            But the voltage ramps up over a short time, so there will be enough torque to get it going, provided it doesn’t cook the start winding which will be energised for longer. We’re not talking about reducing voltage for any length of time

                            #871801
                            Michael Gilligan
                            Participant
                              @michaelgilligan61133
                              On Clive Brown 1 Said:

                              My layman’s view is that these devices don’t alter the supply frequency and therfore will not soft start the type of induction motor normally fitted  to a machine tool. I presume that they are suited to ac brush motors etc. Happy to be corrected.

                              From the FAQs

                              Can Soft Start Controllers be used on all motors?

                              They are most commonly used with three-phase AC induction motors, although some models are suitable for single-phase applications.

                              MichaelG.

                              #871818
                              duncan webster 1
                              Participant
                                @duncanwebster1

                                The wiring diagram for the one I linked clearly shows single phase, and lists AC motors as suitable application.

                                #871867
                                Bob Sillitoe
                                Participant
                                  @bobsillitoe83708

                                  I would have thought that start up over 3 or 4 seconds will be enough to significantly reduce the ‘bang’ at start up. Can’t see that will be long enough to cook the start windings.

                                  #871871
                                  Robert Atkinson 2
                                  Participant
                                    @robertatkinson2

                                    OK for a lathe with a clutch like a super 7 that reduces the number of starts and unloads the motor during starting.
                                    They are not suitable for frequent stop-start operation on single phase motors as they increase the time the start winding is energised and thus it’s temperature. They are more to reduce strain on the supply than the motor.

                                    Robert.

                                    #871877
                                    Bob Sillitoe
                                    Participant
                                      @bobsillitoe83708

                                      So normally how long is the start winding energised?

                                      #871879
                                      Martin Johnson 1
                                      Participant
                                        @martinjohnson1

                                        I had experience with 3 phase versions on pump drives.  Pumps can be tricky, giving the type of problem RA2 describes.  Too much to go into but it involves torque speed curves blah blah.  In other instances they worked OK.  I think John Haine describes the operating principle succinctly.

                                        You might well get away with it without clutches on lighter (Asian) lathes.  Trying to spin up 25kg of over engineered British cast iron multiple times while you try and hit a tight tolerance band is a different animal completely.

                                        Martin

                                        #871891
                                        Robert Atkinson 2
                                        Participant
                                          @robertatkinson2
                                          On Bob Sillitoe Said:

                                          So normally how long is the start winding energised?

                                          0.5-2 seconds is typical for a small motor with a centrifugal switch.

                                          #871903
                                          duncan webster 1
                                          Participant
                                            @duncanwebster1

                                            I know using a single phase motor on frequent stop/start service is cruelty to motors, but I ran a ML7 with a 1/4 hp motor for years with no clutch and no problem. Thd motor finally died from ingress of gunge to the cooling air inputs, which were lined up with the chuck.

                                            #871907
                                            not done it yet
                                            Participant
                                              @notdoneityet

                                              Deleted, wrong quote.

                                              #871910
                                              not done it yet
                                              Participant
                                                @notdoneityet
                                                On Bob Sillitoe Said:

                                                I would have thought that start up over 3 or 4 seconds will be enough to significantly reduce the ‘bang’ at start up. Can’t see that will be long enough to cook the start windings.

                                                You just need to look up on the internet.  There you will find that starts should not exceed eight in any one hour period for a single phase motor, in order to prolong the life of the motor.

                                                I expect that likely means no-load starts, not starts under a load, but it might.  It is a general rule.  Burned out windings are an expensive repair and it is likely more economic to replace the motor rather than repair, these days.

                                                As Robert says, 0.5 – 2 seconds.

                                                Are you willing to risk your motor failing?

                                                #871938
                                                Bob Sillitoe
                                                Participant
                                                  @bobsillitoe83708

                                                  My motor did fail a few months ago, but I only needed to replace the capacitor. It probably failed because I exceed the recommended number of stop/starts. I expect that most people do that as with many turning jobs it just isn’t practical to wait around 10 minutes to take the next cut – well you could but you would drink a lot of coffee whilst waiting!

                                                  As far as will I risk my motor by fitting one of these soft start devices, I haven’t decided yet. I think it is a balance of risk between damaging the drive train through shock loading due to the abrupt start of the motor and damaging the motor.

                                                  #871940
                                                  John Haine
                                                  Participant
                                                    @johnhaine32865

                                                    Apart from the shock to the human system, what is the evidence of damage to the drive train from sudden starts?

                                                    #871943
                                                    noel shelley
                                                    Participant
                                                      @noelshelley55608

                                                      An interesting idea until you look into it ! The ML 7 and many other types of lathe without a clutch have worked for decades with out such devices and had little trouble. Single phase induction motors have been around for over 100 years and are still made and used. My first thought was as Robert has mentioned the stop/start issue as opposed to starting and running for an extended period. I would be very wary of using such a device on a lathe without a clutch ! If the start windings overheat/cook it would be an expensive experiment ?  Noel.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 26 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home › Forums › General Questions › Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.