Myford Super 7 accuracy problems.

Advert

Myford Super 7 accuracy problems.

Home Forums Manual machine tools Myford Super 7 accuracy problems.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #297353
    Nicholas Hill
    Participant
      @nicholashill23289

      Hello,

      I am very new to this, so please excuse my silly questions…I am in the process of setting up my Super 7.

      Following the instructions in the manual, I have leveled it (using a digital level) and in both the x and z axis it is saying 0 deg of inclination.

      I then tried to turn a test piece. This came off very inaccurate. Over a length of 55mm, the chuck end was 8.45mm and the other end 8.52mm, or 1.27mm / m.

      I noticed that if I went over the piece again, although at the same setting, it removed material for the next three passes. As though it was removing more peaks.

      Any ideas?

      My thoughts are – is the work piece deflecting under the load of the tool? Hence more accurate at the rigid chuck end. I was only taking off 0.01" off, so the load would be low. The length of the work piece was about 70mm

      Or, is the machine not square?

      I have tried two types of metal – brass and EN16. The same occurs with both types of material.

      Many thanks,

      Nicholas

      Advert
      #12968
      Nicholas Hill
      Participant
        @nicholashill23289
        #297360
        John Haine
        Participant
          @johnhaine32865

          If the material is only ~8mm diameter it will be deflecting which explains some of the taper. Try some 1 inch bar.

          If by a digital level you mean one of the Wixey or similar types they have limited resolution and accuracy and will not be suitable for proper levelling. You really need a proper machinists' level.

          It's not so much level as such you are aiming at but an absence of twist in the bed, so any inclination is the same at both ends.

          #297365
          David George 1
          Participant
            @davidgeorge1

            Hi Nicholas

            Where are you based, if you live not to far from someone who has the correct tools to set up your lathe I am sure they could help. I live Nr junction 28 M1 Nottinghamshire and have a machine level etc. Or maybe someone else.

            David

            #297378
            Nicholas Hill
            Participant
              @nicholashill23289

              Hi, thanks for the replies.

              The level I have is a GemRed one. So about 40cm. I got it for this job, so I am hoping I may have been silly. It seems that the multi-function button may have confused me! The inclination being RELATIVE to the last measurement. It is too dark now, but I will try with the ABSOLUTE setting tomorrow, and see if it is out.

              Based on the advice above, I looked for a Engineers Level, and accuracy wise they are far better. Mine could be out by 3.5mm/m, while a M&W Engineers Level is accurate to 0.3mm/m.

              It seems we live in a small World. I am in Beeston, about 100 yards from the old Myford factory….I think there is a tool makers still next door, so I may be cheeky and see if I can borrow a level from them…..

              Thanks for the education, and confirming that it almost certainly bed twist. It stops me wondering about the saddle, etc. You never know what you get with second hand machines.

              Nicholas

              #297380
              Hopper
              Participant
                @hopper

                No good using an 8.5mm piece of bar for a test piece. It flexes way too much under cutting load. Like said above, you need a piece of one-inch diameter bar about six inches long to do your tests on. It saves time if you rough turn the middle four inches or so down smaller to make a dumbell shape so you do your test machining on the two end pieces only, at the same setting.

                Leveling the lathe is only a starting point, on a BRAND NEW lathe that had just come from the Myford factory where it was set up on a surface grinder and the top ways ground flat in relation to the four mounting feet on the bottom, which were sat on a dead flat surface grinder table. Leveling is merely a way to ensure that on your relatively wobbly and unflat home workshop bench, the bolted down bed is brought back to dead flat condition as it left the factory.

                However, with a used lathe, you face two problems when leveling, both related to wear on the bed ways. First is that a used lathe will usually have a thou or three (or more) wear on the top surface of the ways at the chuck end where most of the work takes place. The front way will usually be worn more than the back way, by a good few thou. So when you set your level on this worn surface, you are not setting the bed back to the condition it left the factory in, you are pulling the worn surfaces back to level, and so quite possibly putting a twist in the bed. Second is that even if you miraculously manage to get the bed levelled to the same position it left the factory in, you still have wear on the bed ways which will cause the machine to cut tapered or otherwise out of spec.

