2inch Fowler plans

2inch Fowler plans

Home › Forums › Traction engines › 2inch Fowler plans

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #799278
    bob53page
    Participant
      @bob53page

      Help required please.

      I am trying to locate a replacement set of plans for a 2inch Fowler 16 nhp 2 speed ploughing engine TE20. I have originals by John Haining but badly water damaged, dated 3/11/80 . I have tried contacting various sources like Neil Tyler@mach tech, mj engineering, black gates, Ekp supplies. Have had no joy at all. Any help or info that may assist would be much appreciated.

      Thanks in advance Bob Page

      #799301
      JasonB
      Moderator
        @jasonb

        Are you sure Blackgates could not help, possibly depends on who you asked as they may have it listed under “class V” . Certainly in one of their paper catalogues that I have along with some castings but is about 10yrs old.

        I just had a look at Sarik who took over the old MAP then Myhobbystore drawings but thay don’t list it either.

        The other option would be to get hold of the old ME articles which span a couple of volumes as the drawings are in that.

        #799328
        Bob Worsley
        Participant
          @bobworsley31976

          This used to be sold by Brunell model engineering about 15 years ago when I tried to buy a set of castings etc, but the then owner, Graham Howard, couldn’t be bothered to supply the parts bought and paid for. Look back in the history on the ME.

          If brave then might be able to get drawings and castings from them.

          Contained in ME 1980 vols 146/7 and 8.

           

          #799340
          Andrew Crow
          Participant
            @andrewcrow91475

            Hi Bob, I think the model engineer volumes you need are from volume 146 Dec 1980 through vol 147, 1981 and the first half of 1982 vol 148.

            Andy.

            #799358
            Dave Halford
            Participant
              @davehalford22513

              An interesting model, Haining converted an export wood burner to a UK spec coal burner. He mentions intending to supply the export tender drawing later in the magazine series but never did. He also wonders why the firebox is so large. The real engine does not have a Church valve.

              Superba gears are the same.

              See my avatar for the real thing

              #799363
              JasonB
              Moderator
                @jasonb

                I don’t think I have seen any traction or ploughing engines done with the flat tank and basket arrangement, it would make a bit of a change. Could even go to a straw burner and have the working feed arrangement. Might all have to go that way if coal becomes a problem to source.

                Though if you did an export one you would really have to do a canopy which makes it a bit harder to drive the model.

                Talking of gears none of Hainings are really correct as he uses the same DP throughout but a lot of Fowlers had smaller on the crank and getting larger as they got to the final drive.

                #799390
                Dave Halford
                Participant
                  @davehalford22513

                  Strictly speaking Haining’s are approximations just like Minnie. I’ve got a Universal plough or side drum mod for Minnie 3/4 designed which mixes Burrell with a bit of Fowler + some guess work.

                  If anyone’s wondering the odd looking rear wheels are the remains of Bottrills big flat wooden feet.

                  #799405
                  bob53page
                  Participant
                    @bob53page

                    Thanks Bob, I did try Brunell some time last year but like you they let me down. Plans that were ordered and paid for never arrived. I have got photo copies of various relevant pages from ME but would ideally like to replace the originals. Thanks for the assistance.

                    regards Bob

                    #799408
                    bob53page
                    Participant
                      @bob53page

                      Thanks everyone for your input, will let you know how I progress.

                      #873101
                      Walt Nehse
                      Participant
                        @waltnehse22189

                        Hello All!

                        I am also looking for plans for a 2-inch scale Fowler traction engine. The build was started by others. The work was completed to a high degree of precision most of the parts appear to be present.

                        At this point the only items that are missing is flywheel, steering wheel, hand brake wheel, and plans. I was told that the plans came from Model Engineer magazine and that is what I am looking for.

                        I did reach out to MJ engineering with no response so far. I think their plans may be for a slightly different build but don’t mind paying for them if they are close.

                        I think my best bet will be to find the Model engineer articles and would be happy to pay for them. If anyone can point me in the direction of articles, it will be greatly appreciated.

                        Walt Nehse

                         

                        #873110
                        JasonB
                        Moderator
                          @jasonb

                          Walt, can you post some images of the engine that you have, at least four different Fowler engines have been covered in ME over the years. MJ have changes hand not that long ago so you may need to contact Bridport Foundry to get drawings if it is the A7 that you have. If a ploughing engine then there are different sources depending on what you have.

