If the gasket material is flimsy, almost any sealer applied to it will result in damage when removed, most certainly the "stickier" varieties. A brown paper gasket is likely to rip even if grease was used to hold it place while the mating part was fitted.
High torques on fixings of pressed steel components can cause soft joints, coated with Hylomar to be extruded..
It is difficult to disassemble soft joints, without some damage, once they have been subjected to sufficient clamping force. Cylinder Head nuts and studs, or bolts produce quite large clamp loads.
A screw thread gives a tremendous mechanical advantage to apply an axial load.
Think how long one turn of thread is, to give a lift of one pitch. 1/4" x 26 tpi gives a mechanical advantage of 20:1. Quite a long crowbar!, to which a force is then applied.
.As an example, a 1/2 UNF bolt in W range tightened just into yield exerts a 9 Ton clamp load!
And overtightening can bend even a deep casting, worsening leakage rather than curing it.
1/4 BSF can crack a Myford Cross Slide, as I know to my cost.
Howard