Hi All,
This thread (no pun intended) started off a thought process as to the advantage of studs vs studding. I understood that studs were used to allow different threads to be used, e.g. in a cast iron or aluminium casting a coarse thread would be used, while for the fixing nut a relatively fine thread would be used – e.g BSW at casting end and BSF for the clamping nut.
The theory, as I was led to believe, is that the coarse thread was less liable to be pulled out of the weaker or brittle material while the finer thread of the nut allowed a greater clamping force for a given torque.
Hence the use of studs in models with the same thread both ends has no significant advantage, not even an aesthetic one as they cannot be seen. If aesthetics is important on early historic models surely it is more important to use square nuts as would be originally used. Strength of the stud would not be a factor as there must be extra redundant threads below the fixing nuts.
Can anyone explain what other advantage there is that I may have missed?
Best Regards
Terry
Edited By Terryd on 27/10/2012 12:04:14