                          #873352
                          Walt Nehse
                          Participant
                            @waltnehse22189

                            20261016_112619

                            #873355
                            Walt Nehse
                            Participant
                              @waltnehse22189

                              5746516f-ca32-45a6-91f9-7f8ab612fa2e

                              #873361
                              Walt Nehse
                              Participant
                                @waltnehse22189

                                Jason,

                                The preceding pictures are of my friend’s completed traction engine.

                                It is my understanding that my engine is a twin of the completed one.

                                The original builder’s name is on the cylinder block.

                                The project started approximately 20 years ago.

                                I will try and send text with pictures next time.

                                Thank you for your response.

                                Walt Nehse

                                #873364
                                JasonB
                                Moderator
                                  @jasonb

                                  It does not look like any Fowler model that I know. The smokebox is very short and the boiler quite  alarge diameter which has meant they front wheels have been made about half the size of the rear which looks out of proportion.

                                  Also I don’t think any castings have been used with the possible exception of the flywheel which is small in diameter and has a very thick rim, suggesting it was meant for something else.

                                  It is certainly not an A7 to the MJ Engineering design or the Plastow 2″ Fowler. This is my 2″ A7 for comparrison

                                  PICT0264

                                  PICT0265

                                  #873393
                                  Walt Nehse
                                  Participant
                                    @waltnehse22189

                                    JasonB.

                                    Thank you for your input and the picture of your stunning traction engine.

                                    You are correct about the lack of castings; the flywheel was extracted from a solid piece of steel on my friend’s engine; I plan to do likewise.

                                    The good news for me is that 90% of the machine work is completed. The boiler is complete and has previously passed pressure test. All that remains for the wheels is to rivet the spokes into them; I have completed the front and am working on the back. Can’t wait to get it on its wheels.

                                    I was told that the original builder used prints that came from Model Engineering magazine. I also have a folder of handwritten shop drawings noting modifications to the boiler and other items.

                                    I found a functional Model Engineer index. Working my way through it now. Good to know that there will be more than one version.

                                    I will be able to erect without pints but would like to do it right the first time. Prints with plumbing, injectors, pumps, valves, gauges, and the like will be extremely useful.

                                    Walt Nehse

                                     

                                     

                                    #873435
                                    Dave Halford
                                    Participant
                                      @davehalford22513

                                      The way the tender top kicks up so early in a straight line + the short smoke box makes it look a bit like a Savage around 1875.

                                      You normally find small diameter flywheels on American or higher rpm engines though that may have been caused by material availability issues.

                                      #873448
                                      noel shelley
                                      Participant
                                        @noelshelley55608

                                        Hi Walt, Whilst the pictures show a nicely made engine there are numerous items that seem out of proportion and pipe work that doesn’t look prototypical of any engine I can think of. Possibly based on numerous engine features but a freelance. It is not the Burrell that Bassett Lowke did in 1.5″ scale, or a scaled down version of the Foster usually in 4″. I would be loathe to spend much money on drawings that may have little in common with the parts you have. The layout of the pipes for boiler feed are similar to the Foster 6NHP with the 2 clacks on the side of the boiler and the injector low down on the right side more or less behind the wheel, though the crank driven feed water pump is in a different place. The bypass valve, water and steam valves for the injector and steam valve for the water lifter if fitted can all follow standard practice. The water gauges can be either 3 cock gauges or have a simple blowdown, depending how much time or money you want to spend. Good luck. Noel.

                                        PS the short fat boiler puts me in the mind of possibly an Alchin ?

                                        #873564
                                        Walt Nehse
                                        Participant
                                          @waltnehse22189

                                          Greetings.

                                          Thank you all for your experienced advice.

                                          At this point I do not believe that it is possible to find prints that will represent this traction engines construction accurately. I suspect that the builder may have started with some build articles from Model Engineering magazine and modified to his own specifications from there. If I’m lucky, I may be able to locate the build articles.

                                          As I stated earlier, I found a working index of the magazine that may help.

                                          No matter the outcome, I have already had more fun with this project than the cost of admission.

                                          Thank you all,

                                          Walt Nehse

                                        Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
                                        • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                        Latest Replies

                                        Home › Forums › Traction engines › Topics

                                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                        View full reply list.