WM250 inverter drive conversion.

Advert

WM250 inverter drive conversion.

Home Forums General Questions WM250 inverter drive conversion.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 29 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #205858
    Mark P.
    Participant
      @markp

      Hi all, did I read a thread on here,or was it in an article in MEW about converting one of these to inverter drive? After fitting new head bearings the motor brushes have gone fut!😠
      Regards Mark P.

      Advert
      #24137
      Mark P.
      Participant
        @markp
        #205865
        John Rudd
        Participant
          @johnrudd16576

          Iirc, there was an article in MEW about adding a 3 ph motor and vfd to a lathe, cant remember if it was the WM250……

          I'm converting my SPG lathe ( I think it may be the equivalent of the 290 but with a brushed motor…) to 3 phase with a 1.5kw motor ( going for a 2 pole job, the 4 pole 1400 rpm version only comes in a 90 frame size…tooooooo big enough ) and vfd, but undecided on choice of inverter….

          I chose a 2 pole motor for 2 reasons, at low spindle speed, the motor will still be turning resonably quick to avoid any overheating issue, and secondly, the 80 frame size motor has the same footprint…I've turned up a replacement pulley to suit the motor shaft…14mm rather than mod the orig…if at some point I want to revert back, I can…

           

          Edited By John Rudd on 27/09/2015 16:41:24

          #205873
          JasonB
          Moderator
            @jasonb

            Motor speed is one thing you will have to watch if sticking with the same belt/pully ratios as the DC ones run at about 4600rpm at full lick.

            Set of brushes would be a lot easier, the replacements I fitted have lasted far longer than the originals

            #205875
            Mark P.
            Participant
              @markp

              I seem to be replacing brushes maybe once a year! I do work my lathe quite hard. Unfortunatly I can’t afford to have it down for long, so an inverter seems the solution to my problems.
              Mark P.

              #205876
              John Rudd
              Participant
                @johnrudd16576

                Posted by JasonB on 27/09/2015 17:03:23:

                Motor speed is one thing you will have to watch if sticking with the same belt/pully ratios as the DC ones run at about 4600rpm at full lick.

                Which is why I went with the 2 pole job. Run the inverter at 85hz should be around the same rpm….

                #205930
                Mark P.
                Participant
                  @markp

                  John, I have found a 1.5Hp "80"frame 4 pole motor which I'm hoping should go in the hole vacated by the old motor.

                  Mark P.

                  #205938
                  John Rudd
                  Participant
                    @johnrudd16576

                    Mark,

                    Good find….but if you want to stick with the same speed ranges, you'll need to change at least the motor pulley size……..

                    Even running the inverter at 100hz will give a motor shaft speed of 2800…..-and I wouldnt want to push the motor much beyond that…

                    #205951
                    Mark P.
                    Participant
                      @markp

                      Hi John,I will have to play around with pulleys I am thinking of incorporating so sort of back gear while I’m at it.
                      Mark P.

                      #205953
                      JasonB
                      Moderator
                        @jasonb

                        Is there a risk of loosing torque by gearing up a slower reving motor to run at higher spindle speeds?

                         

                        Edited By JasonB on 28/09/2015 12:41:58

                        #205957
                        Mark P.
                        Participant
                          @markp

                          No Jason, I will be gearing down a high revving motor so it should increase torque?

                          #205964
                          JasonB
                          Moderator
                            @jasonb

                            Mark, I thought the 4 pole motors run at 1400rpm, 2 pole at 2800rpm (both at 50hz) but the DC one that is on the lathe at 4600 so you will need higher gearing/pullies to get the same spindle speeds you have now

                            #205969
                            Mark P.
                            Participant
                              @markp

                              Surely the ratios will be the same regardless of motor speed, or am I looking at it from the wrong angle?

                              #205970
                              John Rudd
                              Participant
                                @johnrudd16576

                                Top speed on the lathe is 1000 or 2000 rpm depending on the belt/pulley position.

                                So for a motor spindle speed of 4600, the pulley ratio is 2.3:1 by my reckoning…..

                                If you maintain the same ratio, then for a motor speed of 1400 rpm, top speed now falls by a factor of 0.3 or in revs it falls to 600 ish….(608….)

                                This assumes you run the motor at 50 hz….which is why I went for the 2 pole variant …..by running the motor at 85 hz, I can get near to that same speed…

                                So what you thinking now Mark?wink

                                Someone tell me I got this wrong…..(I rather hope Im not wrong else Ive got the wrong motor again…already bought a previous one…. – )

                                #205972
                                Gary Wooding
                                Participant
                                  @garywooding25363
                                  Posted by Mark P. on 28/09/2015 15:25:21:
                                  Surely the ratios will be the same regardless of motor speed, or am I looking at it from the wrong angle?

                                  Mark,

                                  You're correct, the ratios will be the same.

                                  If you use a 2 pole motor, its "native" speed is 2800rpm at 50Hz. If the VFD is set to 82Hz the motor will run at 4600rpm.

                                  Above 50hz, the motor will give full torque (same as at 50hz), but below 50Hz the power will be the same as at 50Hz, but the torque will be reduced (power = torquexRPM).