                The solution is outlined in the Myford manual, where you take test cuts over your one-inch diameter test bar, with no tailstock centre in place of course, and then further twist the bed until you get the lathe to cut dead parallel. This is done by jacking up the relevant mounting pad on the tailstock end of the bed, either by screw adjuster or shims.

                But it sound like if you are getting as close as you are with an 8mm diameter test piece, when you use the one – inch diameter test piece and eliminate flex it should be pretty durn close to perfect, indicating that you have bought a lathe in very good condition. Well done!

                Edited By Hopper on 10/05/2017 00:04:55

                #297386
                Neil Wyatt
                Moderator
                  @neilwyatt
                  Posted by Nicholas Hill on 09/05/2017 23:40:14:

                  Thanks for the education, and confirming that it almost certainly bed twist. It stops me wondering about the saddle, etc. You never know what you get with second hand machines.

                  Nicholas

                  Don't rush into changing things!

                  A 0.010" cut on 8mm bar will deflect it, even if the tool is sharp.

                  For test cuts you need something at least 3/4" and ideally 1" in diameter. The ideal tool is a sharp HSS one and taking cuts of just a couple of thou.

                  Hopper has given you excellent advice, follow it rather than trying to twist your lathe to follow a bendy workpiece!

                  Let us know how you get on with a thicker bar.

                  Neil

                  #297390
                  peak4
                  Participant
                    @peak4

                    This may well open a can of worms, but have a look at Rollie's Dad's method of lathe alignment,

                    It's essentially the same method I used, before I was even aware of it, where, in my case, I employed a 2MT test bar and a dial gauge. Because you are only using a clock gauge, there are no cutting forces to consider.

                    In my case I couldn't afford a proper certified test bar, but found a brand new, beautifully machined and ground 2MT extension sleeve for £5 from a government surplus store.

                    I used that to set up the twist in the bed, though using the screw threads on the Myford raising block, rather than sheets of paper. Because it's 2MT, I didn't even need to use a chuck.

                    I then added a 2MT stub arbour to the 2MT extension, which allowed me to set it up between centres, and was thus able to set the tailstock offset correctly.

                    When I then used the "dogbone" testpiece mentioned above, with a very light cut, everything came out closer than I could measure with a micrometer, albeit not a 10,000" one.

                    "Levelling" the lathe is advantageous, but not vital. I've no personal experience of it, but from what I can gather, it's more important with large lathes in industry where the sheer size can allow the bed to distort under its own weight, if the cast in concrete floor mounts aren't perfectly level. I this case the precision level is used across the bed, at both ends in the same way that a wood worker would use "winding sticks" to check for a twist in the workpiece.

                    #297532
                    Nicholas Hill
                    Participant
                      @nicholashill23289

                      Thank you all. Hopper raises many good points, and expalins some issues I have had. I found the saddle difficult to get to run smoothly over the whole length of the bed. As they pointed out, this is because the chuck end of the bed is a few thou more worn.

                      After going over the whole bed trying to level it with my spirit level, I tried another cut. This time on a 3/4" brass rod, about 6" long (some scrap came with the lathe). Taking a cut along 4", showed it to be still tapering. So, following the Myford method, I adjusted the tail end, and took another cut. After about 4 further cuts and adjustments, I got no deviation at all.

                      I am realising the luxury I had as a student. The lathes were always set-up for us!

                      Many thanks again, this is why i bought a machine. I want to know how it works, and how to correct it when it goes wrong.

                      Nicholas

                      #297577
                      Michael Gilligan
                      Participant
                        @michaelgilligan61133

                        Posted by Nicholas Hill on 10/05/2017 22:09:05:

                        … this is why i bought a machine. I want to know how it works, and how to correct it when it goes wrong.

                        .

                        Good attitude yes

                        MichaelG.

                        #297600
                        Hopper
                        Participant
                          @hopper

                          Well done. Happy latheing. yes

                          #297836
                          Nick Hulme
                          Participant
                            @nickhulme30114
                            Posted by Hopper on 11/05/2017 11:32:15: latheing

                            Nice one! 😀

                          Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
                          • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                          Advert

                          Latest Replies

                          Home Forums Manual machine tools Topics

                          Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                          Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                          View full reply list.

                          Advert

                          Newsletter Sign-up