Telescope recommendations?

Advert

Telescope recommendations?

Home Forums Clocks and Scientific Instruments Telescope recommendations?

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #331960
    Muzzer
    Participant
      @muzzer

      My daughter is hoping to get a better telescope for Xmas and has identified a couple of possible models around the £300 mark. At this stage she'd rather stick with manual positioning and spend her money on the scope itself – a motor system can come later.

      Can the resident star gazers offer opinions on these scopes and / or suggest alternatives in a similar price range?

      Orion SkyQuest XT8 Classic Dobsonian Telescope

      Sky-Watcher Skyliner-200P Classic Parabolic Dobsonian Telescope

      Thanks for any help!

      Murray

      Edited By Muzzer on 13/12/2017 22:40:10

      Advert
      #3781
      Muzzer
      Participant
        @muzzer
        #331965
        Mike E.
        Participant
          @mikee-85511

          A good place for information would be "Stargazers Lounge"; a friendly helpful site. I've been at this hobby for many years, but am not up to speed on current commercial offerings.

          #331980
          Rik Shaw
          Participant
            @rikshaw

            Murray – I am not deeply into astronomy but a friend who is once told me years ago that it was best if contemplating a reflector / mirrored type for hobby use to go for one of minimum 7" diameter. Maybe the more knowledgeable “gazers” around here can offer more up to date tips.

            Rik

            #331984
            john carruthers
            Participant
              @johncarruthers46255

              Are you members of your local astronomical society? If so you can 'try before you buy' by attending their public meetings to get hands on experience, and maybe borrowing one of their 'loaner' scopes to try.

              An 8" dob is a good way to start learning the sky, quick to set up, easy to use, but not easily upgraded to tracking or goto later.
              It will probably need collimating before use and checking thereafter to get the best from it.

              Bear in mind it will come with only basic eyepieces and accessories. Better eyepieces, filters etc can be acquired as you go along.

              A copy of 'Turn Left at Orion' is a sound investment with any scope and age group.

              John.

              #331986
              Neil Wyatt
              Moderator
                @neilwyatt

                If photography and GOTO is not on the agenda and you have reasonable dark skies, the Skyliner is a superb scope that will let you see very deep. I have looked through one at a reasonably dark site and the views were great, it benefits from eyepiece upgrades.

                To put those dobs on a GOTO mount will be problematic – you can buy goto dobs, but they come as a package. You would also need a mount costing much more than the scope to take the weight.

                How about this:

                http://www.firstlightoptics.com/reflectors/sky-watcher-star-discovery-150p.html

                or this:

                http://www.firstlightoptics.com/reflectors/skywatcher-explorer-130p-supatrak-auto.html

                Shorter focal length will give just as bright views and perhaps a better viewing experience but these will still be good for planets with a Barlow that multiplies the lens power. There is alifetime of viewing in objects you will see with a 130mm scope, and you can get amazing photos for up to 30-60s exposure with the alt/az tracking mounts.

                I have a 130P-DS which is a version of the 130P optimised for photography and it gives excellent views (on the one time I looked through it properly!).

                #332022
                Muzzer
                Participant
                  @muzzer

                  Thanks for those suggestions! I'll get the Turn Left at Orion book and will probably go for one of those ones Neil suggested. As a fairly inexperienced star gazer, Lara hasn't got a lot to go on, so experienced opinions are invaluable.

                  She has a reasonable DSLR, so I'm wondering about getting an adaptor for it. That would allow for the long exposures and by the sound of it a whole extra dimension would open up.

                  It's looking as if she may eventually become a professional stargazer, as she is currently on course to start a masters in astrophysics next year, once she's finished her current combined masters in mech eng for which she has already managed to get a first. No idea where she got that from!

                  Murray

                  #332053
                  Neil Wyatt
                  Moderator
                    @neilwyatt
                    Posted by Muzzer on 14/12/2017 12:32:54.

                    It's looking as if she may eventually become a professional stargazer, as she is currently on course to start a masters in astrophysics next year, once she's finished her current combined masters in mech eng for which she has already managed to get a first. No idea where she got that from!

                    Murray

                    One of the nice things about astrophysics is that many people whose professional work is desk based are also amateur observers.

                    #332071
                    Clive Brown 1
                    Participant
                      @clivebrown1

                      When I had a telescope, and that was some while ago, I got a lot of use out of "Norton's Star Atlas". As well as the good charts, I enjoyed the wealth of supplementary information that it contained, all very concisely described.

                      My 'scope came with a rather inadequate tripod. i spent much time in the workshop improving the mounting, including better angular scales to make star finding easier. Should have bought a "go-to" perhaps!

                      #332112
                      john carruthers
                      Participant
                        @johncarruthers46255

                        A humble webcam would open a whole new area of study, start with the moon (easy to find) then move on to the brighter planets.
                        A webcam and free Registax software can capture stunning planetary detail.
                        A dslr on a Dob would require a counterweight.
                        There are adapters available to hold a phone to the eyepiece for reasonable photos.

                        Loads of free planetaria programmes around for all the common platforms.
                        I'm a bit of a dinosaur and still use HNsky, but Sky Safari is versatile and runs on a phone.
                        Stellarium is another well known planetarium.

                        #332119
                        Neil Wyatt
                        Moderator
                          @neilwyatt

                          +1 for Stellarium, but also +1 for the suggestion of visiting/asking on Stargazer's Lounge.

                          Neil

                        Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
                        • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                        Advert

                        Latest Replies

                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                        Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                        View full reply list.

                        Advert

                        Newsletter Sign-up