Posted by Tony Pratt 1 on 16/03/2020 14:57:59:
Guys, Guys, there is no way an over 70's 'going outdoors' ban could be enforced, we have bugger all police or army to do it. i suggest it might be sensible but hey who knows?
Tony
Well, we can explore the outer extremes of government power for fun, though I must emphasise it's extremely unlikely to come about.
Briefly, in an National Emergency, the Civil Contingency Act (2004) can be invoked. It allows Temporary Emergency Regulations to be imposed, normally by Order in Council, or exceptionally by a Minister of the Crown.
Temporary Regulations only last 30 days unless extended by Parliament, but – and this is the exciting bit – the only Primary Legislation that cannot be overturned by a Temporary Emergency Regulation is the Human Rights Act (1998) and Part Two of the Civil Contingency Act itself. All other UK law can be suspended or replaced by an Emergency Regulation.
Tony's absolutely right to draw attention to the difficulty of enforcing such extreme measures. But a Temporary Regulation could grow authority very quickly if necessary, for example by giving police powers to Civil Servants, Private Security Firms and others. Police powers could also be extended and normal legal protections relaxed. There's nothing to stop government conscripting a Citizen Militia or Cell & Block Wardens on the National Socialist Model, or introducing Tribunals, Camps, and other unusual measures for dealing with awkward customers. I think I'd obey if I were stopped during an illegal stroll by an untrained patrol of jumpy young men during a chaotic national crisis!
In the event the country is invaded, or civil war breaks out, the Army can Requisition civilian property as required. If they want your house for a barracks or latrine, it can be Requisitioned with almost no fuss. If they decide it has to be demolished, or turned into a fortification, that can happen too. Compensation is sorted out after, but it's rough work.
Brits live in a society that's been politically stable and externally unchallenged since 1945. We've grown used to the idea that water comes out of the tap, food is plentiful, health and pensions are catered for and the legal system protects us. While these benefits may seem to be our birthright, we skate on thin ice. At a personal level, life can go sour overnight due to Cancer, or a Stroke, or Dementia, or an road accident, crime, money or family problems. Society is more resilient, but it too can be badly shaken by 'events'. History is littered with examples of failed societies.
Coranavirus is a major event, but there are many other human and natural risks responsible governments must plan for. Fortunately none of the really nasty horrors are particularly likely, fingers crossed. Some come and go – the threat of Nuclear War and Famine is much diminished, but for all we know a large meteorite is on course to whack the planet next year!
In the event of a really major crisis, it's our job to manage as best we can. That means not panicking and putting the women and children first, not ourselves. I wish I was essential and irreplaceable but none of us are. I'm a bag of vulnerable biological processes, one of billions in a herd, all hoping for the best. Only death and taxes are certain.
Dave