A first for ME&W

A first for ME&W

Home › Forums › Model Engineer. › A first for ME&W

Viewing 25 posts - 26 through 50 (of 66 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #871272
    bernard towers
    Participant
      @bernardtowers37738

      EGA, do a page count for the last issue

      #871273
      JasonB
      Moderator
        @jasonb

        What Neil had to say recently about Content. Here

        If MEW content is not coming in he can’t publish what he does not have. Also time of year means you will get articles about how far a loco will go on a teaspoon of coal. I expect there will be some MMEX reports filling the pages, apparently not much home made tooling on show so expect more photos of models. Could that be a sign that people are making models and not tools, the other forums HMEM, MEM, Mech, all have very little “tool” content

        #871330
        JA
        Participant
          @ja

          I have always considered tools as a means to an end and not an end in their selves.

          I think Jason has already commented on it but the lack of interest on the forum in MMEX saddens me. If I was Neil I would take note and do the obvious – not report on MMEX at all.

          JA

          #871347
          Nigel Graham 2
          Participant
            @nigelgraham2

            Regarding the copyright problem, our long-standing principle is of an author designing and building a project (usually a complex model), having drawings, photographs and instructions published in the magazine; then finding a retailer for the drawings and raw materials.

            Is Kesley trying to kill this?

            Assuming the design to be a working miniature of an old machine appropriately modified for construction and function, or is a project original to its maker, if Kelsey demands all rights to all material submitted to it:

             

            To whom does the drawings copyright then belong?

            The designer, the plan-set retailer… or Kelsey?

             

            To whom does the design right belong?

            The designer… or Kelsey?

             

            What if a builder/owner submits his own photographs to both his club magazine or web-site, or some “social-medium” other than this forum, having already sent them to MEW?

             

            +++++

             

            I explored Kelsey Media’s own web-sites and Wikipedia entry. The latter omits MEW and Radio Control Models & Electronics, the only two titles dedicated to anyone creating anything; excluding farming and amateur-gardeners’ magazines, and a couple on motor-vehicle maintenance.

            Woodwork, metalwork, computing and CAD/CAM, electronics generally (apart from a shoppers’ review magazine), model-railways, any models not in MEW and RCME remit, painting & pottery, cookery, household DIY…  all excluded.

            Even knitting, needlework and related, despite the “Alpacas” magazine. If we cannot make a spinning-wheel we cannot use all that soft camelid hair!

            Most of those hobbies have or had their journals, but is Kelsey Media unable to understand the desire to create things? Perhaps that dangerous desire has been covered in KM’s home-hypondriacs’ glossy Psychologies [sic].

             

            If a hobby find its hard to attract newcomers, maybe this profits-led suppression is one of the many reasons.

            At least Kelsey Media is a British company, not owned by the take-and-destroy “venture capital” spivs in Wall Street or Shanghai.

            #871359
            JA
            Participant
              @ja

              Why would a “venture capital” want to own ME&W? I can only see one reason for Kelsey owning ME&W.

              JA

              #871360
              Bazyle
              Participant
                @bazyle

                It is really quite simple. As a first time author you submit your wonderful article with a covering letter explaining that it is submitted for one time publishing with all right retained by the author, etc whatever conditions you want.
                Their admin/secretary who is just that with no technical understanding whatsoever will send back their term asking you to sign them.
                You respond by reminding them of your initial letter. It is up to them to accept your terms it they are keen enough to need your article. If it was crap they won’t bother – that is down to you.

                #871361
                JasonB
                Moderator
                  @jasonb

                  That “long established” tradition went out the window years ago. I think the last set of drawings published separately were for the Nemett Lynx by Malcom stride back in about 2012. That is the last time Myhobbystore added a new set of drawings, don’t know when the last loco was added before that.

                  #871368
                  Charles Lamont
                  Participant
                    @charleslamont71117
                    On JA Said:

                    I have always considered tools as a means to an end and not an end in their selves.

                    I think Jason has already commented on it but the lack of interest on the forum in MMEX saddens me. If I was Neil I would take note and do the obvious – not report on MMEX at all.

                    JA

                    There was very little tooling at MMEX this year. Sometimes there is some, and sometimes not.

                    I like making tools to a good standard of finish, and maybe one day I will have something to exhibit.

                     

                     

                    #871373
                    Nigel Graham 2
                    Participant
                      @nigelgraham2

                      JA –

                      I didn’t say a money-trader would want to own a title. It would want the company publishing the titles.

