Recommended blow torch?

Advert

Recommended blow torch?

Home Forums Workshop Tools and Tooling Recommended blow torch?

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #345313
    jimmy b
    Participant
      @jimmyb

      I've been using a Butane/Propane mix gas blow torch, ( with EN417 thread/valve). I've been chatting to a mate and he swears buy Mapp gas.

      What are your thoughts/recommendations?

      I mainly use it for hardening and oil blacking stuff.

      Thanks Jim

      Advert
      #18871
      jimmy b
      Participant
        @jimmyb
        #345315
        Andrew Tinsley
        Participant
          @andrewtinsley63637

          I did try Mapp gas a good few years back and it was significantly better than either butane or propane. However I have oxy acetylene so it didn't get a lot of use.

          I believe that the current Mapp gas is a different formulation to what it used to be, but others may know more.

          Andrew.

          #345317
          Neil Wyatt
          Moderator
            @neilwyatt

            Consider getting a big bottle of propane and a torch/nozzle kit.

            Even with a cheap and cheerful torch set it's far ahead of a blowtorch (MAPP or otherwise) and not expensive to run (once you have got a bottle).

            #345326
            Speedy Builder5
            Participant
              @speedybuilder5

              I am with Niel, just Propane burners and get a couple of different sized nozzles, One 'Bigun' about 2" diameter and a medium one about 1" dia. Get an adjustable regulator which matches the big burner. Then have plenty of fire bricks. Even for simple jobs, one brick horizontal and a second positioned vertically will halve the time needed to heat something. If you need sometihing more serious for very large work (7 1/2 inch boiler??) consider air/propane
              BobH

              #345330
              Oldiron
              Participant
                @oldiron

                I am also with Neil on the Propane/Butane method.

                Have a look at Rob in Australia. He has quite a few videos on brazing etc with a Bulfinch torch also many no nonsense ways to do things in the home workshop :-

                **LINK**

                regards

                #345331
                Vic
                Participant
                  @vic

                  I read this years ago:

                  “In early 2008, true MAPP gas production ended in North America when production was discontinued at the only remaining plant in North America that still manufactured it. However, many current products labeled "MAPP" are, in fact, MAPP substitutes. These versions are composed almost entirely of propylene with minuscule impurities of propane (<0.5%)”

                  I wonder what the stuff we get is over here is and whether it’s any better than Propane or just more expensive?

                  #345334
                  Vic
                  Participant
                    @vic

                    Just found this for Rothenberger MAPP gas:

                    **LINK**

                    On page 2 it says it’s 50-100% Butane/25-50% Propylene.

                    #345348
                    Ed Duffner
                    Participant
                      @edduffner79357

                      I just noticed Bullfinch now a have a hydrogen/oxygen type torch. Looks interesting …and probably expensive!

                      **LINK**

                      Ed.

                      #345350
                      martin ranson 2
                      Participant
                        @martinranson2

                        To jimmy b … I have been using MAPP gas torches for many years … I have made many, many small boilers and gas tanks for boats … now I have started to make some for small railway engines … the ROTHENBERGER torches are easily available at local builders merchants, B and Q and Screwfix … I think that for the sizes I make they are fantastic … the flame will happily melt small pieces of brass and copper … so be careful.

                        I would never pretend that they would silver solder a boiler for a 5inch loco …there is plenty of temperature available but not enough quantity of general heat, if that makes sense … but for my size of work they are great … the larger of my 2 blowlamps is called a SUPER FIRE 2.

                        As regards whether it is MAPP gas or MAP gas, yes it has changed over the years … the word propylene is there on the label … the old bottles were labelled Methyl Acetylene propadeine or something similar … the new ones are not quite as hot as the old ones … I did once see a technical readout which quoted 1100 degrees instead of 1200 degrees centigrade … still fantastic for small jobs … very quick and easy to use … just be careful where you point it … the blast of heat can extend by quite a few feet.

                        martin

                        #345463
                        john carruthers
                        Participant
                          @johncarruthers46255

                          +1 for the Superfire 2.
                          I was kindly given a torch with several spare canisters of MAPP and propane.
                          It has done everything I need.

                          #345473
                          jimmy b
                          Participant
                            @jimmyb

                            Thanks for all the advice.

                            Plenty of thinking to do now!

                            Jim

                            #345497
                            martin ranson 2
                            Participant
                              @martinranson2

                              To jimmy b … don`t pick one or the other … treat yourself … eat beans on toast for the month and BUY BOTH … use one for small jobs and one for large jobs.

                              martin

                              #345519
                              not done it yet
                              Participant
                                @notdoneityet

                                “BUY BOTH’

                                Or just collect the ’hot air’ from the beans, and use that as a fuel.

                                I use a Nortel Minor and a 5l oxycon with propane. Works a treat but not too portable.

                              Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
                              • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                              Advert

                              Latest Replies

                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                              View full reply list.

                              Advert

                              Newsletter Sign-up