Cookies and similar …

Advert

Cookies and similar …

Home Forums The Tea Room Cookies and similar …

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #522980
    Michael Gilligan
    Participant
      @michaelgilligan61133

      We often see [on the privacy pages of websites] words to the effect of : “Cookies are small data files stored on your computer … “

      I refuse as many as practical, and purge the others when convenient, but it’s surprising just how big some of these ‘small’ files can be surprise

      Here’s a snapshot of the top of today’s list:

      .

      519fe78e-321a-4ae2-9f36-b8d2a077c622.jpeg

      .

      Several of those are bigger than the first Hard Disk Drive that I purchased.

      MichaelG.

      .

      .

      P.S. __ and I don’t even use Facebook !!

      Edited By Michael Gilligan on 27/01/2021 09:48:46

      Advert
      #36257
      Michael Gilligan
      Participant
        @michaelgilligan61133
        #522988
        not done it yet
        Participant
          @notdoneityet

          I suspect it is only the bottom three which were not bigger?

          Our first computer managed to operate with only 32 kB of RAM and no hard disk. The stored memory was on 100kB floppy discs (and that may have been 50kB on each side).

          #522992
          Russell Eberhardt
          Participant
            @russelleberhardt48058

            They are all bigger than my first hard drive!

            Russell

            #523002
            Frances IoM
            Participant
              @francesiom58905

              they are not cookies but preloaded web images etc in your cache – many pages have a header that loads many images so that they are available for next time – there are extensions for firefox that allow you to block certain sites – personally I’d block the majority of that list as the companies usually drop many trackers and provide you with no benefit – always block 3rd party cookies as these are trackers.

              Edited By Frances IoM on 27/01/2021 10:56:03

              #523014
              Clive Hartland
              Participant
                @clivehartland94829

                Using CCleaner seems to sort out all the useless files that get put on the hard disk.

                #523016
                Howard Lewis
                Participant
                  @howardlewis46836

                  I've set mine (Can't remember exactly how ) to delete all cookies at each shut down.

                  The hope is that by so doing, we shall not be plagued by unwanted pop ups, or telephone calls.

                  Anyone noticed a lot more scam calls purporting to be from Amazon, just lately?

                  They usually give them selves away by having too many zeroes on the area code. Prerecorded or it would be nice to chat to someone, if only to waste their time and bill!

                  Howard

                  Edited By Howard Lewis on 27/01/2021 11:36:17

                  #523028
                  Michael Gilligan
                  Participant
                    @michaelgilligan61133

                    Whilst I have absolutely no objection to the rapid digression … I must just mention that my real interest was the astonishing size of some of these small [sic] files.

                    If anyone can explain what might be contained therein, I would be interested !

                    … Where and when was the definition of a 'small text file' ?

                    MichaelG.

                    .

                    .

                    [quote]

                    A cookie is a small text file that websites pass to your computer through your web browser. Its purpose is to extend the website's functionality and create a better user experience, usually through personalization, session management, and tracking. A cookie might save user inputs, shopping carts, login information, or wish lists. It can also be used for advertising and analytics.

                    [/quote]

                    Ref. **LINK**

                    https://www.osano.com/articles/how-cookies-work

                    #523042
                    Journeyman
                    Participant
                      @journeyman

                      As Frances IoM said earlier, those files are too large for cookies. In Firefox all cookies are stored in one file within the users profile. The file name is 'cookies.sqllite' (an sql database file) at present on my system this file is only 2.1MB. I expect other browsers use a similar regime for cookie storage.

                      John

                      #523051
                      Michael Gilligan
                      Participant
                        @michaelgilligan61133
                        Posted by Journeyman on 27/01/2021 14:12:40:

                        As Frances IoM said earlier, those files are too large for cookies. In Firefox all cookies are stored in one file within the users profile. The file name is 'cookies.sqllite' (an sql database file) at present on my system this file is only 2.1MB. I expect other browsers use a similar regime for cookie storage.

                        John

                        .

                        Sorry, John & Frances

                        Yes, I do realise that the size is inflated by 'website data' … but [for example], I do not use Facebook

                        It's the lack of probity & clarity that concerns me : It may only be 'a small text file' that they initially place on my machine, but why then is it so big now ?

                        Next time I clear the iPad I will note the size of some of these 'at first appearance'

                        MichaelG.

