Sourcing Worm and Wheel Gear Arrangement

Advert

Sourcing Worm and Wheel Gear Arrangement

Home Forums General Questions Sourcing Worm and Wheel Gear Arrangement

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 31 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #24390
    David Cambridge
    Participant
      @davidcambridge45658

      Sourcing Worm and Wheel Gear Arrangement

      Advert
      #225584
      David Cambridge
      Participant
        @davidcambridge45658

        Does anyone know where I can get a pair of worm and wheel gears for this sort of arrangement? The reduction ratio needs to be 2:1 (i.e. for a 4 stroke engine) and the diameter of the crank shaft will be of the order 10mm to 12mm ? I’ve spent a while trying to find them on Google, but haven’t managed to come up with anything yet.

        Thanks in advance,

        David

        worm and wheel.jpg

        Edited By David Cambridge on 16/02/2016 09:11:43

        #225588
        Les Jones 1
        Participant
          @lesjones1

          Hi David,
          A worm and wheel cannot give such a small reduction as 2:1 I think what you are looking for are skew gears. (Also called helical gears.)

          Les.

          #225590
          David Cambridge
          Participant
            @davidcambridge45658

            Ah – yes. This image is on wikipedia for helical gears. The lower section is exactly what I'm after. Are they difficult to cut? (I'll have a look in my copy of Ivan Laws book this evening!).

            David

            800px-helical_gears.jpg

            #225595
            David Cambridge
            Participant
              @davidcambridge45658

              Now I now what I'm looking for http://hpcgears.com looks like a good option!

              #225598
              John Stevenson 1
              Participant
                @johnstevenson1

                Correct they are called skew gears which are just helicals with the same hand.

                Normally helicals operating in the same plane need to be opposite hand but if mounted in the a 90 degree plane they need to be same hand.

                Normal plane.

                Opposite plane.

                #225608
                Roderick Jenkins
                Participant
                  @roderickjenkins93242

                  David,

                  Sadly, Ivan law doesn't go into helical gears in his book. I made a pair of gears for my Wyvern engine which uses a similar arrangement on a 1/2" crankshaft and a 1/4" sideshaft. I think Hemingway do the gears. Diane has an article on how I made mine which may be suitable for publication. We had quite a discussion on an earlier thread

                  HTH,

                  Rod

                  #225616
                  John P
                  Participant
                    @johnp77052

                    Hi David

                    There was in the Model engineer some time ago an interesting
                    method of producing these type of skew gears .
                    The author was Jock Smith and can be found from 1995
                    Me Vol 174 issue 3989 page 336 and 3991 page 468.

                    Seen in album " gears " 3 photos 2 are from article MEW 193
                    Gear hobbing in the mill and shows a skew gear being hobbed
                    and the other some completed gears .The hobs were from Arc Euro
                    I think these are now all sold out and they now don't seem to sell
                    them anymore which is a shame as they were a very good cutting tool.
                    Obviously there is quite a lot to make to be able to produce these
                    type of gears in this way and to some extent depends on how many
                    gears you need ,i seem to make more and more of these as time
                    goes by the third photo some gears and some toothed belt pullies
                    made recently.

                    John

                    #225626
                    Ajohnw
                    Participant
                      @ajohnw51620

                      There is a person in the Ukraine selling various hobs pretty cheaply on ebay uk and usa. He has 0.8mod, other sizes and some of the usual gear cutters as well. Russian work at it's finest going on some I bought.

                      John

                      #225864
                      Tim Stevens
                      Participant
                        @timstevens64731

                        One aspect of skew gears to remember – especially on drives like camshafts where the load is high and variable – is to ensure copious lubrication. Another is to ensure that end float of either gear is eliminated (so far as poss).

                        On my 1928 car with a skew gear to drive the magneto (a light load) the gears are trapped between thrust bearings, and the pressure relief from the oil pump blows all the 'spare' oil onto the gear just ahead of engagement.

                        Cheers, Tim

                        #225906
                        Ian S C
                        Participant
                          @iansc

                          I agree with Tim, under much of a load the wear is quite high, its best if the gears are of different materials, ie. steel for one, and bronze for the other. Reason is that the action is a sliding one, and unless they are cast iron, two like metals can tend to pick up on each other, although the brass Meccano ones seem to do all right. I suppose you could liken a skew gear to a multi start worm.

                          Ian S C

                          #225926
                          David Cambridge
                          Participant
                            @davidcambridge45658

                            I think there is still something fundamental going on that I don’t understand.

                            If I want a 2:1 ratio between the crank and cam shaft, and I look at helical gears on hpcgears.com the diameter of the large gear (I’d use this for the cam shaft) is twice that of the small gear(Id use this for the crank shaft). Since PD = N/DP that seems fair enough. But, when I look at the photos like the image of a Find Hansen engine at the top of this thread, the two gears look either the same size or the opposite way round to what I was expecting ?

