
The one on the right, and the ratchet are mine, so a good 35 years old, the two Yankee's on the left were my Dad's, so they will be even older.
The one on the right has an Ash handle, which I made, as the original one came loose and started started revolving.
The colour on the ratchet is a shade darker than that on the Yankee. The Yankee colour looks similar to original Red Oxide paint. Although most of the coloured finish has gone, there still appears to be a clear gloss finish left. My best guess is they put a clear coat on before the colour coat, which may explain why the colour coat does not stay on.
We did have a much smaller Yankee type with a black handle, and a burgundy plastic handled ratchet, I can't find them 'tho, or maybe another family member has them.
These people **Chestnut** do a very good Black Ebonising Stain, an a Black Ebonising Aerosol, if you are going to do them black.
I totally agree with your reasoning, and shed memories. Having done similar to some of my Dad's tools.