CE Marking ( again)

CE Marking ( again)

Home Forums Beginners questions CE Marking ( again)

Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #233733
    BC Prof
    Participant
      @bcprof

      Sorry to bring this topic up again but I have been offered a loco from a dealer that has no original boiler paperwork. It was manufactured post 2002 .

      The, well known, dealer has given it 2x Hydraulic test and will steam test it before purchase

      With no materials spec. for the boiler what is the situation with CE marking and validation and obtaining Northen Fed club boiler tests in future years ?

      Brian C

      #8092
      BC Prof
      Participant
        @bcprof
        #233742
        PT
        Participant
          @pt

          Hi Brian,

          Appropriate CE marking is required on commercial boilers post 2002, it is not required on privately built boilers. So if the boiler is non commercial, there is no issue with there being no CE mark.

          Hope this helps

          Paul

          #233743
          PT
          Participant
            @pt

             

             

            Edited By PT on 08/04/2016 07:32:28

            #233744
            JasonB
            Moderator
              @jasonb

              CE would only have been required if it were a commercial boiler, if the one on your prospective loco was home made then there is no need for it to have a CE mark. Do you know if it is commercial or homemade?

              #233754
              BC Prof
              Participant
                @bcprof

                Boiler is commercial Polly

                Brian C

                #233766
                JasonB
                Moderator
                  @jasonb

                  Is there a boiler number, may be worth contacting polly to see if they have records.

                  #233772
                  Steambuff
                  Participant
                    @steambuff

                    Its also possible that it is not a original Polly boiler …. it could have been changed by the previous owner(s) for a home made one!

                    Also are you sure the boiler was made after 2002?

                    I would be surprised if a Polly boiler was not stamped with a CE mark, serial number and boiler working/test pressure.

                    Dave

                    #233778
                    BC Prof
                    Participant
                      @bcprof

                      It is a genuine Polly boiler and hence has a CE stamp and pressure details but what is the situation in respect of future club tests if I have no paperwork giving details of the materials etc. used in its constuction?

                      Brian C

                      #233780
                      Peter Krogh
                      Participant
                        @peterkrogh76576

                        Like Jason said, contact Polly and see what they have in the records.

                        Pete

                        #233784
                        BC Prof
                        Participant
                          @bcprof

                          Polly don't keep records

                          Brian C

                          #233787
                          John Stevenson 1
                          Participant
                            @johnstevenson1

                            Why not ask the club concerned ?

                            It's OK all the armchair lawyers on here giving advise, they are not the ones testing it.

                            #233788
                            Tony Ray
                            Participant
                              @tonyray65007

                              Firstly I nothing about model boiler testing, I do know about autoclaves but let me ask this question

                              I buy a Polly kit with boiler today, it comes with a boiler number and a test certificate ? I get it fully assembled and working and get all safety checks etc etc done. I take it to an open day and the boiler lets go due to a mufacturing defect and someone gets seriously injured. If what you say aboput Polly's lack of records is true, rather than them just not wanting to hep you, I would not want to be the H&S manager at Polly when the HSE turn up asking to see;

                              Calibration records for testing equipment

                              Training records for the person dong the testing

                              Records of Tests vs boiler numbers & dates for the Boilers they make

                              #233792
                              JasonB
                              Moderator
                                @jasonb

                                If polly can't help then as JS says talk with whoever is going to test the boiler.

                                Its quite possible records were not kept that far back, I assume its more than 7years old and most business records don't need keeping any longer than that

                                #233805
                                nigel jones 5
                                Participant
                                  @nigeljones5

                                  Its all down to your boiler inspector either being reasonable or not. If its made by Polly and is CE stamped then it will have been made to an accepted design with the right materials. There should be no need whatsoever for any additional paperwork, just the usual visual, hydraulic then steam test. Im not the armchair pundit for what its worth, I meke them, repair them and have them tested, and yours should be a doddle to get through – assuming its copper?

                                  #233810
                                  David Jupp
                                  Participant
                                    @davidjupp51506

                                    The CE mark might be accompanied by a Notified Body ID number (depends on equipment category) – this allows you to identify which Notified Body either approved the design and manufacture, or approved the manufacturer's quality system in respect of pressure equipment manufacture. The Notified Body isn't obliged to provide any information – but some publish basic details of approvals on their web sites.

                                    I agree with Fizzy – there is no absolute requirement for the manufacturer to provide paper work beyond the Declaration of Conformity (and also adequate instructions), though many customers would expect/demand materials certificates, and pressure test record.

                                    Edited By David Jupp on 08/04/2016 17:03:39

                                    #233811
                                    Bob Youldon
                                    Participant
                                      @bobyouldon45599

                                      Good afternoon Brian,were

                                      I would as Fizzy has suggested, your first approach should be to your club boiler inspectors. It is an interesting question as the original paperwork is the start of any audit trail. The revised test procedures were promulgated in 2012 and the paperwork differs considerably to that of previous test regimes; as someone has already mentioned there was no statutory requirement on the part of Polly to retain copies of the paperwork, certainly beyond seven years; further I think the Polly who may have constructed the boiler may not be the same Polly Engineering we know today, the original company/supplier being taken over/bought by the present owners. Paperwork can and will get lost or destroyed, It won't be the last time I've seen a grate dropped into a tool box at the end of a days run, the test certificates being almost totally destroyed. So there has to be a starting point and that's your boiler testers, tease out the situation with them, they can always take council with the Northern Association and come to a decision as to the way forward.

                                      Regards,

                                      Bob Youldon

                                      #233822
                                      BC Prof
                                      Participant
                                        @bcprof

                                        Many thanks for the replies Gentlemen. It is nice to know that the consensus is that the actual paperwork is not required.

                                        Brian C

                                      Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
                                      • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                      Latest Replies

                                      Home Forums Beginners questions Topics

                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                      View full reply list.