3 1/2” gauge diesel loco?

Advert

3 1/2” gauge diesel loco?

Home Forums Locomotives 3 1/2” gauge diesel loco?

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #797116
    Paul McDonough
    Participant
      @paulmcdonough43628

      Hi I am interested in making a diesel electric loco preferably 3 1/2” gauge are there any plans out there for something like a class 52 please?

      Advert
      #797515
      parovoz
      Participant
        @parovoz

        As no one has responded yet here is a first pass set of thoughts.

        1/ Can I assume by Class 52 the Western Warship? If so this is actually a diesel hydraulic not a diesel electric…. Just a wee starter there.

        2/ As a regular inhabitant of the ” Rabbit hole of spiralling complexity ” the thought of modern traction in 3 1/2″ gage fills me with dread to build a potentially very complex locomotive in such a small scale. Not impossible, but ‘potentially’ very difficult. I think 5″ is usually the starting point for this.

        3/ The type of power system needs VERY careful thought and there are a range of options. These are….

        a) Pure electric drive with batteries, controller and traction motors. Then usually a sound system to make it sound realistic.

        b) An internal combustion engine – In the case of the Class 52 Warship coupled to a fluid torque converter driving the bogies through a reduction gearbox and Carden – shafts. Definitely the next stage up. The issue is the prime mover here, a commercially built unit, for this scale very small and possibly not robust enough for rail service. OR build your own, next level up again…. Thus depends on ones skill level…

         

        So, designs available that I know about.

        3 1/2″ Gauge 0-6-0 names “1831” by Edgar Westbury utilising a 2 cylinder IC engine.

        5″ Gauge Hymec by Roy Amesbury –  was described in ME commencing volume 160 no. 3827 – June 1988 – A v8 petrol with hydraulic transmission, so prototypical arrangement but not to scale internally. He went a fair bit down the rabbit hole but not too far that he met the white rabbit…..

        Then there is a 52 in 5″ gauge – I think there may be more than one – but this one from Phoenix is typical of the ‘basic’ battery powered Diesel outline models.

        https://phoenixlocos.com/products/model-locos/class-52-western/

        Usual disclaimer, I have no connection or knowledge on the particular model.

        In modern traction land it is ‘relatively’ easy to build an electric powered outline model. The minute one tries to cross into the more scale realm the complexity goes up by the exponential function the further into the rabbit hole one goes.

        I did some thought concepts for a 7 1/4″ Ukranian M62 and it was scary how quickly the complexity escalated, I ran back out that rabbit hole very quickly.

        I did a small 5″ ‘electric’ diesel many years ago ( Brush Bear Peacock D2999 ) and it was reasonably OK but NOT I.C.

        If I was doing this in the future I would probably only look at pure electric traction and avoid Diesel…..

        But it depends on your goal and level of skill.

        Hope that minor ramble assists…..

        Best regards.

         

         

         

        #797533
        Paul McDonough
        Participant
          @paulmcdonough43628

          Thank you for your reply @parovoz you are of course quite right my loco of choice by appearance is indeed a diesel hydraulic ! as is my other favorite the class 35 Hymec, I’m not really that troubled by which loco I build it is the technical challenge which interests me.

          I am in part motivated by Bob Symes class 47, which used a Taplin twin shown at 3:28 in this video

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_IHBZkuDWk

          I can see its a tight package, but a 5″ gauge model is going to be a monster!

          My local track has 3 1/2″, 5″ and 7″ tracks so I have a choice.

           

          #797539
          Howard Lewis
          Participant
            @howardlewis46836

            Some years ago, a member of the Hereford SME (UK) was making an ICE powered Warship or Western, actually making his own torque converters; in 5″ gauge from memory The loco was well advanced, when exhibited.

            I never saw the completed loco, so he either moved away, gave up, or passed on.

            Howard

            #797542
            parovoz
            Participant
              @parovoz

              Hi Paul!

              That video brings back memories…… I saw it the first time round and was really interested in the diesel….. And yes it certainly can be done…..

              As to published designs, apart from the ones I mentioned I don’t know of any others. So I think for this project one is on one’s own……

              So as long as were not going into the rabbit hole of scale complexity then it’s achievable as Howard mentions above. I was going to suggest that a hydraulic transmission was easier / better than electric in this scale…. but going back to Bob Syme’s gauge 1 class 47, that was electric, so I would probably be talking cobblers on that point. I’m no expert in this particular area.

              I think the main part of this project is not so much the loco / chassis / running gear etc. but the development of the power plant, either Hydraulic or Electric, and ensuring it can all fit within the ‘package’ of the locomotive. It’s a great challenge and worthy of the effort.

