What size drill

Advert

What size drill

Home Forums Workshop Tools and Tooling What size drill

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 56 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #254769
    Mike Brett
    Participant
      @mikebrett89695

      Hi

      Can anyone tell me what size drill I need to order to drill a 3.3 mm hole. I have ordered two lots of 3.3 mm drills and although they had 3.3 stamped on the base of the drill there actual measurement was 3.19 mm. Result of this was a broken tap, help please.

      Mike

      Advert
      #18195
      Mike Brett
      Participant
        @mikebrett89695

        Ordering drill bits

        #254772
        MW
        Participant
          @mw27036

          That sounds quite bizzare mike, i'd just go for HSS fully ground drill, normally with plastic and aluminium it will drill slightly undersize, in most metals it will drill slightly oversize.

          You can drill bigger than 3.3 and it will still produce a thread on an M4x 0.7mm tap. 3.4 should be okay even if it doesnt do the same thing as your cursed 3.3's.

          Michael W

          #254775
          John Rudd
          Participant
            @johnrudd16576

            Number drill between 3.3 and 3.4 ?

            #254777
            MW
            Participant
              @mw27036

              If it persisted in that particular material, if it's not a bad drill then you could even ream to 3.3 before you tapped it if it came down to that?

              MichaeL w

              #254778
              John Haine
              Participant
                @johnhaine32865

                Where did you measure? The hole or the drill shank? The shanks are usually slightly undersized, 0.11 mm would be unusual though, mine seem to be about 1% small at that sort of size.

                #254785
                Ian P
                Participant
                  @ianp

                  It might sound patronising but to drill a hole 3.3mm diameter you need to use a 3.3mm drill!

                  Its not that simple however, standard twist drills are not precision hole cutters (although you dont need to be that precise if its a hole for tapping) and they cut holes about the nominal drill diameter.

                  The size of hole a particular drill will produce will vary with the material, speed of penetration and other factors. In your case it would seem that the drills you purchased may be wrongly marked if they are only drilling 3.19 holes (how did you measure that by the way?)

                  When you start tapping a hole you should get an immediate indication of whether the hole is undersize as the tap will need a lot more than normal of torque to turn. At that point its best to stop and review the situation rather than breaking the tap.

                  What is the material you are tapping, what is the thread? what type of tap, CS, HSS, spiral, thread forming, etc?

                  If you are working in SS, Titanium or Inconel best to have the tapping hole oversize.

                  Ian P

                  #254788
                  John Rudd
                  Participant
                    @johnrudd16576

                    Blunt tap?

                    #254791
                    Mike Brett
                    Participant
                      @mikebrett89695

                      The holes I am drilling at the moment are in brass . When I ordered the the first 3.3 mm drills and found they only drilled 3.19 mm I used those, then opened out the holes with an old drill I had that did measure 3.3 mm. This worked fine for a time but eventually the old drill has finally worn out and so I ordered another couple of drills from a different source which also only measure 3.19 mm. This is when I broke the tap, which was a M4x0.7. I have no way of measuring the holes I am drilling , but they are obviously to tight. I usually measure the drills by the shank but even so 3.3 to 3.19 seems a large difference. There must be a reliable source of drills somewhere but as yet I am still looking.

                      Mike

                      #254793
                      JasonB
                      Moderator
                        @jasonb

                        What make of drill was it? I never have problems tapping M4 into holes drille dwith a 3.3mm drill, I tend to use Dormer A002 Jobbers and A022 Stub drills

                        #254795
                        Neil Wyatt
                        Moderator
                          @neilwyatt
                          Posted by Mike Brett on 08/09/2016 15:00:28:

                          Hi

                          Can anyone tell me what size drill I need to order to drill a 3.3 mm hole. I have ordered two lots of 3.3 mm drills and although they had 3.3 stamped on the base of the drill there actual measurement was 3.19 mm. Result of this was a broken tap, help please.

                          Mike

                          If you measure the shank of a drill can be undersize. This presumably helps stop drills jamming in deep holes. You need to measure across the widest part of the flutes.

                          #254798
                          Michael Gilligan
                          Participant
                            @michaelgilligan61133

                            Mike,

                            It is fairly well known that 2-flute drills have a tendency to make tri-lobular holes [especially in thin materials] … Ian's question is therefore significant: "(how did you measure that by the way?)"

                            MichaelG.

                            #254804
                            HOWARDT
                            Participant
                              @howardt

                              A basic jobber drill at 3.3mm diameter will have a tolerance of size to -0.018mm(h8). A new correctly ground drill should give a H12 hole, 3.3/3.42 diameter. These are the sizes for named manufactured drills e.g. Dormer, Gurhing etc. If the shank is less than the marked size then suspect the drilled hole will be undersize also.

                              The shank is the same diameter as the twisted portion. Drill length should be chosen so that the flute is always clear of the hole, otherwise swarf will jam the drill. Also tap thread form should never be run in beyond the top of the hole as they will tap in both directions causing oversize thread form.

                              Howard

                              #254806
                              KWIL
                              Participant
                                @kwil

                                Buy Dormer drills from Greenwood Tools.

