Microswitch accuracy

Microswitch accuracy

Home › Forums › Electronics in the Workshop › Microswitch accuracy

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #871305
    Speedy Builder5
    Participant
      @speedybuilder5

      I have an ELS from Electronicleadscrew.com and am very pleased with its capability as installed on a Boxford AUD lathe.  It has an option that I haven’t used but am keen to set up the “limit switches”.  These are usually microswitches, however they stop +or- a few thousands of an inch.  Are there such things as “precision” microswitches.

      Bob

      #871311
      JasonB
      Moderator
        @jasonb

        Not sure of that particular ELS but the one I used you set lengths by entering them in the keypad and the ELS took care of stopping in exact positions.

         

        Are the limit switches more like you get on a powerfeed and just turn the feed off if you get to the end of safe travel? Same with a CNC the limit switches are at the extremes of travel to save a crash.

        #871317
        mgnbuk
        Participant
          @mgnbuk

          Yes – from Balluff and Euchner to name two + IIRC Omron also do them.

          Available as singles or ganged as multiple switches in a common housing & used for CNC machine tools

          Used the first two mentioned & IIRC the switchpoint is repeatable to within a thou. But ….

          …. these are precision industrial items and they are not cheap. Also require the matching hardened trip dogs.

          Euchner distributor used to be in Sheffield. Catalogue on their website is “Precision and multiple limit switches” in the Downloads section.

          Balluff switches are here : https://www.balluff.com/en-gb/products/areas/A0001/groups/G0113

          If you can identify the type of switch you want they do come up on Ebay at less scary prices. IIRC the chisel point type plungers are more repeatable than the roller tip type.

          Nigel B.

          #871320
          Macolm
          Participant
            @macolm

            Look on the Honeywell website for precision microswitches. I seem to remember these are good for 0.025mm or better stability, though subject to quite a few to specific mechanical and electrical conditions to achieve this. Don’t be surprised if the cost is similar to your lead screw, though I could be wrong about that.

            #871331
            John Haine
            Participant
              @johnhaine32865

              Why would you want that precision? Limit switches are generally to prevent crashes and ordinary microswitches do the job. If you want a home switch for precise tool positioning you can make your own as I have used for the x feed on my cnc lathe for several years.

              #871337
              Clive Foster
              Participant
                @clivefoster55965

                Further to what John Haines says repeatability is generally more important than absolute accuracy for things like end point detection.

                —-

                According to Mrs Google :-

                A standard V3-size snap-action micro switch typically achieves a repeatability of roughly ± 0.01mm to ± 0.05mm (approx. ± 0.0004 to ± 0.002 inches) under well-controlled mechanical conditions, though real-world performance depends heavily on the setup.

                —

                Absolute accuracy tends to be strongly influenced by mechanical play which inevitably varies between switches so simply swopping one switch for another “the same” will give different trip points. Highly commoditised switches such as teh V3 series will show even greater variations as different makers not only have different quality standards but also do the innards a bit differently. Basic V3 units vary from around £ 0.50 to almost £ 5.00 but but the premium versions go up to £20 a pop and beyond. For example Honeywell 19M.

                —

                Mrs Google says :-

                Loose components, roller rings, or hinge pin tolerances in lever-equipped V3 switches can introduce errors typically ranging from 0.003 to 0.007 inches (0.07mm to 0.18mm) according to machine-shop user data.

                —

                In practice well controlled mechanics giving repeatable approach to the switch at the same, reasonably slow, speed every time will take up all the mechanical clearances in the same way over the same distance. Variations of less than a thou can be observed from a well made commodity V3 switch. Even the 50 pence cheapies can be surprisingly good. If you are lucky. Changing the approach speed or direction relative to the switch plunger will generally shift the absolute switching point.

                Clive

                #871341
                Speedy Builder5
                Participant
                  @speedybuilder5

                  Yes, I can set the “limit” by entering “thread length” but you know how turning goes some times, you don’t know (If you don’t have a DRO) where the saddle is at the moment.

                  So, (using the FEED option on the Boxford, NOT screw cutting) slacken off the feed clutch, engage TURNING on the ELS, select ON and feed FWD move the carriage to the stop position, move the microswitch up to the carriage until the feed screw stops and lock in position.

                  Now engage the feed clutch, select REV on the ELS and Bobs yer uncle.

                  Now imagine you are turning a long groove in a bar, have 2 micro switches (one Left the other Right ) and you could turn accurately turn up to these stops. Using these stops eliminates problems of backlash in the feed motion works.

                  Now, you can’t do that on the ELS using thread length !

                  Bob

                  #871345
                  Speedy Builder5
                  Participant
                    @speedybuilder5

                    Thanks for the info Clive, feed speeds would be slow and if I got + or – 0.002″ I would be quite happy.  I will have a look at some of my microswitches, remove the roller bits and see how they perform.

                    #871432
                    Martin Connelly
                    Participant
                      @martinconnelly55370

                      How about this, two detecting switches, one on the travel and one on the leadscrew rotation. If you can stop a leadscrew at a repeated ±0.05mm on a ∅50mm that is 0.00016 of a revolution. With a 3mm pitch that is 0.00048mm repeatability. It gets better if the diameter is greater than 50mm. I would use a single slot disk for the leadscrew and an amplified IR detector board to give a clean open/closed signal. Driving motors with a built in zero point (Z channel pulse) encoder are also a possibility.

                      Leadscrew position using hand wheel dials has long been the normal way that machinists went to a repeatable position.

                      Martin C

                      #871440
                      Speedy Builder5
                      Participant
                        @speedybuilder5

                        Thanks Martin but I think you are over thinking it.  I already have an ELS (See initial post) where I can stop the feed quite accurately using the “length of thread option”.

                        Call me whatever you like, but I wanted to use the “limit switch”  function so that I could turn between webs on a crank shaft for instance.

                        Bob

                         

                        #871447
                        HOWARDT
                        Participant
                          @howardt

                          When I used to design machinery ramp type limit switches were used as end of stroke positioning only.   Accurate positioning can only be given by rotary or linear encoders.  I always used two limit switches at each end of stroke one as a normal position and one as an over ravel position in case the first failed and then a final hard stop.  Mechanical limit switches are not a precision mechanism.

                          #871450
                          JasonB
                          Moderator
                            @jasonb

                            I think what speedy wants the microswitches are stop swithces not limit switches.

                            It would be a bit like a probe works on a CNC the moment contact is made the travel stops and by having the two you eliminate any backlash when cutting in both directions.

                            An ELS will do from a zero point to a distance but that is only good if feeding one way if you take up the backlash before setting zero unless you have ballscrews etc.

                            #871460
                            Chris Gunn
                            Participant
                              @chrisgunn36534
                              On John Haine Said:

                              Why would you want that precision? Limit switches are generally to prevent crashes and ordinary microswitches do the job. If you want a home switch for precise tool positioning you can make your own as I have used for the x feed on my cnc lathe for several years.

                              Back in the day we used the Euchner range as already mentioned for precision stopping, as part of our process, it was state of the art and all we had then that wasnt purely mechanical. We would use a second switch to prevent overuns.

                              Chris Gunn

                            Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
                            • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                            Latest Replies

                            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                            View full reply list.