Posted by Martin of Wick on 02/01/2021 19:59:24:.
…
For it to work as suggested, the likes of AliBaba would have to agree to collect tax on UK sales on behalf of HMRC. I suppose they (and others) might do this off the back of some wider trade deal long term but I cant see them rushing to fall into line just because HMRC say so. I expect AB want to protect their revenue, but the truth is, they could probably buy this entire country out of petty cash, chop it into little pieces and flush it down the pan, without blinking.
Secondly, when a purchase is made from Ali, It has been my experience that a package arrives from a relatively anonymous small reseller / sole trader and there is no obvious link to the OMP on the packaging. Are all these myriads of backroom traders somewhere in the middle of China suddenly going to feel the need to kowtow to HMRC?
I suppose HMRC could take the line that if goods turn up with a declared value but no VAT registration identifier, they would simply confiscate the goods to encourage the others…
I found the Notice quite confusing because it talks consistently about Import VAT when other government sources explain this is gone, replaced by Supply VAT. Now sellers abroad are responsible for collecting UK tax on behalf of HMRC, much as domestic sellers do.
If a UK buyer orders from abroad and the supplier doesn't cooperate, then the tax will be collected on delivery plus a handling charge. Dodging UK tax by buying abroad is made more difficult.
I think more tax will be collected and grey imports discouraged, but it will make it harder for small guys here to buy bargains from small guys abroad. Most likely, small foreign sellers will be forced to sell to the UK through an OMP who sorts out UK tax on our behalf. Could be fiendishly clever or riddled with loopholes. Quite a few advantages to government if it works and other countries may copy the system.
One thing is clear: purchasers are responsible for ensuring their suppliers collect the tax. If the tax isn't collected correctly the buyer is liable.
Dave