injector operation

injector operation

Home › Forums › General Questions › injector operation

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #869747
    Garry Coles
    Participant
      @garrycoles69390

      Hi,

      This might seem like a silly question, but when you operate the horivontal water injector is it best to turn the steam or water on first. Or does it not matter.

      Garry

       

      #869751
      MichaelR
      Participant
        @michaelr

        Not a silly question. I always turned the water on first

        MichaelR

        #869753
        Bazyle
        Participant
          @bazyle

          Essential to turn the water on first to keep thigs cool. The way it works relies on the steam condensing in the cold water and you also need to be able to adjust the steam flow to get that to happen smoothly. You often see drivers looking over the side of the loco to see the injector is first dribbling water, then ‘picking up’ and not disappearing in a cloud of steam.

          #869792
          Baz
          Participant
            @baz89810
            On Bazyle Said:

            Essential to turn the water on first to keep thigs cool. The way it works relies on the steam condensing in the cold water and you also need to be able to adjust the steam flow to get that to happen smoothly. You often see drivers looking over the side of the loco to see the injector is first dribbling water, then ‘picking up’ and not disappearing in a cloud of steam.

            So what happens if you don’t have a water valve to turn on. We all put our injectors at the lowest point possible and flood them with water, what about when the injector is mounted above the water level, the only control you have is the steam valve so steam on and the injector lifts the water by causing a vacuum in the water supply pipe. A decent injector should work regardless of whatever is turned on first.

            #869796
            duncan webster 1
            Participant
              @duncanwebster1

              So does water dribble out all the time? I have in the past considered bringing the overflow up above tank water level, but was talked out of it by the greybeards

              #869798
              Bazyle
              Participant
                @bazyle

                Good points Baz. I was just considering common club locomotive set up. Lifting injectors as sometimes used on traction engines are designed for the different operating conditions. There was a little book on injectors in the common Model Engineer offerings but I have no idea where my copy has got to.

                #869806
                Baz
                Participant
                  @baz89810

                  Duncan, no because the injector is mounted above the water level in the tender, if you have access to Don Youngs LLAS mags have a look at his Marie E, the little “ cowboy” engine, he positions the injectors on roughly the boiler centreline height wise so there is only a steam valve, turn it on and the injector sucks the water up. Don specifies vertical injectors but that is only because of some “ history” with, I think Chiverton. In 2018 I had cancer then covid came along and I was in a very dark place, I started making injectors to the designs in DAG Browns excellent book, I love machining having been a professional handle turner all my working life and making injectors and associated tooling was what I needed to take my mind off of all my problems. I have made 12,18 and 26 oz injectors both vertical and horizontal and they all work beautifully, they all lift and don’t mind if steam or water is turned on first, only thing I did different to DAG was to make my reamers out of HSS rather than silver steel hardened and tempered because I have the necessary grinding equipment available. I can thoroughly recommend the book.

                  #869832
                  duncan webster 1
                  Participant
                    @duncanwebster1

                    Sorry I’m confused, ‘ at the lowest point possible and flood them with water’ doesn’t square with being above the level of water in the tender.

                    #869833
                    Speedy Builder5
                    Participant
                      @speedybuilder5

                      Baz, would you post a photo of one of your steam valve only injectors as I am (and probably others) intrigued as to how the initial “suck up” works.  A sectioned drawing would be even better.

                      Bob

                      #869839
                      MichaelR
                      Participant
                        @michaelr

                        An interesting link lifting injector.

                        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4wsiXPgfdlI

                        #871689
                        Nigel Graham 2
                        Participant
                          @nigelgraham2

                          Bob –

                          The lifting injector works as an e –jector first – the steam jet entering the combining-cone produces a partial vacuum to draw the water up into the device. The air is expelled through the overflow.

                          Once the water is there it will continue to work almost as both in and e– jector modes at once.

                          Their internals are much the same whether used lifting or gravity-fed, but I don’t think all are necessarily good at sucking up the water to start with. DAG Brown designs his so they will lift to an appreciable head even though usually used on locomotives or on traction-engine bunker sides.

                          If the injector can lift sufficiently high, it does not need a water-valve if placed above the tank’s top water-level.

                           

                          Some commercial, full-size injectors were made with a single control that opened the water inlet then the steam in a single turn of the handle. These could work in lifting or gravity-fed installations. The valves were worked by very coarse threads and appear designed so the steam could be adjusted without affecting the water flow.

                           

                          Baz –

                          Horizontal or vertical? Doesn’t really matter functionally. They differ markedly in layout so the overflow valve is always helped by gravity. Horizontal ones are common on most locomotives to suit being low down under the footplate, and the disposition of the in and out pipes. Vertical injectors seem fairly common on road steam vehicles, but the only rule for the choice on a model is fidelity to prototype.

                          Full-size injectors commonly use split, hinged combining-cones to give the overflow action, but this would be problematical in miniature, hence using ball-valves.

                           

                          Duncan –

                          That a particular injector will operate in lifting mode doesn’t mean all will, nor that it has to. On most traction-engines and locomotives the device is located low down and gravity-fed.

                          This gives the advantage Bazyle describes, that the injector starts cold. The steam has to condense extremely rapidly in the combining-cone, and a hot injector or feed-water hampers that. It does surprise me that backhead-mounted, lifting injectors, used on some applications, work at all!

                           

                          Injectors should not “dribble” water when working in optimum conditions. Turn the water on fully on a gravity-fed device and I would expect a full, steady overflow stream, though smaller than the open feed-pipe would pass. Once the magick Physics is under way, perhaps with a bit of tickling of the steam or water valve or both, the overflow should not emit anything.

                           

                          The club’s loco on which I learnt to drive miniatures, was a 5″ g. Maid of Kent (curiously named … Athens) whose injector chirruped like an excited guinea-pig. As it was feeding the boiler I assumed injectors are natural singers. It was years before I learnt a good little injector is seen and not heard. The chirping indicates an inwards air-leak, commonly from a tender feed-bag that is just simple hose pushed onto plain pipe, as the Athenian lass’ was.*

                           

                          For either problem, refer to the chaper on fault finding in D.A.G. Brown’s treatise.

                           

                          =====

                          *was? I hope the “lass” is still running, wherever she is now!

                        Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
                        • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                        Latest Replies

                        Home › Forums › General Questions › Topics

                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                        View full reply list.