                        #523057
                        Calum
                        Participant
                          @calumgalleitch87969

                          The initial screenshot shows "Website Data", not cookies. I am not up to speed on the details but there are now other mechanisms for storing information on your computer than cookies. In theory, of course, all to your benefit if you are not having to download the same thing over and over, but who knows?

                          #523072
                          Michael Gilligan
                          Participant
                            @michaelgilligan61133
                            Posted by Calum Galleitch on 27/01/2021 15:27:06:

                            The initial screenshot shows "Website Data", not cookies. I am not up to speed on the details but there are now other mechanisms for storing information on your computer than cookies. In theory, of course, all to your benefit if you are not having to download the same thing over and over, but who knows?

                            .

                            Indeed it does [it’s from the iPad, and that's how they show it] … hence the chosen title for my thread.

                            MichaelG.

                            #523074
                            duncan webster 1
                            Participant
                              @duncanwebster1

                              I've stopped using Arc Euro's website as it doesn't give the option of refusing cookies. I think that I'm supposed to opt in, which I never do

                              #523081
                              Fowlers Fury
                              Participant
                                @fowlersfury

                                It is infuriating now that when opening most websites, you're required to approve or reject "non-essential" cookies before it will load.
                                I have though found one solution which works on 90% of websites. It's a free add-on for Firefox and Chrome called "Behind the Overlay". Firefox version:-

                                **LINK**

                                It places a small icon in the search bar, or you can Shift+Alt+x. When confronted by the cookie overlay, either click on the icon or use the 3 key combination and the cookie overlay disappears and access the site as normal.
                                A few sites then block scrolling but there's a work-around described.

                                #523083
                                Fowlers Fury
                                Participant
                                  @fowlersfury

                                  Duncan, just used "Behind the Overlay" on Arc Euro's site and that cookie overlay disappeared leaving normal access.

                                  (Typo corrected)

                                  Edited By Fowlers Fury on 27/01/2021 16:31:40

                                  #523093
                                  SillyOldDuffer
                                  Moderator
                                    @sillyoldduffer

                                    We need a Safari expert, but I think Michael's report is of the total storage taken by those websites on his computer. They're not individual files, rather it's space taken by many files, or more likely the same data in database records.

                                    'Web Data' is cached web pages, cookies, and other objects plus web history, maybe all going back to the year dot.

                                    Michael's useful 'whodunnit ' view comes from the Browser or a Cache Viewing app. But Firefox stores web data by type, making it easier to see what it is. Here's what Linux says Firefox has stored on my computer.

                                    webdata.jpg

                                    217Mb in total of which only 1.6Mb is cookies, i.e. it's true – they are small files. The big boys on my machine are:

                                    82Mb of favicons cached locally to improve performance

                                    76Mb places also cached locally to improve performance

                                    and

                                    58Mb webappsstore – the plugins & addons I've loaded into my Browser.

                                    How much storage is consumed depends on the owners privacy policy settings, the type of material browsed, and how many web queries are done.

                                    Is material stored on our computers and shared across the web a privacy problem? I think so. For good and bad you are being tracked.

                                    Dave

                                    #523129
                                    clivel
                                    Participant
                                      @clivel

                                      As others have noted, what Michael is seeing is cached data and not cookies. Cached data is used to minimise network traffic and also to reduce page load times.

                                      For example, when viewing this site, I regularly see the same adverts and images over and over, so rather than my browser downloading them each and every time, they are downloaded only once, only to be downloaded again after a preset expiry time or when they change.

                                      As far as I am aware most browsers allow the user to control the maximum cache size, but this is often an advanced setting and should be left well alone.

                                      Cookies, on the other hand, are small. They are restricted to a maximum of a few kilobytes each, and a browser will only store a limited number of cookies for each site.

                                      Cookies are not the malignant force that so many seem to think they are, but can instead be very useful. For example, I like it if I visit a shopping site, don't complete my order and come back a few days later to find my shopping cart still contains the items I have added. Or when I visit a forum such as this which has saved my login information to save me typing it in again.

                                      Of course, cookies, like most things, can be used for nefarious purposes, but do I really care if a site shows me ads related to my interests or not, I tend to ignore most ads anyway. It should be noted that only the site that placed the cookie can read it. Cookies can not be used for transferring data from one site to the next.

                                      I routinely accept all cookies, and rarely delete them unless I am working on a computer that is not my own, The time, hassle and inconvenience really isn't worth it.