                                #254808
                                JA
                                Participant
                                  @ja

                                  It is a long time ago but I think I was taught to expect a drill to drill oversize. I have always worked with this in mind and piloted holes when possible. If you finish an existing hole with a slightly larger good sharp drill you should get a hole diameter corresponding to that drill (with the usual caveats – rigidity, material, material thickness, etc). Obviously use the best drills you can afford.

                                  By the way tri-lobular holes generally have a constant diameter – measure the diameter of a 50p piece.

                                  JA

                                  #254812
                                  Michael Gilligan
                                  Participant
                                    @michaelgilligan61133
                                    Posted by JA on 08/09/2016 19:32:09:

                                    By the way tri-lobular holes generally have a constant diameter – measure the diameter of a 50p piece.

                                    .

                                    That's the [w]hole point, JA, and why I mentioned the importance of Ian's question.

                                    The 'diameter' may be constant, but …

                                    < sigh > I'll leave you to look it up for yourself.

                                    MichaelG.

                                    #254813
                                    JasonB
                                    Moderator
                                      @jasonb

                                      A simple way to gauge if the drill is cutting to its nominal size or the shank size is to drill a hole and then stick the shank of the hdrill into the hole.

                                      If its a firm fit then its likely to be cutting to the shank size if its an easy fit then probably cutting to nominal size.

                                      #254814
                                      Mike Brett
                                      Participant
                                        @mikebrett89695

                                        Many thanks for all your detailed replies. I have know ordered some Dormer drills from Greenwood Tools.

                                        Cheers Mike

                                        #254815
                                        Anonymous
                                          Posted by HOWARDT on 08/09/2016 19:01:02:

                                          The shank is the same diameter as the twisted portion.

                                          Not always so. All my metric and imperial drills are within ±0.01mm of nominal size when measured at the tip, as near as I can tell. However, the shanks are 0.03mm to 0.1mm undersize, depending upon the drill size, and also taper slightly away from the tip.

                                          Andrew

                                          PS: All my metric and imperial drills are Dormer, bought new in sets

                                          #254816
                                          SillyOldDuffer
                                          Moderator
                                            @sillyoldduffer
                                            Posted by John Rudd on 08/09/2016 17:27:57:

                                            Blunt tap?

                                            That would be my guess too.

                                            When I was a total beginner I often used 3.2 and/or 1/8" holes for M4 in brass and aluminium without breaking the tap. (Now I always use at least the recommended diameter drills: a broken tap jammed in the hole isn't worth the risk.)

                                            Although delightfully cheap the tap I used with 3.2mm holes was new and sharp. I thought it was a bargain until I used it on mild steel. After tapping one hole it was hopelessly blunt.

                                            Dave

                                            #254818
                                            Ian P
                                            Participant
                                              @ianp
                                              Posted by HOWARDT on 08/09/2016 19:01:02:

                                              A basic jobber drill at 3.3mm diameter will have a tolerance of size to -0.018mm(h8). A new correctly ground drill should give a H12 hole, 3.3/3.42 diameter. These are the sizes for named manufactured drills e.g. Dormer, Gurhing etc. If the shank is less than the marked size then suspect the drilled hole will be undersize also.

                                              The shank is the same diameter as the twisted portion. Drill length should be chosen so that the flute is always clear of the hole, otherwise swarf will jam the drill. Also tap thread form should never be run in beyond the top of the hole as they will tap in both directions causing oversize thread form.

                                              Howard

                                              Howard

                                              Do you mean that a tap can cut two sizes or that the cutting portion of the tap must not go below the face of the hole?

                                              Ian P

                                              #254821
                                              john swift 1
                                              Participant
                                                @johnswift1

                                                what kind of drill bit are you using to drill into brass

                                                in the past visiting a workshop I have seen slow spiral bits used for brass or

                                                standard jobber bits with the first mm or so reground so the cutting edge had a zero degree rake

                                                John

                                                PS

                                                for brass

                                                used bits with a slightly dulled  cutting edge is better than a new bit

                                                Edited By john swift 1 on 08/09/2016 20:23:18

                                                #254822
                                                HOWARDT
                                                Participant
                                                  @howardt

                                                  A tap will cut on the way out if the threaded portion goes below the start of the hole. If you look at the Emuge catalogue, a good nights reading, they give maximum thread depths for their taps. As has been said befor in other threads full depth threads don't need to be more than one to two times the thread diameter. Softer metals require deeper threads ( depth refers to length of thread in hole not major diameter of thread).

                                                  Howard

                                                  #254823
                                                  JasonB
                                                  Moderator
                                                    @jasonb

                                                    Thats me Bu**ered then

                                                    So whats one to do if you need a thread longer than the threaded part of a tap. The 1to 2 D is OK for fixings but what if teh thread is for something else like this one that was 90mm deep

                                                    #254824
                                                    HOWARDT
                                                    Participant
                                                      @howardt

                                                      Question the design! Usually you would counterbore to reduce the thread length to keep it within design limits of the cutting tools.

                                                      Howard

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 56 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up