                                  Edited By Gary Wooding on 28/09/2015 15:41:26

                                  #205975
                                  Keith Long
                                  Participant
                                    @keithlong89920

                                    I hope your motor designed for 2850 rpm has a good margin of strength built in to withstand the increase in the stresses of running at 4600. If it won't I don't think I'd want to be in the same room as it when it lets go.

                                    #205979
                                    Anonymous
                                      Posted by Gary Wooding on 28/09/2015 15:41:04:

                                      Above 50hz, the motor will give full torque (same as at 50hz), but below 50Hz the power will be the same as at 50Hz, but the torque will be reduced (power = torquexRPM).

                                      Let's get this straight, assuming we're dealing with an induction motor with a base speed at a frequency of 50Hz. Base speed generally means where the motor is running at it's rated voltage, and hence rated current and up to rated power.

                                      Above 50Hz, at the rated voltage, there is less current, as the motor is turning faster and therefore there is more back emf opposing the current. So the current, and torque, go down but since the angular velocity has gone up the power stays roughly constant. So, above base speed you get constant power.

                                      Below 50Hz more current can be delivered at the rated voltage. However, to protect the motor the current is normally limited to the rated current. Since the current is constant the torque is constant, but the power decreases as the angular velocity reduces. So below base speed you get constant torque.

                                      To be precise the above equation should be:

                                      power (Watts) = torque (Nm) x angular velocity (radians/second)

                                      Andrew

                                      #205981
                                      JasonB
                                      Moderator
                                        @jasonb

                                        My comment was not what torque the motor would give at a given frequency but more what loss of torque there would be due to having to alter pully ratios to get the same spindle speed as the existing motor.

                                        Lets take the slow speed of 50-950rpm, DC motor is running at approx a 5:1 reduction ratio on the small pinion and large spindle pully. Motor running at 250-4600rpm.

                                        Using the same gear ratios the 4 pole would be giving speeds of 15-300rpm, and on the high ratio 30-600. So not a very fast top speed and do you want to run the motor as slow as 75rpm with little effect from the fan?

                                        To get nearer the same spindle speeds rather than a 5:1 reduction you will have to probably go for 1:1 and overrun the motor to get the 1900rpm top spindle speed. Low range would be 2:1 but you would then need to be running the motor at 100rpm to equal the current 50rpm slowest speed which could still give overheating issues .So assuming both motors have a similar torque you will only get 20% the mechanical advantage on the high speed and 40% on low

                                        Edited By JasonB on 28/09/2015 17:08:56

                                        #205982
                                        Les Jones 1
                                        Participant
                                          @lesjones1

                                          I agree with Andrew. If Gary's statement was correct it would imply infinite torque at zero speed.

                                          Les.

                                          #205986
                                          Mark P.
                                          Participant
                                            @markp

                                            Yes I was looking at it from the wrong angle, which angle I don’t know. Will go for a 1:1 or even a 1.5:1. I have never used the lathes high ratio in 6 years.

                                            #205989
                                            JasonB
                                            Moderator
                                              @jasonb

                                              Same here, only used it once when new to see what it was like and never again.

                                              Still not sure that running the motor at 50rpm with the 1:1 ratio would not give overheating problems

                                              #205990
                                              Mark P.
                                              Participant
                                                @markp

                                                Maybe a 2:1 or higher reduction back gear could be incorporated.

                                                #206019
                                                Cabinet Enforcer
                                                Participant
                                                  @cabinetenforcer

                                                  Mark,

                                                  I run a 1.1kW 80 frame 4 pole motor on my inverter converted WM280.

                                                  I use taperlock z section pulleys of size 71mm (motor) to 106mm (Spindle)

                                                  This motor power and belt /pulley setup should ideally be run with twin belts, a larger motor pulley would reduce this need, in practice one belt is fine most of the time, I couldn't be bothered to make a custom mount for the motor to facilitate lining up the pulleys to run 2 belts.

                                                  The pulleys give a ratio of circa 0.67, and in practice give a speed range of 75-2000 Rpm.

                                                  If I were to spec this up again I would go for a ratio nearer 0.5, which would give a slightly more usable low speed with a top end still at 1500.

                                                  The current setup with just 1 belt means the belt slips before the motor stalls, which is fine for my somewhat beginner level experience.

                                                  #206020
                                                  JasonB
                                                  Moderator
                                                    @jasonb

                                                    How do you find the lathe copes with larger dia work with that setup, say a 9 or 10" iron flywheel for example? and any size of overheating with prolonged use of teh 75rpm which would be about 50rpm of the motor.

                                                    J

                                                    #206022
                                                    Cabinet Enforcer
                                                    Participant
                                                      @cabinetenforcer
                                                      Posted by JasonB on 28/09/2015 20:26:31:

                                                      How do you find the lathe copes with larger dia work with that setup, say a 9 or 10" iron flywheel for example? and any size of overheating with prolonged use of teh 75rpm which would be about 50rpm of the motor.

                                                      J

                                                      Haven't a clue, as I haven't done any turning at that size yet, though the motor speed is about 110rpm at a spindle speed of 75.

                                                      I originally intended to get two pairs of pulleys, for high and low, but i went down the middle just to get the lathe up and running, I haven't found the need to change yet. I must get around to measuring up again for the largest size that'll fit under the guard so I can make up a low range set, I think it will be needed eventually.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 29 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up