              Locally we had a chap who built LMS 10,000 in 7 1/4″ with I.C. from a motorcycle engine. It ran very well, but did sound odd changing gear 🙂

              All the best.

               

              #797615
              Paul McDonough
              Participant
                @paulmcdonough43628

                Yes I loved bob’s programmes as a teenager, I was building scale RC model boats back then including steam (Stuart turner double ten powered), he certainly packed a lot in to that dinky loco. My logic is the electrically powered bogies controlled by an electronic speed controller must be a done thing even at 3 1/2” gauge, then the IC / generator package replaces the battery in battery locos, as an electrical/ electronics engineer this is the interesting part.

                I do agree that making this all work smoothly will be a challenge.

                another way of looking at this is I could have suggested a flash steam powered Sun engine generator!

                #797722
                parovoz
                Participant
                  @parovoz

                  Hmmmm ????? Electric bogies could be fun. Finding suitable traction motors to have enough power and fit between the back to back could be a challenge….  Or go for the French style ‘monomoteur’ single geared traction motor like the CC72000 class.

                   

                   

                  #797735
                  duncan webster 1
                  Participant
                    @duncanwebster1

                    I’d couple the axles on each bogie (tooth belt or chain) then have a bevel box on an axle with motor mounted longitudinall on main frame.

                    #797772
                    Paul McDonough
                    Participant
                      @paulmcdonough43628

                      Yes I think you’re right scaling down has its challenges, although I like the belt drive idea thanks

                      #797773
                      duncan webster 1
                      Participant
                        @duncanwebster1

                        A vee4 variant of the Sun so it will start at any crank angle with a mechanical drive could well be easier! Something on the lines of a Heisler but with chain coupled axles.

                        #797780
                        JasonB
                        Moderator
                          @jasonb

                          A Westbury Gemini based V4 may do if you like rotary valves, couple of MTB 1B top halves on a separate crankcase if you prefer slide valves or the Sun option for piston valves

                          What the MTB based one could look like. Wonder why I have an MTB 1M drawn up😉🤔

                          mtbv4

                          #797789
                          duncan webster 1
                          Participant
                            @duncanwebster1

                            Dont the two bevel gears driving the eccentrics clash ( one omitted for clarity!)

                            #797832
                            JasonB
                            Moderator
                              @jasonb

                              I only cobbled together a few bits from the two cylinder parts that I have drawn up. Hence no crankcase it would need a couple of details like the gears and a different crank sorting out. You could possibly mount two bevel gears “back to back” on the crankshaft and stagger the vertical shafts to match the cylinder offset.

                              Something like this, what do you propose for the V4 Sun?

                              v gears 1

                              If you wanted to stick with internal combustion then a new crankcase fitted with 4 Nemett Bobcat cylinders & Head assemblies could be used in V4 or straight 4 configuration.

                               

                              #797893
                              duncan webster 1
                              Participant
                                @duncanwebster1
                                On JasonB Said:

                                I only cobbled together a few bits from the two cylinder parts that I have drawn up. Hence no crankcase it would need a couple of details like the gears and a different crank sorting out. You could possibly mount two bevel gears “back to back” on the crankshaft and stagger the vertical shafts to match the cylinder offset.

                                Something like this, what do you propose for the V4 Sun?

                                v gears 1

                                If you wanted to stick with internal combustion then a new

                                On JasonB Said:

                                …… bevel gears “back to back” on the crankshaft and stagger the vertical shafts to match the cylinder offset.

                                Something like this, what do you propose for the V4 Sun?……

                                 

                                Thats when I gave up daydreaming, although something like a pair of semi rotary valves (like a Corliss) driven from eccentrics on the crankshaft might work. Or a piston valve for each cylinder with the valves at the ends and an eccentric or cam at each end, like 4 Spartan engines.

                                #801399
                                Paul McDonough
                                Participant
                                  @paulmcdonough43628

                                  Dear all, ok so I have found some basic line drawings of a class 47, very smart looking loco to my eye, my question refers to scaling the thing down to 3 1/2” gauge to see if I can get the engine/generator gubbins to fit.

                                  i am looking for drawings which show a typical standard wheel set but also a section through the 3 1/2” gauge track, it seems that both are elusive on the www, your pointers would be appreciated. I have contacted my local Model engineering club am I am hopeful that they might be able to help.

                                  i would still prefer a set of drawings to build a model though even if it is diesel hydraulic!

                                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                Advert

                                Latest Replies

                                Home Forums Locomotives Topics

                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                View full reply list.

                                Advert

                                Newsletter Sign-up