Posted by Rainbows on 23/08/2015 20:30:35:
Posted by John Stevenson on 23/08/2015 19:34:57:
Years ago I used a ML7 in a near production capacity. In all the years I owned this lathe I had the chuck come loose twice.
Was it with a soft start motor or anything?
.
No bog standard single phase motor initially and then later a two speed three phase motor, no inverter, this was pre affordable VFD's
Inverters, in my book bring an extra action to the equation in that because these things have start up and stop ramps and most can be fitted with dynamic braking then the operator tunes these to the limits.
Why I have no idea. In a commercial environment it could save 0.2 seconds and over a working day this can add up but we are talking hobby / shed environment here and it's not needed.
All it does is stress parts not designed to be stopped on a 1/12th scale model of a sixpence.
Another problem is that the back EMF from stopping a motor fast more than not errors the drive out, that's why dynamic braking was implemented.
Stop a big motor in less than 1.5 seconds and most VFD's will error out on a low volts warning meaning you have to reset the VFD.
Keep it around two seconds and it removes all the strain of having a spanner thrown in the works and you actually work faster as you don't have to keep setting the VFD.
So if you do have to run in reverse the answer is to check the chuck before hand and take things steady. Use the tailstock centre if you can and be aware it can happen.
Good thing is it never happens in a split second, unless you are running at 33,000 revs you get a warning.
You see the wobble or results of it in the work and the note changes.
Anyone who is both blind and deaf will be well advised to rest their white stick on the chuck and they will feel the vibrations.
Edited By John Stevenson on 23/08/2015 21:08:02