Posted by Martin Newbold on 28/05/2016 15:21:06:
Well the Tumber is moving forward and only a few jobs left
I still have to pin the Base I have pinned handle not in this photo with a roll pin . I am not happy with the roll pins i bought so am looking for some better ones. Whilst looking at the position of the gears I noticed that the sadle gear s where not holding in place. I noticed that this was because there was a crack in the bracket which prevented the bolt from locking up the bracket:

This was a bit of a blow as the crack is from the casting material presumably the slag was in it when it was founded and cast. I have been thinking about this design and have to wonder if it not a good design either. I am thinking two bolts would be better like a piston con rod:

Anyone have any thoughts please?
The crack in the casting is more the result of bad design rather than just over tightening. The pinch bolt should be much closer to the diameter of the bore. The bolts purpose is to reduce the circumference to achieve the clamping action so the closer it is to the bore the more effective it is. Being positioned so far out introduces a bending moment in the casting rather than pure tension.
Having the casting thicker (at the point it broke) than the rest of the 'band' round the shaft would have helped too. It might be an optical illusion but it appears that where it broke was actually the thinnest part.
Your proposed design will work just as well, its just a matter of however you want to make it.
Ian P