Proxxon PD400 vs HBM 180 lathe

[Sonic EscapeParticipant @sonicescape38234]

What would you choose between a PD400 and an HBM 180 lathe? I found and PD400 in very good condition, like new. But is still 600 euro more expensive than a brand new HBM 180. Does it worth the difference? Is Proxxon really that good comparing with a “good quality” Chinese lathe?

[BazyleParticipant @bazyle]

Look also at the ‘extras’ as they seem to have similar specs. It looks like the HBM has a set over tailstock facility which is both a benefit if you need adjustment and a curse if it needs adjustment. I’m familiar with the Proxxon range of tools for modellers but didn’t realise they also did lathes. Their other tools are always technically good but rather expensive bit like choosing between a Merc and a Ford car. If you just want to get there a Ford is good enough. Perhaps the biggest worry with a Chinese mini is that electronic speed control reliability though I think that is getting better now.

[Roger BParticipant @rogerb61624]

The PD 400 is a good lathe. I was considering buying one when a very well equipped Hobbymat came along.

The biggest disadvantage is the unique chuck fitting so that chucks and faceplates, etc need to be from Proxxon. Accessories for the Chinese mini lathes are much easier to find (and cheaper).

Does the PD 400 you are looking at have a good selection of equipment?

[Author]

Posts