                                      Clive

                                      #523162
                                      Peter Greene
                                      Participant
                                        @petergreene36336
                                        Posted by duncan webster on 27/01/2021 16:19:14:

                                        I've stopped using Arc Euro's website as it doesn't give the option of refusing cookies. I think that I'm supposed to opt in, which I never do

                                        I've noticed many sites do give an option with two buttons: <Accept> or <Customise> cookies.

                                        If you go to <Customise> all cookies are off except necessary cookies for local site navigation (fair enough). The implication is that this set-up is the default you would get if you took the original <Accept>.

                                        I don't believe it.

                                        (Sorry Michael)

                                        #523309
                                        Bill Phinn
                                        Participant
                                          @billphinn90025
                                          Posted by Peter Greene on 27/01/2021 22:49:37:

                                          Posted by duncan webster on 27/01/2021 16:19:14:

                                          I've stopped using Arc Euro's website as it doesn't give the option of refusing cookies. I think that I'm supposed to opt in, which I never do

                                          I've noticed many sites do give an option with two buttons: <Accept> or <Customise> cookies.

                                          If you go to <Customise> all cookies are off except necessary cookies for local site navigation (fair enough). The implication is that this set-up is the default you would get if you took the original <Accept>.

                                          (Sorry Michael)

                                          What happens with the cookies if, instead of clicking on either accept or customize, you just close the window by clicking on the x at top right?

                                          #523312
                                          Calum
                                          Participant
                                            @calumgalleitch87969
                                            Posted by clivel on 27/01/2021 19:45:36:

                                            Of course, cookies, like most things, can be used for nefarious purposes

                                            On top of this, it is worth knowing that almost every user on the internet is uniquely identified by your IP, browser, operating system, and other information that is sent by default to every website on the internet. If 'they' want to know who you are, it's not a problem for them.

                                            #523315
                                            Peter Greene
                                            Participant
                                              @petergreene36336
                                              Posted by Bill Phinn on 28/01/2021 15:52:57:

                                              What happens with the cookies if, instead of clicking on either accept or customize, you just close the window by clicking on the x at top right?

                                              Dunno …. I've always assumed the site owners take the attitude "we gave you the chance to opt out but you didn't take it … so we'll assume you're opting in".

                                              #523320
                                              Frances IoM
                                              Participant
                                                @francesiom58905

                                                Firefox states that it blocks 3 trackers from the Arceuro site (one of which is the ubiquitous google-analytics by which site owners trade your privacy for them getting some info on your use of the web site, another is doubleclick whose function in life is to serve adverts) – however if you click on the close button on the overlay it appears that firefox allows the site to drop three cookies owned by arceuro so under Firefox default settings no real tracking and Firefox can be set to remove all cookies on closing connection

                                                ETA obviously under Android owned by Google you would be tracked to the ends of the earth and beyond (basically Android is a spy device literally tracking your every move- I suspect Apple may well be similar judging from the names in Michaels example

                                                Edited By Frances IoM on 28/01/2021 16:15:35

                                                #523339
                                                Fowlers Fury
                                                Participant
                                                  @fowlersfury

                                                  Ref earlier posting " On top of this, it is worth knowing that almost every user on the internet is uniquely identified by your IP, browser, operating system, and other information that is sent by default to every website on the internet. If 'they' want to know who you are, it's not a problem for them. "

                                                  Does the "almost" above mean all those who don't use a VPN? Seems unlikely as in 2020 (quote) "If you use a VPN, you're among around 31% of internet users".
                                                  **LINK**

                                                  Using a good VPN provides a whole manner of safeguards and benefits since you're not identifiable to the websites visited.

                                                  #523823
                                                  Calum
                                                  Participant
                                                    @calumgalleitch87969

                                                    A VPN removes exactly one of the identifying attributes I mentioned: your IP. If you want to obfuscate the other pieces of information, you have to use a VPN service that does so automatically or you have to configure it yourself.

                                                    > If you use a VPN, you're among around 31% of internet users

                                                    While that's probably a fair reflection of total internet traffic, I doubt it reflects the average internet user in the West.

                                                    At the end of the day, almost every website of interest requires you to identify yourself to it and re-identify when you visit again, so there is only so much that paranoia can save you from.

                                                    #524272
                                                    Michael Gilligan
                                                    Participant
                                                      @michaelgilligan61133
                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums The Tea Room Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert