An Alternative Simple Edge Finder

An Alternative Simple Edge Finder

Home › Forums › Workshop Tools and Tooling › An Alternative Simple Edge Finder

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #875347
    Macolm
    Participant
      @macolm

      The recent Beginners Questions thread about laser and electrical contact edge finding having run its course, I would like to harp back to an easy alternative that I outlined in MEW Jan 2023. A variant of the simple mechanical type, this uses a ball race as sensor. Such a feature probably dates back more than a century, and if the present device has any “inventive step” at all, it is fitting the ball race so that it can self centre, although that too may have been done long since. Using it is simple, accurate and very quick. A proviso, the mill ought to have a DRO for maximum benefit.

      SimpleTo Do

      The pictures are self-explanatory. Take a suitable edge finder, unhook the probe part and substitute the ball race, and you are good to go. I used an ordinary 606 ball race (6x17x6), so the outer radius is unfortunately 8.5mm! For a quick try, find a washer just slightly bigger than the bore of the ball race, pull out the spring, hook on and set in place. Watch your fingers on the sharp spring end, make a simple hook.

       

      In use, the finder is fitted to the mill spindle, with no need for the shaft to run precisely true. With the spindle running, as usual the ball race is fed against a face of the work then retracted, thus self-centring. When not contacting, the ball race will run at spindle speed, when fed in to contact it will stop. Now here is the good bit – at least on my setup. There is a transition point where the ball race runs at slow speed, and this only occurs at one exact reading of my 0.01mm resolution DRO. Fine positioning to this point is easy by lightly tapping the table back and forth with a hide mallet. This contact point is intuitively the “correct” one, and this can be is confirmed by taking points on either side of a reference cylinder, and doing the sums.

       

      Here are some other points. The ball race needs to be free running, a plain unshielded one is probably best, a sealed one no use at all. While a shielded one as shown reduces ingress of swarf, it also makes removal of any internal debris less easy. I expected to need to de-swarf the ball race occasionally by running it in clean paraffin. So far this has not proved necessary, though I do keep the finder carefully in a plastic pouch. My MEW article went on to discuss using the ball race finder and a reference cylinder to enable quick height changes of a round column mill. This has proved a valuable method since it can be done “retrospectively” when I find I miscalculated the headroom. It merely re-references the DRO zero, so is very quick to do.

       

      So please give it a try, and report – if you hate it, the original edge finder functionality can be quickly and fully restored. It would be valuable to know if the point of slow speed rotation always happens, or if not how it can be achieved. For example, it may be a function of the clearance in the ball race. At one time ball races were graded to select for the specific fit in the housing.

    Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

    Latest Replies

    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

    View full reply list.