                       

                      Bazyle –

                      I don’t think literary and technical quality would count for anything in that argument.

                      The administrator need not understand the article. Accepting or rejecting an article on contents is for the specific magazine’s editors; but acceptance or rejection of the Terms & Conditions in any across-board transaction may well be a YES/NO question handled by some clerk obeying Procedures not knowledge, nor initiative.

                       

                      Jason –

                      I didn’t know that. It’s worrying, suggesting no-one is preparing plans for publication. They don’t have to be of locomotives, either, and it’s not the trade’s fault if it doesn’t receive any such material.

                       

                      Charles –

                      Is there any significant lack of interest in MMEX on this Forum? Yes or no, your suggestion that it need not be covered in the magazine is hardly going to help!

                       

                      #871374
                      JasonB
                      Moderator
                        @jasonb
                        On Nigel Graham 2 Said:

                         

                         

                        Charles –

                        Is there any significant lack of interest in MMEX on this Forum? Yes or no, your suggestion that it need not be covered in the magazine is hardly going to help!

                         

                        I’d say there is a significant lack of interest on this forum compared to others. Maybe you need to look at some other forums to see where the interest is.

                        MEM have been discussing it for months partly due to arranging their own display but there are a lot of other posts both prior to as well as after the show with many photos posted and some video. Link here to a six page thread, may have to register to see some of the images posted as attachments https://www.modelenginemaker.com/index.php?topic=12989.45

                        Even MECH this year has a good range of photos as well as comments on the exhibits, meeting up etc. https://modeleng.proboards.com/thread/16089/midlands-model-engineering-exhibition-october?page=2

                        Compare that to what we have here, Meridians few posts about tickets, etc. Your post about booking and a few odd ones by the likes of Noel. Also a couple of people posting about their club stand.

                        So certainly a lot less interest and if you want a report then you will see a lot more on the net than is worth publishing. Photos will be better quality and a good size, video you can’t put on paper.

                        If the lack of interest on here is an indication of the subscribers interest in the subject then I’m inclined to agree with Charles and not give it much in the way of page space.

                        #871383
                        John Haine
                        Participant
                          @johnhaine32865
                          On mike barrett 1 Said:

                          difficult to please everyone. But I have just ordered the latest copy online as I am interested in 3D printing!
                          Expensive way of getting a copy but I dont know of anywhere that would have for sale locally…:(

                          You’d learn a lot more from online sources much quicker and cheaper.

                          #871384
                          John Haine
                          Participant
                            @johnhaine32865

                            Thanks Jason. And what the the definition of “The Work”?

                            #871385
                            Michael Gilligan
                            Participant
                              @michaelgilligan61133
                              On John Haine Said:

                              […]  And what the the definition of “The Work”?

                              In the absence of a clear contractual definition … I would presume it to be the totality of what the contributor was submitting at the time.

                              MichaelG..

                              #871390
                              JasonB
                              Moderator
                                @jasonb

                                I would think so too.

                                I suppose one way to get round it would be to take two photos of everything, Lay out your drawings differently and do an alternative text if you felt that at some point you may want to use or publish elsewhere.

                                #871392
                                Charles Lamont
                                Participant
                                  @charleslamont71117
                                  On Nigel Graham 2 Said:

                                  Charles –

                                  Is there any significant lack of interest in MMEX on this Forum? Yes or no, your suggestion that it need not be covered in the magazine is hardly going to help!

                                   

                                  Nigel, Jason

                                  Read it again. How on earth did you get the idea that I wrote anything like that?

                                  On the contrary, I think MMEX is very much within the subject area of the mag.

                                  #871393
                                  JasonB
                                  Moderator
                                    @jasonb

                                    I’m not sure how far back Kelsey go but one of their old titles was Stationary Engine Magazine and that always had a section for models. They also produced several books on building specific models which were a compliation of articles that had been in the mag. That must be 25yrs ago so they have always known that people like to create things.

                                    #871394
                                    JasonB
                                    Moderator
                                      @jasonb

                                      Charles, I used Nigel’s quote but my comments were more that I was in agreement with JA that this FORUM has shown little interest compared to others. Even You only posted your photos on MEM so I have to assume you felt that most here would not be interested. (Unless you are saving them for a writeup in the mag?)

                                      It is within the subject matter but how many will read it? Not many if as I said interest is similar to that on this forum.

                                      Last years write up was spread over 3 issues, 12 pages but if people here are more interested in machines and tools all they got were two small photos neither of which showed the subject very well.

                                      #871395
                                      John Haine
                                      Participant
                                        @johnhaine32865
                                        On Michael Gilligan Said:
                                        On John Haine Said:

                                        […]  And what the the definition of “The Work”?

                                        In the absence of a clear contractual definition … I would presume it to be the totality of what the contributor was submitting at the time.

                                        MichaelG..

                                        If the word is capitalised in a contract it usually indicates that it is subject to a definition in a specific clause very near the front. What does the whole agreement say?

                                        #871396
                                        JasonB
                                        Moderator
                                          @jasonb

                                          You will have to ask Neil for a copy, I only have what I posted.

                                          #871401
                                          southernchap
                                          Participant
                                            @southernchap
                                            On Andrew Tinsley Said:

                                            Please don’t give me “write an article for ME&W”. It is a commercial enterprise, there to make a profit. New authors lose the rights to their work since the latest takeover.

                                            I agree that you can’t please everyone, I am not complaining, just observing that there was nothing of interest in the current magazine. Surely any feedback must be useful to the editor.

                                            Andrew.

                                            Absolutely this.

                                            As I’ve said before, that’s an argument which is valid for free parish magazines, not for a commercial publication.

                                            I don’t imagine anybody’s criticising Neil, he’s doing the best with what he can get.

                                            The publisher got it wrong when they merged MEW with ME.  Choo choos are currently a dying interest and that was always inevitable.

                                            ‘Making’, whilst not exactly the big buzz, at least has some current cultural traction.

                                            The publishers, in common with most late stage capitalist enterprises, are just trying to squeeze the last of the juice out the fruit.

                                            What would have probably been more sustainable, would be to put some actual effort in, see where they can raise interest in the magazine from non traditional potential outlets like school DT/STEM departments (such as they exist now, I’ll grant), maker spaces, “men’s” sheds/community workshops/repair cafes, youth community groups, etc.

                                            But that would have required vision, courage, and an interest in anything beyond the bottom line.

                                            If anything, it should have been the ‘loco strokers’ who should have been deprioritised (and I say this, despite Saint Stefan of Gotteswinter having just announced that he’s going to start building Kozo’s New Shay; eh, I’ll watch the videos to learn from his always fascinating skill, his brilliant insights on workholding and tooling use, and his very dry, but warm German humour).

                                            All this said, Julie’s article was enjoyable, and I’m looking forward to the next part.

                                             

                                            #871405
                                            southernchap
                                            Participant
                                              @southernchap
                                              On JasonB Said:

                                              Could that be a sign that people are making models and not tools, the other forums HMEM, MEM, Mech, all have very little “tool” content

                                              Or take a look at Hobby Machinist Forum ( https://www.hobby-machinist.com/forums/ ). Yeah, it’s dominated by our American cousins, but certainly no worse for that, model making is not a big thing on that forum (not as much traffic on the gunsmithing section as one might expect either😄).  There’s a very broad range of discussions on various machining topics there.

                                              #871481
                                              Charles Lamont
                                              Participant
                                                @charleslamont71117
                                                On JasonB Said:

                                                Charles, I used Nigel’s quote but my comments were more that I was in agreement with JA that this FORUM has shown little interest compared to others. Even You only posted your photos on MEM so I have to assume you felt that most here would not be interested. (Unless you are saving them for a writeup in the mag?)

                                                 

                                                This seems to me to be mostly a UK populated forum and I assumed that most people on here would know about the show and would find reports if they wanted them. MEM, OTOH, seems to me to have a much more international following, so I posted a few photos thinking they were mainly for the benefit of foreigners. No, I am not saving my photos. I can post them here if you like, but I think there is better coverage available.

                                                #871556
                                                Michael Gilligan
                                                Participant
                                                  @michaelgilligan61133

                                                  I have just submitted my Feed-back:

                                                  .

                                                  IMG_2147

                                                  .

                                                  Other disgruntled subscribers might usefully do the same.

                                                  MichaelG.

                                                  #871558
                                                  JA
                                                  Participant
                                                    @ja

                                                    I found Charles’s and others’ photos of MMEX exhibits on MEM very interesting and possibly useful. (Just a comment without any following questions).

                                                    JA

                                                    #871637
                                                    John Haine
                                                    Participant
                                                      @johnhaine32865

                                                      Surely someone could just copy the definitions of the “the Work” and “the Material” for me please? Or provide a copy of the whole agreement?

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 26 through 50 (of 66 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home › Forums › Model Engineer. › Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.