                            David

                            #225927
                            David Cambridge
                            Participant
                              @davidcambridge45658
                              About 1:47 into the below video is an example of my above post.
                              #225928
                              Roderick Jenkins
                              Participant
                                @roderickjenkins93242

                                David,

                                It depends on the helix angle. For helical gears, if you want a right angle drive then the helix angles just have to add up to 90 degrees. The pitch diameter of a helical gear is given by N divided by (DP x Cos(A)) where N is the number of teeth, DP is the Diametrical Pitch and A is the helix angle. For 45 degree helix angles Cos (A) =1 so the relative diameters depend soley on the number of teeth – 36 teeth will be twice the diameter of an 18 tooth. If you choose 26.6 degrees and 63.4 degrees for the 2 helix angles then you end up with 2:1 gears that have the same OD – which is what the Wyvern uses:

                                gear 9.jpg

                                HTH,

                                Rod

                                Edited By Roderick Jenkins on 18/02/2016 13:20:47  To correct the error MichaelG pointed out below

                                Edited By Roderick Jenkins on 18/02/2016 13:33:04

                                #225929
                                Michael Gilligan
                                Participant
                                  @michaelgilligan61133

                                  Posted by Roderick Jenkins on 18/02/2016 13:19:23:

                                  For helical gears, if you want a right angle drive then the helix angles just have to add up to 90 degrees.

                                  If you choose 36.6 degrees and 63.4 degrees for the 2 helix angles then you end up with 2:1 gears that have the same OD – which is what the Wyvern uses:

                                  .

                                  Rod,

                                  Forgive me if I am being very stupid today, but:

                                  36.6 + 63.4 = 100

                                  Does it not ?

                                  MichaelG.

                                  #225930
                                  JasonB
                                  Moderator
                                    @jasonb

                                    You can see the angle on this Domestic that I made, the shallow angle on the crank gear lets it be larger than the cam gear where you would normally find the opposite with spur gears. This allows the larger dia crank to pass through without such a thin wall as in Rod's photo

                                    Better shot where you can see the helix of both gears

                                    Edited By JasonB on 18/02/2016 13:28:57

                                    Edited By JasonB on 18/02/2016 13:30:56

                                    #225931
                                    Roderick Jenkins
                                    Participant
                                      @roderickjenkins93242
                                      Posted by Michael Gilligan on 18/02/2016 13:26:23:

                                      Posted by Roderick Jenkins on 18/02/2016 13:19:23:

                                      For helical gears, if you want a right angle drive then the helix angles just have to add up to 90 degrees.

                                      If you choose 36.6 degrees and 63.4 degrees for the 2 helix angles then you end up with 2:1 gears that have the same OD – which is what the Wyvern uses:

                                      .

                                      Rod,

                                      Forgive me if I am being very stupid today, but:

                                      36.6 + 63.4 = 100

                                      Does it not ?

                                      MichaelG.

                                      Not as stupid as me! Sorry, typo – should be 26.6 blush . Rushing to go out to my guitar lesson – really must go now!

                                      Rod

                                      Rod

                                      #225933
                                      David Cambridge
                                      Participant
                                        @davidcambridge45658

                                        Thanks everyone. The missing part of my understanding was the cos(A) in the formula

                                        David

                                        #225934
                                        Martin Connelly
                                        Participant
                                          @martinconnelly55370

                                          If we are picking holes in this then cos(45) does not equal 1, Tan(45) equals 1 and cos(45) is 0.707 (square root of 2).

                                          Martin

                                          #225939
                                          Martin Connelly
                                          Participant
                                            @martinconnelly55370

                                            Further to this 2:1 ratio in similar sized diameters for skew gears:

                                            The angles in the example above are found from the inverse tan of 0.5 and 2 (half the speed one way and double the speed the other).

                                            Tan(63.435)=2

                                            Tan(26.565)=0.5

                                            The angles have been rounded to 3 significant decimals. If they are rounded to 1 decimal you get the angles stated earlier.

                                            Hope this helps anyone considering other possible ratios.

                                            Martin

                                            #225941
                                            Roderick Jenkins
                                            Participant
                                              @roderickjenkins93242
                                              Posted by Martin Connelly on 18/02/2016 13:55:04:

                                              If we are picking holes in this then cos(45) does not equal 1, Tan(45) equals 1 and cos(45) is 0.707 (square root of 2).

                                              Martin

                                              Pick holes we must – got to get it right. The point I should have been trying to make was that with both gears at 45 degrees you use the same divisor, so that the relative diameters stay in proportion to the teeth number.

                                              Sorry again – must try not to rush things.

                                              Rod

                                              #225944
                                              JasonB
                                              Moderator
                                                @jasonb

                                                Well if we are picking holes then sq root of 2 is 1.414 in my bookwink 2

                                                #225947
                                                John Stevenson 1
                                                Participant
                                                  @johnstevenson1

                                                  Doesn't matter what formulae is used, you will still get squiggly teeth.

                                                  #226009
                                                  David Cambridge
                                                  Participant
                                                    @davidcambridge45658

                                                    So armed with my new understanding, I can now ask the original question more sensibly.

                                                    Does anyone know where I can get helical gears of angles other than 45 degrees. I get the impression from the HPC web site they will make gears to order, but if I can find them on the shelf that would probably be better ?

                                                    #226014
                                                    Anonymous
                                                      Posted by David Cambridge on 18/02/2016 22:50:50:

                                                      Does anyone know where I can get helical gears of angles other than 45 degrees.

                                                      Stock Drive ?

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 31 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up