Posted by alan lloyd 3 on 14/12/2017 18:57:58:
Exactly if that resistor goes short circuit you will be pluged into the mains, the electrians I worked with would never use them
I've rarely, if ever, come across a normal carbon type resistor go Short Circuit, only go High Resistance, or Open Circuit.
Capacitors on the other hand………..
Regarding the little beepy flashy pen mains detectors, I've never been comfortable with them to detect the absence of mains, just the presence of a voltage. It's always hard to prove a negative.
The way I sometimes use one is to clip or place it next to the circuit to be tested, such that it is bleeping/flashing permanently. Then when you turn off the switch and the detector notices, you know you've isolated the correct circuit; assuming that it's not dual fed of course.
Also, even with a meter, test the tester before testing the circuit, to help prevent false readings.
Bill