Posted by Chris TickTock on 29/08/2019 08:46:07:
Some good posts here and Johns LINK is super good and useful. As the intent is to improve my lathe skills whilst making something useful I may go for something else.
Chris
Depends why you're making it. Although a small screw-jack isn't particularly useful in itself, making one will stretch your skills in new directions. For example, it will teach you more about threads than buying a Whitworth gauge and asking what it's for.
If you wanted a punch for practical reasons, the quickest way to get a good one is to buy it. Chances are shop-bought will be better and cheaper than a home-made version. However, there's an excellent reason for making your own, which is the value gained learning how to do it. Actually cutting metal gives the operator a sense of what his machine can and cannot do, exposes problems you didn't notice in the book, and teaches the characteristics of materials, cutters and more. It's about problem solving and technique.
Apprentices used to be set to file steel into one inch cubes. The finished cubes were useless and of course could be made in a lathe or milling machine in a fraction of the time. But the point wasn't producing cubes, it was to develope manual filing skills for real use later. In the early stages of fun-with-metal, learning how to make things is more valuable than the object itself. Nice if you can combine learning with making a useful tool, but I found new challenges more useful than simply making stuff.
Dave