Forum Etiquette,. Specific’s, and jumping in.

Forum Etiquette,. Specific’s, and jumping in.

Home Forums General Questions Forum Etiquette,. Specific’s, and jumping in.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #24758
    Raymond Anderson
    Participant
      @raymondanderson34407
      #257642
      Raymond Anderson
      Participant
        @raymondanderson34407

        In light of the debacle that has[d ] become the ER thread.[ hopefully all is clearer now ]. I will say here and now that I am sometimes not specific enough in my meanings. I will try to be more specific in future. Also, it does not help clarity when fellow members just "jump in " to a thread before they have read all the posts. The amount of threads that have been pulled and twisted and fired off at tangents through " jumping in " is high.. It only leads to confusion, arguments, and toys being thrown. Many of us, and yes, including me . need to learn how to argue their point of view in an sensible adult way. and although i'm never the one to cast the first stone, i'm not whiter than white.

        There is room for all opinions, and we all have the capacity to argue them in a constructive, adult fashion. nuff said.

        cheers

        #257655
        Clive Foster
        Participant
          @clivefoster55965

          I've always felt that forum discussions, wherever they are and whatever the topic, have much in common with barside discussions in pubs and suchlike watering holes. The longer they go on for the more convoluted they become and, usually for well established ones, the more folk join in. Not having been there from the beginning late arrivals usually fail to get the context and, in pub equivalent terms, rarely experience more than the forum equivalent of half a pints worth of natter (is that one page or two) before joining in. Generally speaking forum discussions tend not to run on that long unless new folk jump in or the thing goes off at tangent. In general folk don't jump in unless they have pretty strong views which more or less guarantees heat, light and dust.

          Is there a forum driven equivalent to getting half, or more, cut? That would explain a lot.

          Clive

          Who has views on the ER system but wisely stayed silent.

          #257658
          Frances IoM
          Participant
            @francesiom58905

            Personally I don’t think online forums debating highly specific technical points can ever work unless all contributions are moderated – being an retired academic who has seen (and been involved in a few) vigorous debates my observation is that the key requirement is a good chair to whom as in all formal debates contributions, requests for clarification etc are addressed – an open non or badly moderated forum rapidly descends to the chaos of multiple threads unless the impossible happens and contributors self control to an impossible degree.

            ETA that obviously the bar chat type forum can provide some info, amusement and enjoyment but the highly technical single topic debate needs the control as mentioned.

            Edited By Frances IoM on 24/09/2016 16:16:50

            #257664
            MW
            Participant
              @mw27036

              I dont think anyone can approach a forum discussion in a robotic fashion. Can't we all accept that we aren't encyclopedias and you're not going to garner "hard and fast" information. It's like a whingey kid wanting to get everything good from something without any of the bad consequences of debating, you've got to wade in.

              It's a typical synergy and fastfood culture of effeciency to want positive information without any of the idiosyncracies of what makes us human. If it really lived up to that we'd all be complaining how fake everything sounded.

              Having said that, personal insults should remain outside, that i agree on.

              Michael W

              Edited By Michael Walters on 24/09/2016 16:24:47

            Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
            • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

            Latest Replies

            Home Forums General Questions Topics

            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

            View full reply list.